Benny Tesoro’s

Pizza was good. We love the Benny pizzas and this one was lacking a little. Huge slices and great toppings. They were closing and made fresh for us. Gave us a couple free slices but but them all on plates and stacked on top of each other. When we got home all the cheese and toppings stuck to the plates so all we had was dough. 2 very young employees and they probably did not know better.

We came here while visiting OBX and only picked it because we had a coupon and it's next to the brewery. The pizza was good but not outstanding, they left a lot of crust on the edges. The biggest pizza is quite large though, it fed 8 of us and we still had two pieces leftover. The default slices are pretty large, but they will cut them smaller if you ask. They don't serve anything else, but they do have a cooler of drinks that you can purchase from.

We had a group of 6 kids and 6 adults. We got two 28" and had 2 pieces left. Great pie. Sauce was really good and the crust was perfect. And yes, it was cooked all the way through even in the middle.

It was pretty good!Some people have given this place bad reviews and I don't think that's appropriate.We've tried the pizza from Bennys before, but not this specific one.I'm ordered two slices.Customer service was okay. Dining area was a little messy, but it wasn't a dealbreaker:Cheese slices are $5.50, canned drinks are $1.50.Them slices be huge.

We recently dined here and found the pizza to be decent, though not exceptional. The size was quite large, to the point that it required two paper plates to manage, which felt a bit impractical.

Didn't even realize there were so many locations but love the one in Charlotte so stopped by here for lunch and had our usual

Great Pizza (and I grew up in New York)...And the best and most friendly staff.What a view of Pamlico Soundand Lost Colony Brewery's Beer Garden is next door.

The pizza was huge and delicious, this will feed 20 people easily, service was great and view of sound was amazing, one slice is enough to feed my wife and I, we will be back.

We ordered the $50 pepperoni pizza. We thought it would be as great as the other Benny's pizza in Virginia. The pizza was paper thin in the middle two inches from the crust. The cheese was cold and congealed. We had called in the order and picked it up since we live 5 minutes away. The pizza we got evidently was a pizza that had been sitting on their cart for people to order slices from. The staff there were rude and argumentative. We will never ever ever ever order from there again. The Pizza Hut in Manteo has always been great but we thought we would try Benny's since we prefer real yeast raised crust.

Finally stopped in to try pizza here. The slices are huge and delicious! Definitely plan on ordering a whole pie when we have company this summer. So glad we finally tried it.