Crab & Catfish

I couldn't wait to write my review! I just finished the best lunch ever. They have great lunch specials. I got a shrimp and crab boil and a basket of waffle fries, and it could have fed 3 people! I can't wait to eat my leftovers. I paid a little extra for spicy butter and Cajun seasoning, and it was SO delicious. It's pricey, but seafood always is. And I think the lunch prices are exceptionally reasonable for portion size! The lady working the register was awesome. Even though you order at the counter, she came around and checked on people multiple times. Delivered boxes and bags to the table. Refilled drinks. She was great. It's spacious and clean inside with the whole table set up to keep things clean and tidy. Because a boil can be a bit messy. I will absolutely be back.

This was a subpar seafood boil place. When you order you order at a register. My lobster tail was over cooked. The boil did not cover with much juices and everything was just warm. The bathroom was not clean. The seasoning on the seafood was good but experience was subpar.

This is a fairly new seafood place in Broken Arrow that offers fried or boils. Slightly above average, more like 3.5 stars though.Got a #6 boil which included 1 crab cluster, 8 shrimps, 1 lobster tail, sausage egg, corn, and potatoes. The price was fair at $35.99. The original flavor was okay, slightly salty, similar to Cajun. Shrimps were pre-peeled, and tasted not as great as shell-on shrimps, but less work to eat. Lobster tail was my favorite. Crab meat was a little cold to me. A majority of the boil was POTATOES, a piece of corn, a whole sausage, and 2 boiled eggs; none of which I cared for. Could I get more seafood instead?This is not a full service seafood restaurant either. You order the food at the counter. They bring the food to your table. You get your own drink.

Pros: I thought this was a new restaurant that opened, but really this is just the broken arrow location of crab Kings. My husband likes crab kings, so not a problem for him. I do not like crab kings. I don't like the quality of their seafood, I don't like that they use an artificial butter instead of a real butter, and I don't like that they over boiled their seafood. But for people who like crab kings, they have a broken arrow location. Cons: the waitress kept upselling us. There were all these hidden charges. I didn't realize that if you add an egg to your meal, they charge you the price of the egg and then they charge you $.30 for more mix. And then if you order an extra corn, they charge the price of the corn and then $.30 for extra mix. I ordered extra butter thinking that it would be just a container of butter. But what they did was they flooded or to go Styrofoam box with butter. And they got our order wrong. The meal we bought has two clusters of crab. They gave us four. Great! However, our meal was supposed to come with sausage which really balances out the flavors and they forgot that.

Food quality, serving sizes, and prices were excellent - 5 stars all the way! The decor is bland; inspired by airport food-courts, but hey - the flavorful food makes it great anyway. I loved the Fried Shrimp Basket, and my wife enjoyed the Fried Catfish & Lobster Tail Basket. We had never seen a fried lobster-tail, but it was good!Order at the counter & pick your seats! I hope to return for more.

We had high hopes for this place considering previous reviews. First, the positives. The establishment is clean, the staff is friendly. Now, the negatives. My wife ordered the catfish basket with sweet potato tots. I ordered the Jumbo Shrimp basket with onion rings. The food price is reasonable and they do give you a good quantity of food.......but every piece of the catfish was mushy and although piping hot, it was grossly undercooked. My wife liked the breading on the fish of what little she ate. She stated the tots were ok, but not worthy of ordering again. My shrimp had the same breading and I did not like it one bit. I actually took it off to just eat the shrimp plain. The shrimp would've gotten a higher rating if they had the same batter the onion rings had. The tartar sauce also needed some work. It was too vinegary and not enough dill. Unfortunately, we will cross this establishment off of any return visits in our future. Caveat Emptor

A solid choice for a seafood boil. They give a healthy portion for a good price. Myself and my wife enjoy the food.

This place has been here less than a year and we were glad to try it out. The lady working said that weekends are busy. We came an hour before closing. Crab bites had good flavor, were a greasy breaded fried type, yummy but we were wishing for a dipping sauce. The real butter sauce in the Legs and Tails platter was flavorful. The shrimp and lobster cooked to perfection. Plenty of food, we were able to box some up to go. Overall this place reminds me of a quaint modern day Joe's Crab Shack with better food. We would come back, maybe for a causal lunch. This place is also family and kid friendly with videos playing and pop music. Lastly, try the frozen daiquiris. They are refreshing and not too sweet.

Very impressed with this place. We have traveled across the south multiple times and the food is amazing. So we are always skeptical on these kind of places. For Broken Arrow Oklahoma this place is great. We got the bayou seasoning and spot on. The service was really good. The lobby is nothing special but comfortable. We got the boil for 2 and really enjoyed it. If in the area, try it out.

Best seafood boil around! The place is great and spacious and nicely decorated with big tables (cause it gets messy!). They even had a Missing Man Table for November honoring Veterans which was just such a nice touch. The woman who attended to us was very nice and helped explained all the options and there is definitely a lot of options. The food flavors were beyond explosive. I choose non spicy but it still had a kick. They have many flavors to choose from so it would be interesting to try them all (e.g. garlic honey). They also seem to have a nice bar with frozen drinks and beer, alcohol selection. My favorite was that they went the extra mile and provided gloves which I have never encountered and was very convenient. The only feedback I'd give is to provide actual fresh lemons instead of lemon packets.