204 Pizza

Came in Christmas Eve since we got turned away from Repeal next door since they closed early. We're the only people in the place, which is small but nicely decorated. Service was friendly, and the menu is pork-free which I wasn't expecting. Got a cheese and a supreme pizza and a few waters. Asked for the pizza well done, and it was about a billion degrees coming out of the oven! Crust was nice and crispy, didn't fold with all the toppings on it which was nice. Overall the pizza was solid and it's a great spot just a few blocks from the house. Will definitely come back!

Frozen pizza would have been a better choice. The layout is nice. Great outdoor seating area; nice, tight indoor area. Everything you want from your local pizza shop. Not much space for anything but making pizza. Other yelpers' comments about the people being rude; meh. They were just doing business. Not everyone needs to smile and pretend to be your friend. It was promising. But man, the pizza was bad. We ordered the meat lovers. The crust was hard and flavorless. The sauce was watery and flavorless. The cheese was run-of-the-mill cheese. My first bite, and I immediately compared it to Matey's in my mind. Just not good pizza. We were starving and I only ate 2 slices. My toddler loves pizza so much that he has a pizza dance and he only ate 1 slice. When my kid went to the bathroom later on, lemme say it without detail, that was the worst smell that's ever come out of him. My skin broke out bad. I didn't connect all the dots until the first time I went to the restroom after that meal and had the same experience. It was horrible. I attribute that to ingredient quality. I don't know what else to say, but I will not eat there again.

Ordered the deluxe pizza and garlic knots to go. The pizza was good, the garlic knots were better. I enjoyed the red sauce that came with the garlic knots. I appreciate that they are opened late. I would say they had great value for their food considering their prices were good.

Pizza was terrible - 4.5 rating clearly left by people who eat shit for dinner. Pizza was tasteless. Got a whole pie and we each (2 of us) ate one slice and threw the rest in the trash! Please stop telling people this is NY pizza. Horrible

Avoid! Avoid! Avoid! Pizza maker couldn't be more rude and slow. Pizza is eh at best. Place is kinda clean, but can do so much better at the oceanfront. Look elsewhere

Food: We ordered pizza it was good only complaint my daughter's slice had hair in it. Their cheese fries with beef bacon was amazing. Service: The delivery was speedy. Side note: I love the no pork menu

Ordered a pizza at 12 . It never came . The lady on the phone said she has to ask her boss if I can cancel the charge for a pizza they didn't deliver . A big waste of time . They pizza was good last time I was here but the service SUCKS.

WOW! The best pizza I've ever had. I highly recommend the deluxe large. Thin crust and cooked just right. Good foldable NY pizza. The Greek salad is also 5 stars!

Man this is the best place to go on any occasion a bit pricey but worth your buck I personally bought a whole pizza and I think that's where it's worth it Vs the slice because it was hot fresh and delicious. Not really a pizza girl here but I will be back the pizza was light and thin I just loved it . Indoor and outdoor seating .. it was late so the service was as good as it was gonna get before closing they were very friendly

My favorite pizza place guess they are closed bc we never got our pizza after 2 hours so had to cancel. Hope they were just on vacay