House salad with ranch dressing
Rock Island Red minus the Ham add minced garlic
cars parked on the side of the road
Sign
Small supreme pizza
Interior
Cheesy garlic bread
Salad no chicken
Meatball sandwich
The big sloppy pie
Menu page 1
Side salad with blue cheese and garlic bread
Sam & Ella's supreme
Sunrise Pizza with less mozzarella and extra Feta
Meatball sub
Meatball sub
Medium dominiquer (chicken bacon ranch pizza basically)
Menu page 2
Only curbside and takeout right now
Cheesy garlic bread
pizza, food
Supreme pizza
Cheesy garlic bread
Exterior
Tracy F.
Jul 31, 2024
Came here very hungry and ordered a small deluxe pizza. My son ordered a meatball sub, since he's not a black olive fan. Yes, I know he can request no olives but sandwich it was.Kinda hard to ruin a meatball sub so it was good and he enjoyed it. Came with a bag of ruffles and a dill pickle spear.My pizza was fabulous, if you like thick pizza. Loaded with veggies and meat, a small was more than plenty for me. Took half home.The waitress was really nice, offered ranch when she delivered my pizza (mind reader) and also brought a lid with the box so I could take my ranch to go. Perfect for my hotel munchies! She even asked if we wanted our drink refills to go.Lots of seating inside and the chicken/rooster decor was cute.But just a heads up, there's no chicken on the menu in this palace!Enjoy
Read More
Jamie S.
Apr 18, 2024
I have been eating at Sam & Ella's Pizza for many years. They have always had the same menu. And the inside has looked the same for ages! The staff are always friendly and bring all the ranches. Because the ranch is a superior must have, and it's not because the pizza is bad without it. The ranch just enhances the incredible pizza even more. It's thick doughy crust, which some people don't love, but I love carbs too much! It's one of those pizzas that everyone in Oklahoma should try. It's a staple after a long hot river float too. The arti toast is one of the most brilliant creations known to man too. Who doesn't love spinach artichoke dip slathered onto garlic bread smothered in melty cheese baked to perfection?! And the salads and sandwiches are great too!
Read More
Celeste N.
Apr 13, 2024
I love pizza. This pizza is nice crispy with a chewy edges. Service was great. Dining room was nice with a chicken themed decorations. They are located just down the street from the college.
Read More
Brit W.
Sep 14, 2023
Sam and Ella's is a quaint restaurant near NSU with lots of fun chicken paraphernalia all over the place. Truly a chicken palace with a fun play on words. The staff was friendly and the pizzas are great. They are extra cheesy with a great crust, flavorful sauce, and fresh ingredients. We will visit when we are in the Tahlequah area again.
Read More
Joann T.
Jul 29, 2023
There was hair in my pizza. I understand sometimes things happen when we go to a restaurant with human error, but the way things were handled after the hair was found was literally the worst experience I've had with a restaurant, ever. The waiter, Annika handled things really well and probably was the best part of coming here, but Ireland was rude and inconsiderate after waiting two hours for our food in a smoky room.
Read More
Dave W.
Jan 11, 2024
I happened to be in Tahlequah today, and a friend had recommended this place. I must say it's some of the best pizza I've ever eaten, and I've eaten a lot of pizza. Fresh ingredients, excellent crust and sauce.
Read More
Jannie B.
Aug 24, 2022
This is my former employment in college (19 years old). Jack and Andrea are the owners and this is literally their baby. Jack is a self proclaimed former rocker - was in a band and this name is where it all birthed from. The pies are all former titles to his song s from their album, albeit never came to fruition but birthed this gem instead. This place will always have a special place in my heart. It is where Carrie underwood was employed. It is also where I met a life time best friend while employed. First off the salad is bar none. I ordered it sans chicken. I do remember more bell pepper but I digress. I remember a college Math professor who would have this salad daily! I do not recall his name.Then the arti- toast. This is a spin on the ole regular cheesy bread - I guess you could say. It is more like a calzone but I love it and my husband has to get everytime we visit here,Of course we ordered the classic big sloppy pie- containing a layer of cheese, a layer of black olives and a layer of pepperoni- ONLY TO BE REPEATED! So double layer toppings!!!! There is no place like this place! My son (a self proclaimed dominoes lover) literally said "I AM IN HEAVEN." haha I was surprised there were no waitresses and they sadly took the old soda fountain bar. All that remind of it is a photo of what it used to be. Overall the quality of the food surpasses everything else. Of course we will be back bc it's my college staple
Read More
Bryan B.
Jul 10, 2024
Going to start with the service. 1 star. Service was horrible took a very long time to be waited on once we ordered again a very long time. Once severed I have to admit the food was very good if they could speed up the service it would be wonderful
Read More
Gaby L.
Aug 9, 2024
There pizza isn't that good .... restrooms are nasty .... people are friendly tho and costumed service is great
Read More
Ryan B.
Sep 17, 2024
( First time going!!!!! )So from the start we really thought it would be chicken not pizza and subs bcs it says chicken palace but it wasnt, sooo now the service was ok the waitress where nice but slow the food was slow we waited 40 MINUTES for our pizza to come out and it was BURNT and it wasn't even that great, but we even ordered appetizer that came out burnt we asked the service to check on our pizza and she said since she put in the order it's not on her it's how ever long the chef takes. Just over all went one time never ganna go again, not even worth talking about positively.
Read More