Cosmo's Pizzeria Southern Shores at the Market Place

My boyfriend and his family have been coming here for over 10 years, this is my second year coming and it doesn't disappoint! Food is yummy and service is always great!

Open on Monday and Tuesday!My family loves Pizza Stop and were devastated to find out that they were closed on Tuesday until they bit into Cosmos's New York style pizza! Thin and well seasoned with a chewy crust. We highly recommend the Margherita. Tip: If you order the pickles to-go, remove the ranch from the box. It may spill.

This place was recommended to me by my grandma who lives close by and she has good taste! Pizza was delish, cheese curds were good, pickle chips were soggy (which can kinda be expected from a to go order) staff was very nice. My only recommendation is to call way ahead because the wait times in the summer are a doozy. I waited an hour for my food... but that's how you know it's good ;)

Ordered the Philly cheesesteak pizza and it was ready about an hour later, cost about $20 for a medium, it was good, barely taste the banana peppers and it was greasy. Overall it was okay, still looking for a good pizza place in the OBX...

Pizza was great. Light chewy crust, pizza sauce had good flavor. Would get it again! We got the Margherita pizza and a cheese pizza.

Love love the food!!!! Great staff! The margarita pizza is everything!!! Love this pizza gem!

We took home pizza and a salad and we all enjoyed it (both kids and adults) - perfect for families.

Not NY style. Crust too dense, thick and chewy to be considered NY style pizza. Not the same as I remember eating from 2 years ago. Maybe the dough recipe changed. Won't be back

Every pizza we have tried arrives with SKIMPY toppings! They are so CHEAP while charging you good for pizza. Pizza is made with flour, cheese and tomato sauce all relatively inexpensive! They can afford to put more toppings like other great pizzerias! Not ordering here again. Shameful!

The way Owen spins that dough back there in the kitchen demonstrates true artistry. Cam is also a true beauty in the dough deparHe is truly inspiring. The restaurant atmosphere is electric and the food is impeccable.