Vinny's New York Pizza

Great slices and they're cheap. Ordered a whole pizza the second time and it was good but a lil bit too greedy for me and I like cheesy greedy pizza. Definitely go again.

We hit Vinny's New York Pizza recently before a show at the Fox Theatre, with my son and his uncle. As a native New Yorker I'm always keen to try NY pizza in Atlanta... good news and not-so-good news on that front. Staff was SUPER friendly and kind, which is always appreciated and refreshing. The place looked like a hippster, NYC dive-joint, which was, to me, also on point.The pizza itself, although quite tasty and enjoyable, wasn't really evocative of New York--sauce was a bit too sweet and the dough wasn't thin enough. NYC 'za is foldable goodness with zingy tomato sauce, and Vinny's was thicker than average. on a brighter note, Uncle and I had a side salad, which was surprisingly good! we had the balsamic dressing and I would order that again in a heartbeat. thanks for a fun time and good food!

Last minute dinner and most places we usually order from were closed, thank goodness! Meatballs were a great value, delicious, and made me happy dance. Pizza was perfect and love the crust crunch. Will definitely order again.

As a native New Yorker I can confirm that the pizza at this location (860 Peachtree St., Midtown, GA) tastes exactly like NY pizza!First bite took me back to BKNY!!

Clean, bright place; looks newly renovated. Friendly, personable, and attentive staff. Enjoyed Stromboli, pizza, and beer. All generous portions at a fair price. Would come back regularly but it's a long flight from SoCal!

Years ago, Vinny's was questionable. Today, Vinny's is an institution that sustains Midtown.The staff is friendly.The food is great! Not exotic, Just fantastic with the staples. My biggest problem: they close at pre-Batman hours.I always order to go and I can't emphasize enough how amazing the staff is. But I wish they stayed open later.They get 5 stars and I wish I could give them six.

Solid. I'm from NY and it's pretty solid. Closest thing you'll find I think. I like the outdoor seating.

Overdue first visit, enjoyed 2 huge NYC style foldable cheese pizza slices and fountain drink‼ Deeee-lish

The most amazing New York style Pizza in the Downtown area. Perfect pizza from the crust to the sauce. I must admit that the East coast pizza is real Pizza at its finest.

Steer clear of this place! We ordered a pizza & tiramisu via door dash this evening. The cold pizza arrived over 40 min after it was originally supposed to arrive and the tiramisu did not arrive (though we were still charged for it.) Honestly, had the pizza arrived warm, it would have been pretty good.) We called the restaurant to inquire about the whereabouts of the rest of our order & the manager was unapologetic, rude, and dismissive. There are FAR better places to get mediocre pizza in town. Don't bother with this place.