a box of cookies
a dozen cookies in a box
a cookie and a cookie face
Cookies
a stack of cookies on a cake plate
food
6 pack
food
food
a display of cookies
a shark eating a cookie
Lydia C.
Jul 28, 2024
Delicious cookies and super sweet owners! My husband and a couple of friends enjoyed the cookies so much that we even returned back to the Cookie Shack to take some cookies home on the last day of our OBX vacation. My favorite cookie was the Cookie Monster which was really cute with the Cookie Monster having a mini cookie in his mouth. I also enjoyed the red velvet and Oreo and my husband enjoyed the pumpkin and peanut butter cookies. All the cookies had a good chewy texture and were not overly sweet or thick. The cookies are room temperature and they're still good that way, but I preferred to warm them up a little when we got home. The owners also kindly gave us a free lemon drop cookie since we ordered a half dozen!
Read More
Marie S.
Jun 15, 2024
Cookies are really good- I enjoyed the lemon drop cookie it was soft and chewy had great flavor.The other cookies were really nice to look at - most had chocolate or cream frosting (which I cannot have) My husband really enjoyed the peanut butter cookie. He said not a lot of peanut butter flavor but the texture was great.We got to meet the owners - they are super friendly and helpful!
Read More
Caroline J.
Aug 20, 2023
This place knows how to market! Was next door trying out the beers at Lost Colony and they bring over some cookies from the shack and encourage patrons to try a sample. They were delicious so on our way out we stopped to pick up some cookies for ourselves. We got a 6 pack and the owners were sweet to throw in two extras for us to try. They were extremely helpful with explaining all the cookies they had available. You can tell that they love what they do. The cookies are delicious and I highly recommend grabbing some cookies here during your trip or if you live locally in the area.
Read More
Spencer Y.
Jul 5, 2024
Local mom and pop shop with super friendly owners. The cookies really hit it home with homemade style cookies. They taste just like how a mom would bake them. My personal favorite is the pumpkin with the cream cheese frosting. Would highly recommend for anyone in the area of obx with a cookie sweet tooth.
Read More
Kim H.
Aug 17, 2024
The cookies are absolutely delightful. Fantastic service. Great selection. Will be going back for sure.
Read More
Maddi H.
Jul 30, 2024
Wonderful cookies and amazing service!! Don and Larry are incredible people, super friendly. The cookies were warm and a delicious treat to share. Would've included a picture, but the cookies were eaten before I could grab my phone. Highly recommend the cookies and cream and pumpkin cookies. If you're looking for a yummy treat, give this place a try!
Read More
Caitlin B.
Jul 23, 2024
So so kind and amazing cookies. Especially the chocolate chip we got for free. Totally amazing skilled people. Hidden gem!!
Read More
Bryan C.
Jun 18, 2024
Amazing cookies super friendly people great atmosphere :) will be back to try more flavors
Read More
Kali M.
Aug 21, 2023
Went in this evening to try some cookies and the owners were extremely nice. Informed us on all the flavors and we were even fortunate enough to catch a fresh batch right out of the oven. Would 100% recommend. These cookies were so tasty!
Read More
Kelly G.
Jul 4, 2023
Some of the best cookies I've ever had in my life! Fresh baked and incredibly delicious. Still working my way through trying all the flavors but so far my #1 fav is the strawberry shortcake cookie. The owners are so friendly and helpful too. Don't miss this place when in the OBX!
Read More