Cosmos Pizza
Cosmos Pizza
Half and Half Specialty Pies Fig & Crab
This pizza is sooo good! Hospitality is top notch. Bartender is awesome.
Exterior
Mozzarella Sticks
Margarita Specialty Pie - small
pizza
interior
food, pizza
Classic!!
food, pizza
One Love pizza. Crying of joy. Pittsburgh dreams of producing this
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Large Pizza 16"
White Specialty Pie - Small
Grimlock likes pizza!
Hot and Spicy (5/5)
Build Your Own Pie - Large Pizza
Key lime pie
Supreme Pizza
Allison's salad with the chicken mysteriously missing
Rome Sandwich - Regular
Meatball Parm Sub - Regular
Garlic Knots
Great way to start the evening!
Sarah S.
Oct 31, 2024
We visited Cosmos while staying in Corolla on a recommendation & are glad we did. While it's not quite NY pizza crust the flavor was good and the options were enjoyable. Also, always appreciate when we can split a pizza by having sized to both our different preferences. Enjoyed the drink options as well. Additional the staff was friendly and helpful. If this place was close by I suspect we would frequent visitors. Hubs even decided to get a T-shirt .
Read More
Barb B.
Oct 17, 2024
Had to stray from our usual pizza option due to hours being different in the off season, but it brought us to Cosmo's which ended up being a nice surprise! We ordered two large pizzas and wings for carry out. The food was ready within 15 minutes, hot and fresh. Pizza was yummy with a really great sourdough chewy crust, toppings were fresh and flavorful, wings were large and tasty as well. Overall, this was a win and a nice discovery after coming to the area for 30+ years. We will be back!
Read More
Amber G.
Oct 11, 2024
Tried subs today! So full. Got the Rome and meatball parm. I think we loved the pizza more. But the subs were outstanding.Got some key lime pie and my husband about fell out his seat it's so good
Read More
MeeMaw V.
Dec 14, 2024
This one is hard. The pizza itself is not bad and has good flavor. The issue is the price. You get very little for what you pay for. A small White pizza (smaller than the size of a dinner plate) is $18.89. The same with the Margarita Pizza for $19.89. The mozzarella sticks are average sized and you get six for $8.99. Overall, the food is good and the location of it is very convenient, but the price makes us hesitant to return.
Read More
Thi H.
Jul 18, 2024
We ordered pizza for carry out while vacationing in Corolla. Highly recommend this place. The pizza came out perfect. The dough was soft and they were not cheap with the toppings. We ordered the Supreme Pizza and traded the black olives for pineapple. We also customized a pizza and ordered a pepperoni pizza with banana peppers and bacon.
Read More
Kimberley P.
Sep 14, 2024
We are officially in the off season now and we still can't get it right. We ordered pizza, mozzarella sticks, and an Allison's salad. The salad was supposed to have grilled chicken, but it didn't. I don't want to drive all the way back for this. As I was leaving there was a guy who picked up an order of french fries and I said "oh, the fries are THAT good that you'd just order fries?!" And he said "nope, they forgot them when I ordered earlier." Yeah, they're not that busy. Oh and the pizza isn't good. So don't bother.
Read More
Steven G.
Aug 8, 2024
Always order from here when in Corolla, OBX. My go to is the Corolla Classic large pie. Sauce is awesome and the spices are great. Loaded slice but not too much. I mostly do take out but they have a great bar with lots on tap. Cool place inside and they have outdoor seating if you want. Be prepared to wait on busier nights (weekends).
Read More
Clyde E.
Sep 21, 2023
Really cool spot.The food is definitely worth it. The pizza was our favorite. Self serve beverages. Staff is a little rough around the edges, but they get the job done.Cash discount too! We liked it so much we ate here twice in a week.
Read More
Vito S.
Aug 23, 2023
Ordered a large 16 inch cheese pizza to go for lunch at the counter for the family. The counter lady was on her earbuds having a conversation about her relationship problems as soon tand took her multiple attempts to take my order. It took the restaurant about 25 minutes to crank it out. They have a dining room with a bar area for a cocktail if that's your fancy. Pizza toppings are $3 dollars each. THEY DO NOT SERVE SLICES!The pizza dough was very doughy/chewy and not a crispy as I would have liked. The sauce was extremely bland. It is similar to a dominos or a Papa John's style but not as flavorful. It's definitely not the pizza we are blessed to have in the NYC Metropolitan area. The hunt continues for good pizza on the OBX
Read More
Ebram R.
Feb 2, 2025
Stellar pizza. Feels very homey and welcoming. The bartender should be a comedian. What's up trox
Read More
