Andolini's Pizzeria Broken Arrow

We were hungry and wanted some pizza, and were told this was the place to go. We decided to sit inside and had a table near the window. Our server was friendly and told us about the menu - so many choices it was hard to decide. We ordered the eggplant appetizer and fried mozzarella along with two pizzas. The apps came out quickly. Who doesn't love mozzarella / so good. The eggplant appetizer was good but a little thick and hard to cut. We finally decided on a cheese pizza and one with mushroom, onion, bell pepper and pepperoni. When the pizzas came out they looked amazing and tasted good but neither one was hot. I usually cut the first few bites until it cools, but this was disappointing when I took the first bite. Our server was new but she was great. We always had drinks and empty plates removed. We had to get boxes because we ordered too much food.So...yes the food tasted good but the pizza wasn't hot, and the eggplant was a little thick. The indoor and outdoor seating was nice and the service was very good. Maybe we just had an off night, so we will try it again sometime.

My husband and I stopped by for the weekday lunch special. The price is very reasonable for what you get. Unfortunately, my husband and I did not like the pasta. The meat sauce was minimal and very watery, and the texture of the meat was odd. My husband had the caesar salad and said he would not get it again. First, it had almost no dressing on it so he asked for more, then we actually got to taste the dressing he said the flavor was very strange. For the good, the pizza was delicious! Thin crispy crust, delicious sauce, and the perfect amount of cheese. I would get the pizza again, but the pasta and salad were a miss.

In the phots in our today's order... the spaghetti was off today. I haven't had the spaghetti in a while, maybe something was changed? It is bland. Hopefully they add some broth to in later visits.. We had to ask for refills on drinks.. haven't had that before. Maybe this was an off Sunday. Pizza nailed it! Bruschetta, I wish there were actual Roma tomatoes in this go-around.... That was off too. But the bruschetta needed something else too... more "oomph!!"

The unlimited lunch for 13.49 is one of my favorites splurges. The Caesar salad is delicious, every single 'za is magnificent, and the staff is always so attentive. Plus, you can't beat the ambiance of having porcelain busts of Julius Caesar staring at you from above.

Ordered to-go Combo pizza tonight. Pizza was fresh and delish. Luv the Christmas decor! Service was quick! Highly recommended!

Good was amazing! Love the Athenian Pizza and salad was delicious. We ordered take out for the football games today and we have nothing negative to say! Andolini's never disappoints!

Best BBQ Chicken pizza there is!! Toasted onion strings on top make it the bomb. Never had a bad pizza here,

As someone who has grown up in BA and has spun pizzas, won pizza awards, and tasted pies from nearly every state, I approached this restaurant with high hopes. The ambience here is fantastic--warm, inviting, and perfect for a relaxing meal. However, the pizza didn't quite hit the mark for me.Every time I've ordered, whether to go or dining in, the pizza has been undercooked and overloaded with cheese. In my book, a true wood-fired pizza is all about balance and simplicity. Unfortunately, this spot's style and toppings just don't do it for me.True delicious pizza has a "less is more" vibe. I would love to see them lessen the size, reduce the cheese portions, and stay true to a more simplistic wood-fired approach. With these adjustments, I believe they could really elevate their offerings and create something special.

I ordered a pizza to be delivered and I have had to go orders and when my brother comes home he says we ALWAYS have to go to Andolinis because he loves the Strombol. I have yet to be disappointed with anything we order! Hands down best pizz!

Review of Andolini's Pizza in the Rose DistrictOur Sunday night visit to Andolini's in the Rose District hit the spot, delivering pizza perfection in a cozy, family-friendly setting. From their classic pies to the new deep-dish offering, it's safe to say Andolini's knows how to serve up some seriously satisfying pizza.The FoodLet's talk about the star of the show: the pizza.Deep Dish Pizza (ROMAN Custom): My wife and I decided to give this one a shot, and it did not disappoint. Thick, cheesy, and loaded with toppings, each slice was a comforting, indulgent bite of pizza heaven. The crust had that perfect balance of crispy edges and a fluffy interior, soaking up just the right amount of sauce. We chose double Candian Bacon and Fresh Mozzarella for the three toppings. It's safe to say we'll be ordering this again.Classic Medium Cheese Pizza: Andolini's does the classics as well as they do the bold experiments. The cheese pizza was everything you want -- a perfectly made crust with just the right amount of crunch, and bubbling cheese. It was a hit with the teenage "I only want Pizza" kid. Even our pickiest eater was happy, which is always a win!Cheese Pizza (Kid-Approved): For the little guy, the cheese pizza delivered simplicity at its finest. Gooey cheese, a flavorful tomato sauce, and a thin, perfectly cooked crust -- no complaints here (they will give the kids dough to play with before the meal gets there.) The VibeThe Rose District location has a warm, inviting atmosphere, with twinkling lights adding a festive touch to the space, they have their own take on "the chute" overhead. The service was friendly and efficient, and even though it was busy (as you'd expect on a Sunday night), everything came out hot and fresh.Final ThoughtsAndolini's is the kind of place where you know you're going to get a consistently great meal, whether you stick to your tried-and-true favorites or venture into something new like the deep dish. Their attention to quality ingredients and perfect execution shines through in every bite.If you're in the Rose District and craving pizza, Andolini's is a must. You will have to drive around for a bit to get a parking spot up close, but I think we call could afford a few extra steps after a big meal like this. We'll definitely be back for more -- especially for that deep dish!