Gambill's Pastaria & Grocery

Wonderful place! You can hear the staff in the back speaking Italian!! I was shocked of how real Italian this place was! I had lots of questions as my hillbilly Okie self was reading the menu. The staff was so nice and they all made me feel like family. So how it works is: You order when you walk in, take the number to your table. Staff brings food to you. Drinks and silverware are self serve. If your looking for a nice place to eat- try here! This place feels like a nice date night because of the ambiance. And such a CUTE patio to eat and drink some vino :)

Came here for lunch one day with the wife and we ,had a pleasant experience.Note, you have to order before sitting down and get your drinks and silverware from the back. I like how they used the red and white checkered tablecloths on each table.We ordered the hot chicken with candied jalapenos pizza, a side of meat sauce pasta, and a cheesecake to try. While I'm not a huge fan of white pies, the pizza was good. Coming from the NY area, I thought the flour they used was pretty decent with quality toppings. However, it was a tad bit too spicy for my liking, but the wife loved it.For the pasta, the homemade noodles were fantastic and cooked extremely on point. I thought the sauce had too much oregano and perhaps a little too much garlic, but it was tasty nonetheless.My favorite part was the cheesecake. Visually, it looks burnt and one of the reviewers here said it was burnt, but it's not. The restaurant should advertise this as a basque cheesecake because most people would probably think it's a burnt NY cheesecake. Anyway, the cheesecake is divine and had a little bit of the caramelized flan taste and is less dense than a NY cheesecake. This was a home run and I would get this every. single. time.The staff was friendly as well. Great find!

Second time here because I really want to like a place that serves fresh pasta. Unfortunately, I ordered the Eggplant Parmigiana and Spaghetti this time and it was so very underwhelming. The cheese on top was so thick that it masked the taste of the eggplant. The sauce had absolutely no flavor! I don't want to be mean so I'll leave it at that. I did hear from a friend that the pizzas are good but at this point I'm just not impressed. At all.

This place is a gem! The pasta is clearly made with love and the sauces are incredible. I especially loved the lasagna, it tasted like my grandma's. The grocery section has a great selection of Italian goods too. Highly recommend!

We are from California and we came here for the annual Tulsa kickoff tournament. We came here on a very busy day. I ordered 2 kids Mac and cheese and fettuccine Alfredo, along with an eggplant parmigiano spaghetti, and a side of house made Caesar salad. The food was delicious, but the fettuccine Alfredo was the highlight! It was the best one out of everything we ordered. The environment is loud, so it's perfect for families with children.

Stopped in to this restaurant...not knowing what to expect, hoping for an Itallian sausage sandwhich....but no luck, so we made our own and ordered 2 sausages in marinara and cheese focaccia bread, and ate them together.Sausage was good, traditional seasoned, and the bread reminiscent of the loaves at Macaroni Grill, only with cheese!! We sat, we ate, we laughed. We enjoyed the food...wasn't exactly what we were looking for, but it worked!They have lots of offerings, soups, pastas and pizzas...maybe next time. Staff was friendly, restaurant clean and bright...if you remember it from before, it has definitely had a serious facelift!

Nice little neighborhood gem. Great selection of house made pasta dishes. We've been going since they opened and hope to continue to come from many years.

Nice little "hole in the wall" kind of place. Overall the food is great. The chicken parm is quite good, and I love their bolognese. I wish the tomato sauce had a bit more of a kick, but there's plenty of other items to choose from.Can't go wrong with the pizza!We somehow always end up spending at least $50 for two dinners lol. The tiramisu is very good, and it's nice that there's outside seating for the warmer months.It is counter service, so be prepared for that.

My favorite restaurant! The most delicious, authentic Italian food. The brown butter pasta with grilled chicken is perfection. Their focaccia bread and homemade butter is delicious, as is the gelato. Incredible environment and the friendliest staff! Food is freshly made and you never have to wait long to get it. I don't live in Tulsa, but I come here every chance I get!

We found this very ordinary. The goat cheese salad had oddly cold, soggy cubes of pork belly or jowl that were disconcerting and unappealing. Caesar had food-service croutons, which are bad and easily replaced with delicious croutons that are made fresh. We got three different pasta dishes, one either Gorgonzola, one lemon and one Alfredo. All three were quite unremarkable. The pasta was freshly made but stuck together in clumps. Meh.