McNellie's South City

I had my Dad's 70th birthday party here and was able to reserve the big room for only $50 during the day. The staff were so helpful and friendly. The event manager was great at answering all my questions throughout the planning process. The waitress so so on top of things and did amazing. The food on the catering menu is very different than the regular menu. We had the chicken marsala with rice and vegetables and it was so good. We also got their artichoke spinach dip, which is always on point.I highly recommend having a party or gathering here.

We were looking for a new spot to enjoy an adult beverage and spotted McNellies! It was midday and they had minimal guests. We had lunch prior to going so we sat at the bar and didn't look at their food menu. The drink menu was expansive with a huge selection of beers - bottles, cans, and tap! See photos! If you're a beer lover, this place will surely satisfy your thirst! The restaurant appeared large enough for groups & I noticed a semi-private dining area along with an outside patio. Since visiting, we read other Yelp reviews and the restaurant currently has a low health score rating, 73 out of 100.) The bar service was good and if their health scores improve, we would consider revisiting, if in the area.

If you have not been to McNellies's, I have a recommended as it is a highly rated pub in Tulsa. The main location is downtown and they boast their 300 beers on tap. You can even get a sheet to record all of your beers drink and earn a mug with your name on it to put on the wallThis night when I went there, mind you, I've been there more times than I can count, we were with a huge group of 25 people. the business was very accommodating for the size of our group and got our food out really fast. As far as the food I would say it is really good pub food and nine times out of 10. I love my food. One thing I will say is if you want a really good cheap burger, go on Wednesday nights when they have five dollar burger night.My boyfriend this night had the bratwurst platter that was really good and I had the Cuban sandwich. I wasn't a fan of the white hoagie that it was on but otherwise it was really good.

I went to dinner with some friends and it was my first experience. I ordered the pulled pork nachos and the plate and the nachos were cold. I was starving so I had to eat them. The wait person was trying to be nice but everyone could tell she was on her last nerve. I don't think I would make an effort to return

The food was okay, basic Mcnellies but the server for our group would make eye contact as we ask to order then keep walking... she forgot our sauce, and the drink was whack. We literally had to have several people wave the server down even to get our order in. Ambiance was eh. The strawberry essence was a nah, wouldn't order again.

Haven't been here since 2016 apparently they changed the fish last week. It was good we got the fish and chips but I substituted for a Greek salad and my husband subbed his for tabouli it was very good but I will say I preferred the fish before because it was a light batter still has good as I remember but now I have lunch and dinner was plenty of food! I swear the fish before was long thin pieces with light batter but every picture I see on here doesn't look like what I remember; I really did prefer the old style because it was light and not heavy; as someone who has diet restrictions because of my health we went here today because of the old fish and chips ( it wasn't as healthy as I should eat because breading but it was good!)

McNellie's "The Original Charburger" may be an overlooked sleeper.My wife had the burger. I had the Fish and Chips. The fish portion was a slab, bigger than a fisherman's lie. On the side, a combo mixture of crisp fries, or "chippies" if you prefer. Enough for two people. (check the Photos) The tarter sauce was a little funky tasting, but that was OK, because in true Irish fashion I prefer the Malt Vinegar. The burger was excellent. It appeared to be a half pound patty. It was cooked to text book perfection Medium Rare. Grill lines and a crisp char flavor finish. Just as my wife ordered it. Complete with L,T,P,O& M, hold the Mayo. Along with it, more delicious fries than you can eat. Rayleen was our server. She was covering a busy area of the restaurant. But she did a great job, all with a friendly smile. The restaurant has a comfortable pub atmosphere. If you have not tried a McNellie's "The Original Charburger" you need to get it on your list

So, first of all, let me say I was a bit stumped when we found ourselves in South Tulsa needing a place for dinner, something that wasn't a chain or outrageously expensive. After one misstep, we ended up at McNellie's. I forget about this location.The chicken salad was amazing and as always, the burgers are better than average. Service was great and I found a new "canned" wine I really like.(I'm open for new suggestions for dining in this area though but it's good to know McNellie's is there.)

Really nice, spacious, well decorated, very friendly staff, a bar selection that is awesome and delicious food! Nice job

My friend and I went to McNellie's for lunch. She had the Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap (may not be exact name) It was huge and delicious! We shared a giant pretzel. Delicious! I ordered the hamburger and ff. It was very good! We had a very good, attentive server, unfortunately I don't remember his name. I will definitely be back!