NYC Pizza

Sicilian Pizza was very good. The NY Style was good, but there was an odd spice that I didn't care for. I try to distinguish between personal taste vs. general quality. I didn't care for it, but there were no issues.

My husband and I stopped in for lunch first time last week. We each got a slice and one of their Jamaican meat pies. I loved my pepperoni and mushroom slice, it was very thin and crispy, served hot! The first couple of bites of the meat pie were good but I got a third bite that had an overpowering seasoning that kind of turned me off of the rest. Next time I would ask for extra mushrooms on mine. It's counter service so you walk up and see what they have and they run it through the oven to heat, so I would think throwing a few mushrooms on it wouldn't be hard. I did not like their ranch, but their pizza sauce was really good, not sweet at all. They could use a dining room refresh, it looks a little depressing. But I'm definitely going back for more.

NYC Pizza is a pretty simple pizza parlor. I ordered two slices of the pizza that was already made, one with meats and one with everything, and they were both great. Add a drink and it was plenty for me. When I walked in the young man behind the counter immediately went for help. I could tell by looking at him that he needed help with the language. It turns out he's from Mexico and still learning English. My Spanish is no muy bueno, so it was better for him to get the manager. But everyone was very nice and helpful. And the pizza was delicious.I don't get to Tulsa very often but it's nice to have another place to add to my list of good restaurants.

Overpriced and not worth going. Poor customer service and cold food. Got a slice of pizza, pizza rolled up item and patty type deal. Not so good. Poor ambiance, not worth sitting and eating. Would not recommend.

I have tried almost everything at NYC Pizza, except the desserts and salad. The only dessert I've tried is the tiramisu which was alright, but these items are not why you go to NYC Pizza. One would go to NYC Pizza is of course for their pizza. I would say that NYC Pizza is too "thin" for me. It could have been a little thicker, but it's good and quite cheap. My favorite item from NYC Pizza used to be the calzone, but now it's the patties. It's like a mini calzone with a crunchier crust and the inside is almost the same with less ingredients. It's so delicious. Unlike the pizza slices which can be ready in a few minutes, patties took almost as long as a calzone. If you decide to get them, be prepare for some wait time, but it will be worth it, I promise.

Hot, fast, fresh slice!! It hit the spot!! We were just passing thru on our motorcycle journey, and this place was fast and great!! Nice fresh sauce, crispy NYC style crust, yummy toppings!

The best NY slices in Tulsa area. Service is friendly. I always see a steady stream of dine in and carry out customers.

Good price of the size though it does take a while to get your order so I recommend calling ahead. The service was very friendly but there is not a lot of seating space.

Consistently good pizza at a good price. No complaints. It very much tastes like traditional New York style pizza.

It's the real deal. Just like the pizzas you get at Penn Station in NYC.It's as authentic and delicious as what I've had in NYc.