McGarity’s Restaurant & Saloon

Awesome food awesome service Awesome ambiance Definitely will come back!Shepherds pie is #1

We had good service and received a discount since our hotel was in close proximity, unfortunately the food was not great.Mom ordered crab cakes meal and I got Fish, Shrimp & Chips meal.Her crab cakes were mushy and honestly over-sauced. She ate most of one of them. My shrimp were huge but flavorless. The fish was more like big fish sticks. I mean, they weren't store bought necessarily, but cut into stick shapes. The batter on them was also not flavorful, despite me adding malt vinegar, salt, tartar sauce (which wasn't great), etc. I don't do mushy peas, but Mom kind of liked them. The chips were pretty good.I ended up eating the rest of my meal later as a late-night snack. It still wasn't all that flavorful, but it was edible.

It was so good. The place was super cute on the inside. Large portions of food so order sparingly. The quality and service were as top notch.

Just opened we ate here on Friday night at 4. Not a Huge place so by the time we were leaving it was full.Food was excellent, except for the Brussels. Shepherd Pie was very tasty. Not big so you may want to order a starter or a side.Alot of starters sounded really good.The egg rolls for sure.They bring you a basket of chips when seated.Desserts are large and price large too! We should of shared but I wanted German Chocolate and husband wanted Carrot Cake.Expect to spend almost $80 -$100.00For 2.

We came from out of town, and walked in on a Saturday night at 6:30pm, and was able to get a table quickly. Our server (Bobby) was super nice and professional, my wife and I appreciated his suggestions. His first was to advise her on getting the Espresso martini, it was amazing! We got the Reuben Egg Rolls, very large portion and delicious. After hearing the portions were large we decided to share the fish, shrimp and chips, and it was a good call, we could barely finish the fish, had to leave some fries behind. overall, great experience and great food.

The food here is delicious! We looked at the appetizers and selected the Irish Reuben egg rolls. For the main course, we chose the gumbo on a bed of cheese grits. Yum! Also, the Irish bangers and mash with cabbage. Customer service was friendly. We'll be back to try other menu items.

Great atmosphere, chuck was awesome food was amazing and you definitely have to try the cocktail blackberry julip!!!

Was able to be seated immediately on a Saturday night. Probably because this place is a hidden gem!!! Hubby and I shared the Reuben egg rolls (sooooo good!) and Shrimp/Fish & Chips. Portions were big and we were quite happy. Probably the best fish & chips we've had Mayb ever (they don't look special but trust us!)

This place was a hugely pleasant surprise. I just happened to be in Eureka Springs that day and went in for lunch. Wow!! The food was absolutely cooked to perfection and the atmosphere is really nice, upscale, and the staff is very friendly, especially the server known as "Meesh" (short for Michelle). I mean it, this food was super, super delicious. I'll be going back the next time I'm in Eureka Springs, which should be in about three weeks. Can't imagine anyone would be disappointed with this place in any way. A little pricey, just as a forewarning...

The ambiance and decor of McGarity's Restaurant was very interesting and we enjoyed playing shuffleboard while waiting for our meal.Our meal was okay, but not on par for the price and location. We probably should have ordered from the "Irish" dishes, but when shrimp and grits are on the menu, that is my go-to meal. The grits had very large clumps in it and there was a lot of sauce covering the grits. The shrimp were cooked nicely, the entree lacked seasoning. It t also had a fried green tomatoe in the center, but I would have preferred that to be served in a way that it wasn't coated by the sauce on the bottom.My husband had the seared ahi tuna and it was okay as well. The Brussels sprouts were not great and we just left them on the table.