Jimmy’s New York Pizzeria

My husband and I visited on a Saturday afternoon around 2:30pm. There was one table that was clean - three or four tables were occupied and the rest had not been cleaned off yet. They appeared to be short staffed with one worker on break, one at the register, and one in the kitchen (this person was visibly eating through the food pickup window). The employee working the register was nice and helped us out with the menu, since this was our first visit. We ordered some garlic knots to share and a slice of pizza each. Our order took awhile but there was a sign saying that some orders take longer than others, so we patiently waited. The cashier took a few more orders then started cleaning off the dirty tables. Another diner noticed that this employee was going between cleaning and picking up food orders without washing their hands. She made quite a scene when their order was delivered - I think this could have been handled better on the diner's side, but the employees might need additional food safety training between the cook eating while preparing other people's food and the cashier handling food after using cleaning spray. Our cheese garlic knots were good, but difficult to eat off of the foil they were heated up in. The pizza slices were not as good - my veggie slice had raw veggies on top. My husband's slice was somehow burnt but cold. The slices were big for the price but overall not good. Not sure we will be back.

As a New Yorker, I'm happy to have found Jimmy's with their authentic NY pizza. Great dough, crust, and flavor. We had the Brooklyn pie today and all the ingredients tasted so fresh. With Sinatra playing in the background..it reminds me of home. You won't be disappointed.

Jimmys is one of our FAVORITE pizza places and we were so excited to see it on here for delivery! Pizza is excellent as always has a nice flop to it, full of flavor and the crust is done perfectly. The Stromboli is full of meat and cheese and is exploding with flavor. The service is always quick, professional and friendly. It's a small pizza joint with a few tables and booths with an open kitchen vibe.

I must say, I really enjoyed this pizza spot. I was in the area for a cheer competition and didn't want to get too far away from the venue. I wanted pizza but didn't want a chain pizza place, so I decided to give Jimmy's a try. I ordered a slice of pepperoni and a slice of liberty supreme. I had to pay a bit of an up charge for the liberty supreme because I wanted to make some modifications. I also grabbed a Greek salad. You can tell off the bat, that all the dressings are made in house. The ranch and vinaigrette were so delicious. The vinaigrette definitely added a layer of flair to my otherwise kind of "meh" salad. I really didn't enjoy the chopped iceberg. It would have been much better with some romaine or some other type of greens. I do however, love that they make the salads fresh and not give you something that's been sitting in a plastic container for who knows how long. Our pizzas came out hot and fresh and the slices were HUGE. Definitely a lot of bang for your buck. I struggled to get through one slice and I was starving. LolIt is thin crust pizza, so be prepared for that. I was hoping for a little more softness to the crust, but it was a little too crunchy! Good, but still crunchy. I also love that they use fresh ingredients. It's been a long time since I've been able to get fresh mushrooms and spinach on a pizza. Overall, I'd definitely check it out again it was tasty, clean, had a full dining room, and just an overall great experience.

This place is one of the best pizza joints in Oklahoma, I was born on the East coast and at times I get home sick,I go there and get my pizza fix on,the staff is always friendly, the place is clean,and the bathrooms are well kept, the only thing is missing is Manhattan Specials,(which is a coffee soda),Jimmy the owner is a really good guy from where I grew up,this guy,this guy is a character, May is super friendly and is just awesome! Props to them if I can give 10 stars I will

Stopped in Jimmy's New York Pizzeria and had a great time. Friendly and helpful staff, clean and presentable spot! I was happy to see that this was actual New York style pizza. I ended up getting two different kinds to try and it was more than I can eat due to the slices being so big.I had the Manhattan meat slice and the Staten Island white slice. Both were really great. You definitely get a nice authentic New York style with these flavors. I would recommend checking these guys out! See photos!!!Cleanliness: 10/10Service: 9/10Pizza taste: 8/10Ranch: 6/10

On principle I will never return to a restaurant that charges me to drink tap water while I'm dining in for a meal. Not a concern because the food is very average anyway. The bacon on my slice was the of the poor quality and kind that is typically on salad bars. Soft, rubbery, chewy and fatty bacon. Ricatta was not any good either. Crust is really good here but not enough to carry a slice.

Incredible. Best calzone I've ever had. Simple decor, but very nice. The staff are really friendly and are ready to recommend anything to fit your cravings!

This place is the most consistent and delicious pizza we have in town. By far my personal favorite and the family who own it and run it are amazing.

Excellent spaghetti with meatballs! The atmosphere is very simple, clean friendly, and the food and service are great!