Gaetano's Pizzeria & Creamery

Ok first time visit, I should have gotten the name of the woman at the counter, she's a delight! Not only was she super pleasant but she 1000% was trying to get what I ordered put on the menu! So what we ordered was the bacon cheeseburger calzone but as a pizza. If you want to do this here's my suggestion take the 1000 island dressing from their salads use as sauce base add meats and cheese and cook, maybe butter the crust and add sesame seeds at end of bake. Seriously those pizza rolls are KILLER, nice size, full of flavor and pepperoni and dusted with delicious Italian seasonings! We both ate 2 rolls and 2 slices, went home with leftovers and don't even need dinner tonight. The service is so GOOD HERE. Please forgive my photos I remembered to take them after I had already snatched a couple rolls and the pizza slices but seriously don't sleep on this place. Their menu is limited but very well executed and they also have ICE CREAM!!!! Clean space, clean restrooms, plenty of seating and more than ample parking! We will definitely be back!!!

We love Gaetano's for their mouthwatering Pizzas & Pastas! The Gaetano's Supreme is piled high with chunky meats and veges and loaded with savory deliciousness! And their lasagna may be my favorite dish on the menu! It's packed with savory, Italian flavor! Oh So Good! Although we've not had an opportunity to dine in, the food has always been delivered hot and fresh! My husband recently popped by to pick up dinner and said the restaurant was very clean and the staff was super friendly! They also have a variety of Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream! I hope your experience is as good as ours! *And be sure to check out their weekly specials!

Gaetano's Pizzeria has one of the best pizzas in Jenks with The Confluence of Ten Toppings. I have ordered for delivery along with the large Caesar Salad several times. The restaurant consistently delivers with a golden crust, ample toppings, and overall satisfaction. They provide delivery through DoorDash and the service has been excellent. I look forward to visiting the restaurant in person soon to try their ice cream and experience the atmosphere.

First time here. Most likely won't be back. Took just at an hour to place order and get our food. I ordered a lunch size pizza, salad and drink. My husband ordered a grilled chicken sandwich. The menu online said it came with a salad but was told came with chips. Sad that it took an hour for this. Yes they were busy and only 2 people working. I get that. I felt bad as there were 2 guys that left without getting their orders and told the gal working there and she never asked about refunding them their money. Just know lunch time could be pushing it if you have to get back to work or be some place.The pizza was decent and salad was good. My husband said his sandwich was good.

Really good pizza. Brought my 5 year old son here and we both enjoyed it. Was not busy at all for dine in on a Thursday night.

I ordered dinner for a pickup. I had lasagna, which was very tasty. Wife had the roasted penni with delicious red sauce. And a dinner salad, which was better than expected.Meal included fresh bread sticks which was worth the price!As I was checking out, I saw the small but nicely supplied ice cream. Strawberry gelato and chocolate swirl looking ice cream. Both, by nature of the product, melted deliciously down your throat.Entire meal was delicious. Now we've had pizza from there before, too. The Chicken Alfredo is outstanding.Have you ever been at a establishment where the individual that's running the cash register, had no personality at all. They don't even say thanks for coming in, or anything.I was met by this teenager and gave her my monies for dinner. After that I noticed the ice cream bar. That's when she left the cash register, put on her gloves and began helping me.Big deal you say, but she was exceptional, have the ability of making people feel welcomed. Respectful, too.Having a staff and service such as this will always bring me back!

So we decided to give Gaetanos another try because I just love their Raspberry salad dressing so much. So we started ordering again a few weeks ago and it went good for awhile. I mainly just get the salad every time (sometimes a pasta here and there) but the last few times I got a salad, some of my greens had moisture and were browning already. At first, it was just a little bit and picked out the bad ones and enjoyed the rest of the salad. But the most recent salad, about a quarter of my salad had moisture and browning, it was really unappetizing to be honest. This is all WITHOUT dressing, I had to pick out all the bad ones and even then I kinda didn't even want to eat the rest of the salad. Keep in mind, this is third time this has happened in one week! (Yes, we know, kinda a lot for one week but I've been on a salad craze lately). Very disappointing since I was giving them a second chance and I really do love their salads.Update***** What is the point of having an online ordering service that doesn't let you "Guest Checkout" 95% of the time? It's been awhile since I've placed an order so I can't seemTo remember my sign in at all! So of course I click the "forgot password" option. But guess what? No matter how many times I click it and type in my email address, it does not work. I never received an email. (And yes, I've checked my junk mail also). So I go ahead and guest checkout and what does it do? Clear my whole order. Again and again and again. Pretty annoying right?

This place makes some awesome pizza. We love to get their specialty pizzas and their salads. We eat here pretty regularly and have never been disappointed. I love supporting a local business and hope the best for their future success.

This place is a tad overrated. I believe the ratings have something to do with the lack of options in the area. I ate here once and was really disappointed. I would say unequivocally and without doubt that "QT has better pizza."Will give it one more try and post another review.

Really good pizza really good service overall really recommend this place, cheesy bread is where it's at especially with their buffalo sauce