Nettie Ann's Bakery

This bakery is connected to the Amish Cheese House, so you have to shop both when in the area! I stop in anytime I'm driving through. It's fully stocked with loads of baked goods and frozen ready-made desserts, pizzas, casseroles, etc. it's a cute little shop. The cashiers are always friendly. I've never had anything I didn't love either. My tops faves are carrot cake, Oreo puffcorn, breakfast pizza, tater tot casserole , and all of the bread loaves! Prices are extremely reasonable for homemade items too.

While on a road trip, we decided to stop at Nettie Ann's. The smell of yeast and warm bread hits you as soon as you open the door. The bakery is on one end of the building and a deli on the other. Nettie Ann's has everyone's favorites: loaves of bread, cookies, and pies. Most of the baked goods are wrapped and placed on shelves for you to select. We selected a loaf of pumpkin bread to offer our host, and we also got some oatmeal raisin cookies. While on the sweet side for me, the items were very fresh and like homemade. We were in and out of the store in under 10 minutes, which also speaks to the quick service.

Delicious oatmeal whoopie pies! The workers are friendly. The iced banana bread is delicious! I've yet to try the frozen foods but can't wait to try those next. The only downside is a huge piece of packaged plastic was inside the icing I took a bite out of but it wasn't sharp or anything. I'll just take smaller bites ha. I'll still shop here and the prices are nice!!

My first trip to Nettie Ann's even though my hubby brings treats home from Nettie Ann's periodically. This place is amazing. We were tempted by a cute Apron for a grandson, with tractors on it, and pecan pie, whoopie pies and sugar cookies. Yes we went a bit crazy. We tried it all when we got home and everything was yummy. The smell in the bakery was amazing. I will be back again and again!!!

Ordered 3 pies; the apple and raisin were very good. The pecan pie, however, was unacceptable. It didn't set properly . As you can see , it's missing pecans. My family has bought from here many times and this is the first time getting a sub par product. What's more disappointing is that either no one checked before sending the pie or, someone did and didn't care. Either way, a very disappointing experience for a loyal customer.

The most delicious food whether frozen entrees or desserts. It is well worth the trip unless you live in Oregon like we do now. When we lived in Tulsa/Broken Arrow we traveled there regularly to get the wonderful food. If you ship to Oregon, please put us on the top of the list! Thanks!

Stopped in the bakery while visiting the Cheese House. The people here are friendly & willing to help you with any questions you might have. I purchased some delicious snacks, frozen meals for later & some sour dough bread. The bread was so delicious. We can't wait to make the trip back soon to the bakery.

I am surprised with only six reviews at the time of this writing. Netties Ann's Bakery and the Amish Cheese House are legendary. I am a long-time customer and drive 50 miles from my home in south Tulsa several times a year. The baked goods are second to none. I order pies and rolls a few weeks in advance during the holidays. Forget showing up on Christmas or Thanksgiving Eve and expecting to get pies or rolls. Perhaps the place does not get much attention because it is north of Highway 412 on US 69. There's not much traffic to speak of on old US 69 anymore. Folks, if you are traveling on US 412 east of Tulsa, get off on US 69, go north about two miles, and visit what is known as the Amish Corner. The Amish Cheese House and Nettie Ann's Bakery are at the stoplight. You cannot miss it. Give both a visit; it is well worth your time, and your stomach will thank you.

Their cinnamon bread! I just can't tell you how good it is.They also have a nice deal where you can buy the day- old bread at a pretty steep discount, which is nice. Its still good, and my kids eat go through it fast enough that it doesn't get stale. Its a good deal. Their store made pies and frozen dinners are delicious, chicken enchilada casserole is my favorite.

They have the most amazing fresh baked breads, cookies, meals, etc. I get fresh baked bread there every chance I get. It's so yummy. You can get day old or two day old bread and save lots!! Although I love going in the morning and getting while it's still warm!!! Sooo good!!!