Cindy's Pizza

Bought one of Cindy's frozen pizzas at the Oasis on the west side of town. It was very good. Easy to put it in the oven for a quick meal. Definitely better than frozen options at the grocery store.

The best Pizza in Stillwater hands down. Cindy is a very sweet woman and cares about her customers and the quality of the pizza!! I will definitely be ordering again.

Skip Hideaway and get you a pizza from Cindy's. Best part about Cindy's, outside of the pizza, is the box has a target on the back. Awesome.

They don't have burnt crusts like the Hideaway.I will try them again to get some of their signature garlic bread. They don't seem bothered to have customers come into their business like so many other places in town. I wish they would put some wax paper under the pizzas so that we could recycle the box.

We're visiting OSU from the east coast and this is the Best pizza ever! At first I thought it a little strange that we were going into a grocery to pick up our Pizza but not strange anymore. That crust is what dreams are made of.

It looked like cafeteria pizza from back in grade school. The taste was ok but it was undercooked. The pizza used to be great when they were at the old location located on Husband Street. The recipe or oven used seems different from the original location.

Best pizza, garlic knots, garlic cheese bread, and cheesecake in Stillwater! Cindy is also super friendly

literally the best pizza in stillwater! you can tell these people really care about their customers AND their pizza. personally, i think this place is better than the hideaway. highly recommend their garlic knots and the crust on their pizza is AMAZING! if i could give it more than 5 stars i would!