Custom Cake Cakery

Cupcakes

XL Single Cupcake

Single cupcake of choice.
$4.00
4 XL Cupcake

4 extra large cupcake of your choice.
$16.50
6 XL Cupcake

6 extra large cupcake of your choice.
$24.50
Dozen XL Cupcake

Extra large. 12 cupcakes of your choice.
$45.00
XL Baker's 4 Count

Baker's choice of 4 count of cupcakes. No special request will be honored.
$15.00
XL Baker's 6 Count

Baker's choice of 6 count of cupcakes. No special request will be honored.
$20.00
XL Baker's Dozen

Baker's choice of a dozen xl cupcakes no special request will be honored.
$40.00

Banana Pudding & Cake Bowls

Large Banana Pudding Bowl

Our signature banana pudding, fresh organic banana chunks and topped with whip crme and wafer crumbles.
$10.00
Small Banana Pudding Bowl

Our signature banana pudding, fresh organic banana chunks and topped with whip crme and wafer crumbles.
$7.00
Large Salted Caramel Banana Pudding Bowl

Our signature banana pudding, fresh organic banana chunks, drizzled salted caramel and topped with whip crme, more drizzle and wafer crumbles.
$10.00
Small Cookie Pudding Bowl

Our signature banana pudding, no banana chunks layered with whip crme and wafer crumbles.
$6.00
Strawberry Crunch Banana Pudding Bowl

Our signature banana pudding, fresh organic banana/strawberry chunks, strawberry crunch topping with whip crme and more strawberry crunch.
$10.50
Signature Bread Pudding

1 serving of our signature bread pudding drizzled caramel sauce. Contains raisins and pecans.
$6.00
Banana Cream Pudding

10 oz container Our signature banana pudding but with a twist. Layers of crumbled vanilla wafer, whipped cream and banana cream custard with chunks of bananas.
$7.00
Punch Bowl Cake Bowl

Layers of our crumble scratch vanilla cake, with whipped cream and strawberry or cherry compote.
$8.00

Breads

Banana Bread- Mini Loaf

Our original moist recipe.
$5.00
Pumpkin Bread- Mini Loaf

Our moist pumpkin bread made from scratch.
$5.00
Gingerbread Loaf

Perfectly moist spiced gingerbread loaf.
$5.00
Iced Banana Bread

Banana Bread baked in a single serve pan and topped with our signature cinnamon spiced cream cheese icing.
$4.00

Brownies, Cookies & More

Cake Scraps

Variety of cake flavors from our cake carvings from the current day. You can select with or without buttercream.
$3.00
Tray Bake Cakes

Choose your preferred flavor of tray bake cake. Individual-sized cakes baked in a disposable aluminum pan.
$4.50
Chocolate Fudge Brownie

Classic slice of our chocolate fudge brownie.
$4.00
Sweet Potato Pie

1 scratch made signature sweet potato pie in a pie box.
$28.00
Mini Sweet Potato Pies

2 servings of our signature scratch made sweet potato pie.
$5.50

Cake Jars

Cake Jar

Layers of crumbled cake, buttercream, and added toppings/fillings/sprinkles.
$10.00
German Chocolate Cake Jar

Layers of crumbled chocolate cake, layered with coconut frosting and fudgy chocolate buttercream.
$10.00
Lemon

Layers of crumbled lemon cake and lemon buttercream.
$10.00
Strawberry Vanilla Swirl Jar

Layers of crumbled strawberry and vanilla cake and our vanilla and strawberry buttercream.
$10.00
Banana Bread Jar

Crumbled moist banana bread layered with a cinnamon spice buttercream.
$10.00
Patriotic Chocolate Sprinkled Jar

Layers of crumbled chocolate cake with creamy chocolate fudge buttercream and festive red, white, and blue sprinkle mix.
$8.00
Rainbow Cake Jar

7 layers of vanilla rainbow-colored cake crumbles layered with vanilla buttercream and topped off with festive rainbow sprinkles.
$10.00
Patriotic Vanilla Sprinkled Jar

Layers of crumbled vanilla cake with creamy vanilla buttercream and festive red, white, and blue sprinkle mix.
$8.00
Vanilla Red, White & Blue Jar

Crumbled layers of vanilla red, white and blue cake with vanilla buttercream.
$8.00

Sliced Desserts

Cake Slices

1 sliced serving
$6.00
Sugar Free Cheesecake Slices

2 slice serving
$7.50
Cheesecake Slice

single slice serving with your choice of topping
$7.00

Buttercream Cake

8 in Dessert Cakes

Pick and choose from a variety of readymade dessert cakes prepared daily here at the cakery. Serves 8-12.
$65.00
6 in Dessert Cakes

Pick and choose from a variety of readymade dessert cakes prepared daily here at the cakery. Serves 6-8.
$45.00

Drinks

Tropical Fruit Lemonade

Our signature made lemonade bottle and prepared here at the cakery. -mixed with fresh tropical fruit puree.
$4.00
Passion Fruit Lemonade

Our signature made lemonade bottle and prepared here at the cakery. -mixed with fresh passion fruit puree.
$4.00
Aquafina

Pure, refreshing still water.
$2.00
Honest Juice Box

Apple juice, grape, fruit punch order will be offered based on availability
$3.00
Orange Fanta Soda Can

Bright and bubbly orange-flavored soda, offering a refreshing citrus taste in every sip.
$2.50
Chocolate Nesquik Milk
$3.50
Grape Crush Soda Can
$2.50
Strawberry Nesquik Milk
$3.50
S Pellegrino Sparkling Water

Effervescent mineral water with a crisp, refreshing taste.
$4.00
Tropicana Apple Juice, 10 oz.
$4.00
Sunkist Berry Lemonade, 12 oz. Can
$2.50
Peach Crush, 12 oz. Can
$2.50
Mountain Dew Star Spangled Splash, 12 oz. Can
$2.50
Mountain Dew Liberty Chill, 12 oz. Can
$2.50
Blue Coconut Lemonade

Our signature made lemonade bottle and prepared here at the cakery. -mixed with blue coconut puree.
$4.00
Sprite Soda Can

Sprite soda in a can. option for ghost energy drink in mango or sour patch kid's blue raspberry flavor.
$2.50
Lemonade

Our signature made lemonade bottle and prepared here at the cakery.
$4.00
Sunkist Cherry Limeade Soda, 12 oz. Can
$2.50
Sunkist Mango Orange 12 oz. Can
$2.50
Sunkist Watermelon Lemonade 12 oz. Can
$2.50

a purple and white cake

a woman holding a cake

a birthday cake in a box

a bouquet of roses in a vase

interior

a cake in a box

interior

Perfection!

Cherry cupcake is official. Has real pieces of cherries inside the cupcake.

food

Their fresh cookies

Check the real pieces of cherries inside.

interior

a hand holding a jar of cake

a chocolate cupcake on a white plate

a strawberry on a plate

a dessert with sprinkles

food

Joanna W.

★★★★★

Dec 22, 2024

Would I recommend Custom Cake Cakery? Yes, a million times yes. I ordered their full sheet number cake for my husband's 40th, and it turned out better than I could've ever hoped. I wanted to use my husband's photos and they ran with it, and the results were stellar. I was absolutely speechless.The cake (1 chocolate and 1 red velvet) was fluffy with the perfect amount of sweetness. The frosting and Bavarian creme were superb!