Dessert Garlic Knots (Like mini cinnamon rolls)
Cheese curds
Beers on tap
Front page of the menu, and the qr code on the napkins dispenser for the beer list!
Bar settings and my Pepsi drink
Chicken Philly
a table and chairs in a restaurant
interior, salads
Artisan Pizza
The vibe might be "divey" but it's definitely a vibe
interior
Poutine topped with Brisket
Olive pits left on our pizza! This was on my fiancé's plate. I also had to spit out a pit on one of my slices!
Philly
"Fog Horn Leg Horn" Fried chicken sandwich. (Had the chicken tossed in spicy garlic sauce.)
interior
Highly recommend. The pizza was so good, I had to leave a positive review before the food coma set in. New Yorker Pizza Special
18 inch cheese with pepperoni
Big ass slice of onion on pizza
Triple Decker Club Sandwich
Grilled Chicken and Pesto Sandwich
Five cheese pizza
food, pizza
Shella Y.
Feb 25, 2025
The service here is the greatest! I'm visiting the area and I needed late night pizza. I can tell you within 60 seconds of entering this establishment that Morgan and Bobby are employees who provide outstanding service to the community! It is refreshing to have this type of experience now days as its usually lost in translation with this generation! I hope they are getting paid their worth! This can easily be my go to happy hour if I lived here! Pizza was delicious!There was another bartender last night that was absolutely disgusting, he could have ruined this review but because the other two employees treated me so wonderful, he was eliminated from this review. He should be working the back and not at the bar with his attitude though....
Read More
Vanessa A.
Dec 23, 2024
Pros: this place is open til 2AM. Has a good variety of pizza and appetizer options and a build-your-own. You get a hot pizza even if you show up late at night. The wait staff are nice. And they come with a bar, if you're feeling a drink too. They have outdoor seating that is heated in the winter seasons. And the place is equipped with TVs to watch sports. I've been to Cogan's before (twice). And in all the times I've gone I've had a pizza every time. Since I'm no pizza connoisseur, I can say that at least for the likes of me, the pizza is alright and tasty enough to eat. Though I reckon pizza afficionados might have a lot to nitpick.Cons: Typically the environment can get quite crowded. Since it's a pizza/bar, it can get packed and loud especially on the weekends and late at night. It was also incredibly loud not because there were a lot of people but because a staff member behind the bar was yelling his lungs out reacting to a football game. Since the restaurant only had a few customers, his voice stood out and at times it was incredibly startling and piercing considering how loud the music already was. I typically would not mark off for this considering that this place is made to be loud and lively, but if you're somehow sound sensitive, this might not be the place for you.The waters we got had a musty aftertaste, and we couldn't tell if it was from the water source or the cups themselves. Surprisingly, even though I'm not picky with my pizzas, I had a bone to pick with their pizza today. We ordered the Pirate's Booty, described to contain the ff ingredients: "Pepperoni, ground sausage, salami, green peppers, red onions, black olives, mushrooms, extra sauce and extra cheese - ARGH!" So tell me why my fiancé ate a whole clove of garlic? Not just that, he also ate tooth-breaking, hard as rocks black olive pits added as toppings to our pizza as shown in the below pictures. This is incredibly dangerous for people with brittle teeth so proceed with caution if you plan ordering any pizzas with olives here. I also noticed the veggie toppings were definitely added after the dough was baked with the sauce and some meats. There was no char to them so we had raw onions and peppers. They didn't even melt into the cheese and it was a pain to eat. Not to mention the pizza was also really wet. Not a greasy good kind, but watery bad kind. I even had multiple layers of big onion slices slapped on my pizza slice. And the mushrooms were definitely old. Some of them had a fishy after-taste and you can see the blemishes on them.We may have just been really unlucky tonight!
Read More
Kaylee V.
Oct 14, 2024
Second time eating here. Got the mediterranean pizza and they did not skimp on the toppings. I think the crust is some of the best around, nice and airy (not too thick or thin). Service was nice, they did take awhile to get menus and drinks out. Place is on a corner and has super chill vibes.
Read More
Michael P.
Mar 2, 2025
Excellent service and great food and reasonable prices friendly staff and great music
Read More
Marianna F.
Mar 21, 2024
Funky dive bar atmosphere with covered outdoor seating. Looked pretty dirty. Menu had an adequate selection of pizzas but you had to order the 18 inch to get Neapolitan crust. The smaller size was cracker thin crust. We ordered one Margherita and one cheese and I added pepperoni. The Margherita had large chunks of tomato and whole cloves of garlic. The sauce on the cheese pizza was spicy which we should have been told about in advance. The taste overall was good though and the crust was delicious.Sorry. Probably won't be back.
Read More
Megan M.
Aug 31, 2024
Went here with a group of friends on a week night and the food was way better than I expected. We got a couple of sandwiches in addition to pizza, the pesto mozzarella was my favorite. Our waitress was very kind and helpful, but we did have to move tables while in the middle of eating our dinner so they could set up karaoke, but she was very apologetic about it and offered to carry everything for us.
Read More
Jonathan B.
Dec 7, 2024
Great pizza. I really enjoyed the Buffalo pizza and the New Yorker. I ordered delivery and it arrived quickly and it was still warm.
Read More
Liberty G.
Jan 26, 2023
This place has dollar slices from 4 pm to 7 pm. The pizza taste like tasty frozen pizza. I know the pizza here is fresh but the flavors were not there. The tomato sauce tasted store bought, too much cheese and the dough just tasted like regular fast food pizza crust. This place has a lot of drinks, and the service is good. Only street parking.
Read More
Aeric S.
Feb 26, 2025
Cogans has been my go to spot for years. Idk what happened but my pizza was soupy in spots where the crust disintegrated in the middle. I'm hoping it was just an off night and maybe the pizza tray was lop sided. Service was great still. Hostile environment though. People were not great this time for some reason while just trying to play pool. Place is great overall hope it was just an off day!
Read More
Katie R.
Jan 19, 2025
Cogans Is an amazing bar/pizza place my boyfriend and I love going whenever I spend weekends with him the atmosphere is amazing and so are the drinks!!
Read More