Upper Crust Wood Fired Pizza

My husband and I had occasion to travel to the south side of town for a show and wanted to try something we've never had before. Upper Crust has been there for as long as that shopping center has been there, so we figured it was obviously holding its own and doing good business. When we arrived, we told our waitress it was our first time and she recommended the social hour specials. I ordered ERWO and we got the fried mozzarella to share. Sorry, no picture of that! We devoured it. We asked a few more questions of the waitress who was knowledgeable and enthusiastic about the menu, including letting us know we could order the pizzas in a smaller size for a lesser charge which wasn't obvious from a cursory review of the menu. We decided to share the Numbers pizza and the classic NYC Grinder. We did ask for the pizza to be well done. Everything arrived promptly and I would say the only note is we would have preferred the pizza more well done. Shortly after we asked for a box, the manager came over to check on us. The waitress had alerted him that it was our first time and he came over to check on our experience and leave us with a free appetizer coupon to use on return. We will be back. The service was excellent and there are other items we want to try out, and we loved that they were enthusiastic and welcoming. By comparison, when we went to another long-standing Tulsa restaurant for the first time recently, we were treated with condescension and basically ignored because we weren't their weekend regulars. Upper Crust welcomed us, fed us well and asked us to come back, with an appetizer on them. THAT is good service!

I enjoyed my visit to Upper Crust. We ordered the meat supreme pizza. The pepperoni was crispy and the bacon was delicious. I just personally don't like soft pizza. I expected it to be more crispy. Our waitress Hunter was very attentive and knowledgeable about the menu so service was awesome and we sat outside which made the ambiance romantic.

The food was amazing! The ambiance was sort of sports bar (which i wasn't expecting) but we had a good time. I got the strawberry Italian soda which was really good, and the appetizer was a goat cheese, fig mix. It was really good as well, our server was sweet & I would go back!

The food was spectacular. The mozzarella sticks are the best I have ever had. Braden was an amazing wait. Took his time and answered all our questions.

First time visiting Upper Crust! I stopped by on a Monday night and our group of 4 was seated right away.Food Rundown Italian Nachos - Flavor was interesting, but the presentation wasn't very appetizing. Grilled Cheese with Tomato Soup - The Grilled Cheese could have had more cheese on it, and the soup was pretty basic. Tony's Italian Pizza - This was my favorite thing we ate. The roasted garlic sauce, pepperoni, and banana peppers combined for a great savory taste. The booth we sat at was comfortable, and the service was friendly. Overall it was an ok experience, and would recommend sticking to the pizza if you give Upper Crust a try!

Upper Crust is our favorite Tulsa area pizza. However, last weekend we stopped by for lunch and the pizza had far too much sauce. The pizza was almost "soupy". The cheese slid off the sauce and the sauce "splashed" onto the counter top ( and onto my pants) We mentioned it to the waitress ( the bartender) but she didn't say anything except " oh yes too much sauce."We will probably return but the customer service was lacking.

Pizza was great. Great wood fire grill taste with fresh toppings. Salad was large and fresh. Cheese sticks were crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. Heated leftovers up in air fryer and they were still great.

Wonderful food and service every single time!We eat there often!Very classy with great ambience!

Gluten free crust is amazing for those who would benefit! Very pleasant environment and the food is very very good.

The atmosphere is amazing! Cory the manager is involved with his employees and customers to maintain a high level of service and food quality. He treats you like valued customers!We have had different servers that were really good! Jason, Dante and Conner have been the best we have experienced anywhere! The food tastes is very good! Well prepared and fresh! We also enjoyed the dessert-Naughty Knots! Wonderful.We recommend this restaurant for sure! It is very clean, friendly and professional . The tables are kept clear as you finish even when other servers walk but they pick up the dishes that were used!