Isabella’s Italian

I was remiss to not post a review after my first meal here, but the second time was every bit as lovely. With an unassuming exterior but lovely interior, Isabella's joins only 2 other restaurants in Fayetteville (for me) that make me feel truly pampered. White tablecloth, knowledgeable staff, proper table and wine service, with a diverse menu all impeccably prepared is just entirely too rare these days. Isabella's delivers. Between the 2 visits we've had: classic cocktails and nice wines by the glass, both the mozzarella and the burrata appetizer, the sweetbread entree, filet Oscar style, veal scallopine Oscar style, and the halibut. If I was super nitpicky I would say the halibut was a little over, but I also know the difference between what I think is perfect halibut and it being "over" is likely less than 30 seconds in the pan. It was still tasty, with a nice lemon butter & caper sauce. One visit was finished with olive oil cake another was a rich chocolate cake, the kind you finish regardless of how full you are. Both worth repeating. For a memorable meal with celebration worthy service in Fayetteville, Isabella's is a wonderful choice.

Great service from Josh! Delicious flavor and sauces on the salmon and chicken. Great wine selection and cocktails.

Simply outstanding. Cocktails were so good. The beef tenderloin and potatoes and asparagus left me speechless. WOW. You can dress up if want or dinner casual for date night or girls night or just treat yourself. You won't be disappointed

I am late writing this review as I was here over a year ago. The interior is very nicely done, upscale. The menu is diverse with many very good options. I started with the stuffed mushrooms and they were excellent. Seasoned well and the stuffing was not overdone, great sauce as well. I then had the lasagna, a good test for any Italian restaurant and it was very good. I would like to of had a little more seasoning for taste but very good. The red sauce was on point. My wife had the Fruits de Mere Risotto which had so much shrimp, scallops, mussels and sea bass. It was a very good dish. We then had a cheesecake with blueberry sauce. It was a very large piece of cake and was outstanding. Service was excellent as well. The price was fitting for the quality and service.

Such an incredible dining experience.Great food, service and environment. Great Italian food.

Walked at 615p they were booked up so we had to sit at the bar. Morgan was cool Had a couple cocktails. They were made stout, so appreciated the nice pour. Stuffed mushrooms had a great flavor. The sauce was lukewarmThe Caesar salad has awesome. Bowl made from Parmesan cheese was delicious Seafood risotto and lasagna with scallops were great. Would recommend getting a reservation and enjoy.

It was a nice Italian restaurant. The waiter was nice and also knowledgeable of his product. The food was well prepared and presented. One of our dinner guests really enjoyed her Cobb salad with a garlic Parmesan crust bowl. She shared and it was good. My dish was good but I put too much black pepper on it and the delicate taste of the pasta in a cream?sauce was put off by it. It was my fault so no blame on waiter or restaurant. I would recommend this place and I would come again

isabella's is a horrible place to eat. their food made me terribly sick. when i spoke about they were very ugly. don't eat there it's not worth their high prices and terrible food and employee!

What a wonderful find. We were heading someplace else and saw the sign. I stopped traffic to back up. We went to the location in Bentonville. So very needed here. Beautiful, quiet, great cocktails, amazing food. And the decor is perfectly done. We love it. We'll be back again soon and often.

I needed something with sugar, and Isabellas' came through in a big way. The people were, over the moon, nice and the tiramisu was everything I was looking for and much, much, more.