Tiny Tim's Pizza and West Mountain Brewing Company

Tiny Tim's seems to be a controversial restaurant here in Fayetteville, and after eating there for the first time today, I totally get it. The pizza is not a very typical pizza you'd find in Fayetteville. The crust is thin, but not too thin, and crunchy and not too doughy. As someone who grew up in the Midwest where all pizza was at least partially inspired by Chicago style, this pizza tasted like home. But if you're born and raised in the south, this definitely will be different.The crust tastes and has the consistency of a saltine cracker (but in the best way, I promise!) the sauce is delicious and the toppings tasted very fresh. Service was very fast. We were there at peak lunch time on a Saturday, but our order was taken immediately and the waitress checked on us throughout the meal.Overall, the pizza isn't for everyone. My northerner fiancé didn't love it because he's used to a very thin crust. But to me, the pizza was awesome and I'd totally eat at Tiny Tim's again.

I'm vegan and couldn't find anything specifically vegan on the menu, so I modified the veggie sandwich by asking them to remove the cheese and mayo and add some pizza sauce on the side. The sandwich was ok, not great. The menu says "plenty of mushrooms, black olives, green peppers", but there weren't very many. It was served with chips and a wedge of pickle which were good. The price was normal for a place on the square. The ambience is great and the service was excellent!

A long time standard on the Fayetteville Square great for pizza and local beer definitely worth checking out

John,Thank you for your hospitality. My wife and I truly enjoyed the pizza and the "jog" down memory lane. Tiny Tim's in Springfield is a good memory. When you continue to operate Fayetteville's oldest Restraunt and oldest brewery in NW Arkansas the history is rich (A lot of dry counties) Thank you for keeping the OG 80's art posters. You honor all of the hard working small business owners and all those who enjoyed a pizza on the Square in Fayetteville. I like beer and the Blood Moon is good! Cheers

Horrible customer service. Waited for 15 minutes for service, after trying for get their attention the staff, (guy with pony tail) kept gossiping and mocking us for trying to get waited on. Weirdest experience we ever had in a restaurant. There are plenty of other restaurants nearby to eat than wasting time here ...

Great pizza. We'll definitely go back when we're in Fayetteville again. We carried out from their downtown location and weren't disappointed. Highly recommend.

We had a great afternoon here. Bartenders were awesome! We loved all the stuff they had on tap. Highlight was the pizza! Not sure what all the bad reviews are about? We did have to wait a while for our pizza, but they make it fresh. And it was totally worth the wait! Definitely be back on our next trip!

I will say this time to time again, this is the best place to eat in Fayetteville! The food is delicious, with options for pizza, sandwiches, soup, salads, and more! This time though, it blew me away even more than usual! I had a kind server who was very quick! They helped me choose my food and came back in a flash with it! Also, they have a wonderful bar inside with fun music. Finally, it is located in the perfect spot in the middle of the square! Definitely would recommend a visit here if you live nearby or are visiting!

The family met this afternoon/evening for dinner because they have good beer and pizza. Unfortunately, the place filled up and they only have two waiters and one bartender serving the whole place. The service took a turn for the worse because there was too many people for the servers to manage, no fault of theirs. They called in help that showed up after the main rush. My opinion on a Friday afternoon/evening is that it's better to have one too many servers than not having enough. Beer and pizza were still good, once you got it.

My daughter and I were visiting from Texas and in the mood for some pizza. I thought the pizza was good, very reasonably priced and great service! Plus it is located right on the square.