Payton’s Corner

Well...burgers are underwhelming. I didn't care for the meat or cheese on the regular burger; both tasted funny and the patty was in and did not seem fresh. Onion rings were good. Fries were not crinkle or fresh. I might go back to try something else on the menu if I was in the area.

This is a fun little "hole in the wall" with great food. Don't let the outside fool you. It looks good on the inside and there's plenty of seating. You pay at the counter, you eat off of paper plates, and you eat with plastic utensils. You take care of your own refills. If any of that bothers you, keep in mind that you might be missing out on the best burger you've had in quite some time. This could easily be one of those places you gather with friends every week.

Truly an unexpected surprise! Who would have thought that such a great burger would be found at a Gas Station?!! I would re comment that anyone in the Tulsa area give this place a try. I travel to Tulsa several times a month and my co-workers said we had to try this place out. We waited past the typical lunch hour so we could all sit together. Very limited seating! I think I counted 3 tables 3 booths. The menu is limited to just burger and other sandwiches. I would honestly rate this burger higher than a four but I have to go back and visit again. It's on my list to go back and try another burger.I noticed they also have a small breakfast menu which I'm open to try if I arrive early enough. Like others have said a hole in the wall with great results!

You will smell like a cheeseburger when you leave! The small place was packed. Luckily, we got a table. There was a group of 16 ladies having a luncheon and gossip session. They filled the small dining area. Fortunately for us, most of them already had their orders when we walked in. The kitchen staff was hustling. We were orders #26 and 27. Order 22& 23 went to their table; #24&25 was a to-go order. Quickly after that, our orders came out, #26 (regular cheeseburger and fries) and #27 (double cheeseburger and O-Rings) I was surprised, these are hearty cheeseburgers. Good big beef patties, between fresh buns and dressed with L,T,P,O&M. Hold the mayo and I should have said hold the ketchup. A minor slip up and infraction of proper burger protocol on my part. Excellent Burgers. The fries and onion rings, commonly found fast food prepared versions, were perfectly cooked to the proper golden brownIt is a small community/neighborhood gas station/store that has been around forever. Friendly service. After our order was served, the cook came out of the kitchen and got involved with the gaggle of ladies as they were finishing their lunch.The burgers at Payton's frequently are caught up in food fights on local foodie blogs. Burger aficionados spar endlessly with polemic comments to defend their favorite "Best burger in Tulsa." It is an unresolvable controversy. I would certainly rate Payton's Corner burgers in the top 10. Try it if you haven't.

Stopped in for lunch recently after seeing a barrage of positive reviews online. First, it is in a gas station! Not a problem - some of the best bbq in America is in a gas station in Kansas City. But I digress. Not much seating so plan accordingly - four of us were prepared to take it back to the office if needed. But we lucked out and snagged a table. Very friendly from the order takers to the pick up window. Burgers seem to be the deal, but other items such as catfish are popular too. I had the bacon cheeseburger and a catfish fillet - hey, I needed to try it! I'm a sucker for a great catfish fillet. BCB was generously sized. Fresh lettuce, tomato's, etc. burger was properly cooked and it all came together well. Like eating a homemade burger. Crinkle cut fries - don't see these often but I like them a lot. Fried perfectly - almost extra crispy, the way I like it. Catfish fillet was good - $3.99 for an ala carte piece seemed high, but I get it - it's the sign of the times. It was not very big, but it was tasty! And speaking of tasty, the tartar sauce was really nice! Not sure if homemade, as it was in individual plastic containers - but it was the perfect complement to the fish. And fries. I'll be back as it is close to my work, and I may try some other selections.

This is, without a doubt, the best grilled burger I've had in Tulsa, OK. I heard about this place through a food vlog and had always wanted to give it a try--it did not disappoint! Great experience all around.

If your there for one of the Best Burgers you've ever eaten, you won't be disappointed. Thin but not too thin. Thick but not too thick. Pattie had just enough tasty crunch burnt in!Service: hey if you want to rush through a fast food joint, better leave. You will not regret the moment you walked in the front door and was totally overwhelmed by the smell of burgers cooking on the grill! Took us 40 minutes to get a burger baskets. Get a cold drink and watch the crowd come and go. We saw two Jenks Fire Trucks park out front, along with the Chief in his boss-hawg truck! Bottom line: if it's bringing in a entire station here for a burger, it got to be delicious!

I had read really great reviews on this burger place so tonight we got two burgers to go. I got a cheese burger that I thought would have all the fixins (lettuce, tomato, pickles, onion etc) but it was only meat, cheese, mustard, bread. The burger had a good taste to it but was pretty dry. The fries that many people were raving about were mediocre. Dry as well. I'm not sure I understand the hype. To me, it is what I would expect for a gas station burger joint.

Called in order and 15 minutes was ready. Husband loves burgers and I love crayfish cowder..

Good burger. Best hamburger you will ever have in a gas station. Meat is very flavorful and onion rings are great.