The Craft Creamery

Friendly staff, SUPER cute atmosphere, delicious ice cream flavors!!!! They have revolving flavors that are from different ice cream establishments. They offer ice cream and coffee... imagine an affogato!!? To die for! There is a sushi spot right next door that has amazing specials. Go get sushi, then finish it off with ice cream. Please bring back UBE!!

Stopped here on the way home from Sunset Cliffs. When we walked in, the place was packed with fellow ice cream lovers. There are a bunch of bar stools with a limited tables and chairs for you to sit and savor your ice cream. Nothing fancy but you're not really here for the atmosphere-- it's the yummy creamy ice cream!There were many ice cream scoopers on hand to handle the rush. Staff is very helpful and friendly. Samples were offered upon request to ensure that proper flavor choices were made. Even though my ice cream order was misheard it was quickly rectified with NO hesitation whatsoever and an apologetic smile. For those dairy-free folks, there are oat milk ice cream options too. And if you thought of the delicious ice cream wasn't enough, you're in for a magical surprise. Be sure to grab the pink spoon -- it changes colors from pink to purple while you eat your ice cream. So FUN!!! One thing I found odd was that there were no napkins. So be prepared to not be messy eating your ice cream.

I loveeeee this place! Such a fun concept to have rotating ice cream flavors from various places. Great amount for a single scoop - $5My favorite is the Tillamook flavors or when they have anything from Molly Moons!

Super friendly staff, stopped by on a Tuesday evening and there was absolutely no line! I got the mint chip and toasted coconut and pineapple and holy cannoli, the coconut pineapple was SO GOOD. I can't figure out which creamery it's from and it's killing me, but it took me straight back to childhood.

Luscious, creamy vegan options with our favorite being the soy mint chip. The scoops are huge and the counter servers are so friendly. I love this place for all its deliciousness and positive vibes.

A source and distributor for local ice cream that shares space with Moniker Coffee. Get your cold treats and hot drinks all at one place!This small shop accessed through street parking has a few stools and benches for dine in, however it was a bit dark with minimal interior lighting when the sun was setting. There weren't too many traditional seats typically seen in coffee shops but it seemed the espresso machine wasn't the main attraction; the ice cream was!Due to the variety of flavors, it was challenging to decide at first but because of the limited stock and the ability to sample flavors, we were able to make our choices and start devouring our cones. I ended up with the Exhausted Parent which has a coffee base with chocolate chips.The service was exceptional and they were extremely patient with us as we took some time to pick the flavors we wanted to purchase. They also have color changing spoons which the kids find super amazing.In addition to scoops and cones, they also sell the ice cream by the pint. Find a flavor you just absolutely must take home to enjoy later!Overall, The Craft Creamery is a decent option to get a taste of local ice cream without having to make the trek to each one of those locations and is typically quiet enough for you to get in and out quickly without much of a hassle. Street parking can be a bummer but the side streets in the neighborhood usually have space. If you're a local or out of towner, you may want to consider making your way to taste The Craft!

The best ice cream spot near shelter island. Have been gaining here a couple times a year with family with dessert after dinner. The service is super quick and everyone is very nice. They let you try any flavor you want. They also frequently change their flavors and usually have 1-2 soy options. The kid scoop alone is a LOT of ice cream. The single scoop is humongous for one person, probably equals to a pint of ice cream from the grocery store. For 80 cents more, you can choose two different flavors for the single scoop. The lavender and espresso were our favorite. The Lavender flavor is stronger than any other lavender ice cream we've tried which we loved.

Cute little ice cream spot in Point Loma :) They feature a wide variety of different ice creams/gelato/sorbets from ice cream shops around the country. The two staff members were friendly, they were also working the Moniker coffee bar -- I have to try that next time, it was too late for coffee for me.My son got the Strawberry ice cream (Tillamook) and it was so good! We've never had Tillamook before -- super creamy. I got a scoop of the Mango Tangerine sorbet (I forgot where it came from) and it was to die for -- really refreshing. We'll def have to come back and get a flight. I wish I got the Cookie Monster ice cream, hopefully it'll be there next time.

What a beautiful concept to open an ice cream & coffee shop all in one. I'm still thinking about this ice cream I had on Sunday. I tried the flight which comes with 4 kids sized scoops (that are equivalent to your avg sized scoop of ice cream). For flavors I got the London fog, pistachio, rich chocolate brownie, and a banana based ice cream with peanut butter & chocolate chips. I forgot the names of the last two! If you like pistachio, you must try their pistachio ice cream. They do not skimp on the pieces of pistachio in this ice cream and I think this may be the best pistachio ice cream I've ever had. I need to grab a whole pint next time I goThe banana flavored one with peanut butter swirl was also a favorite! I mean we finished all 4 scoops and left very happy I'd love to go back to try some coffee through Moniker Co :)

TL;DR: hidden shop that carries flavors from multiple craft creameries from around the country. Super fun tasting and generous scoops - excellent service!Wanted something sweet after lunch so stopped by Craft Creamery and weren't disappointed. They had 4 different creameries with multiple flavors for each available for any size bowl/cone all the way up to hand-packed pints!Ordered the Fat Elvis (Banana base + chocolate + peanuts/PB) originating from the Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream shop out of Madison, WI. SO GOODWish they made and carried some of their own flavors but doesn't seem like that's part of their business plan :/The servers were very patient with all the samples and gave us very generous scoop sizesI'll be back next time in the area looking for my sugar fixCheers, Craft Creamery!