Jay's Original Hoagies
Jay's Original Hoagies
Turkey and cheese with all the fixings
The Monster
outside
the menu
Definition of a hoagie
Menu
the menu
The gang
sandwiches, food, sandwich
food, sandwiches, sandwich
sandwiches, food
sandwich, food, sandwiches
sandwich, food, sandwiches
pizza
food
outside
Jay's Original Hoagies tucked away in a little strip mall at the corner of Sheridan and 91st
food, sandwiches
steak, food
food, sandwiches
pizza
menu
Getting ready to unwrap some goodness.
Robert K.
Jan 16, 2025
From the Philadelphia area, but not a gatekeeper. Jay's was very good. Had a few different sandwiches.
Read More
Sarah D.
Oct 15, 2024
Do not sleep on this place! I got the turkey and cheese 4-inch hoagie and it was scrumptious! I got it with all the fixings. Within five minutes I devoured it. Jay and the staff were so sweet and made my sandwich fast. An added bonus is that the walls are decorated with baseball photos! I will definitely be coming back here whenever I am craving a sandwich.
Read More
Bobby B.
Apr 30, 2024
Best sandwich in Tulsa hands down. 10/10Jay will likely make your sandwich. Bread is to die for.
Read More
James R.
Apr 8, 2023
Despite Yelp techs stupidity, THIS is a separate location from the 91st Street location. This is located in the Advanced Autoparts parking lot. They don't have the extensive menu that the OTHER Jays brick and mortar location has but if you need your hoagie fix this is a more convenient location than deep south Tulsa to get it. There is a different number for calling in orders to the trailer than the number ON the trailer. Weather and help permitting they open 5 days a week for lunch at this location. If Yelp techs don't screw up this listing the proper number should show on this page. Not sure why Yelp techs ditched my 1st listing for this location. McDonalds has several locations but has several listings here as well. YELP BOOBS!!! THIS IS A SEPARATE LOCATION FROM 91ST ST LOCATION. Extract ur cranium from ur nether regions and add this listing.
Read More
Camille H.
Mar 28, 2024
Easily the best sandwich spot in town. Their hoagies are like none other, and the staff is very kind and friendly. After coming here, it's hard to think about eating a sandwich anywhere else - the hoagies are too good! We love coming here for lunch, and I would recommend to anyone looking for a good lunch/sandwich spot.
Read More
Alice G.
Mar 16, 2023
Oh my god. I got the Italian Special. Thus was by far the best sandwich I have eaten in the United States. I will come back!
Read More
Jameson W.
Sep 11, 2023
We got lunch here 9/11/2023. I order the turkey and my boyfriend got the Italian. It was our first time trying the place out. Let me tell you, these were the best subs ever. Everything was so fresh and delicious. I wish they stayed open for dinner. We will be back.
Read More
Justin F.
Feb 28, 2025
Jay's is hands down the best sandwich shop in Tulsa. I go every week and the quality is spot on every time. I highly recommend getting any sandwich Rob's way!
Read More
Kris M.
Dec 14, 2024
Love Jay's Hoagies! Tasty, fresh, yummy bread and friendly service! You can't go wrong with Jay's!
Read More
Ciarra P.
May 21, 2024
Amazing! The sweet peppers are amazing, all my fiancé could say is "holy sh!t"! Such a nice guy and really takes the time to think about any and all customers when making his menu
Read More
