Fudge Brownie
Key Lime
a man walking in front of the pie factory
a display of pastries and pastries
outside
Key Lime Pie
donuts, interior
Whipped cream frosting with strawberry filling
Carmel Apple, Tiramisu, Key Lime and Triple Layer Carrot Cake
Strawberry Rhubarb. Good!
Awesome Apple Pie
Inside
Key Lime Pie
Toucan sampler pie
Key lime
Cookie / Pie Display
The pie case
Key lime pie
Cookies
New York cheesecake
Inside
Key lime regular size
Toucan's Sampler
pizza
Kayla H.
Nov 3, 2024
This place has been opened for 35 years! 35! Holy cow! I had a best friend years ago and her and I would literally make it a thing to come here and grab a slice of quiche Loraine because we absolutely loved it! So that was about 16 years ago. So it's been 16 years since I've been back to this place. After a plant run with my mom I asked her if she had ever been here before and she said she has never been here before so we decided to check it out. My mom said she felt like she stepped into a 1960's pie / coffee shop which I totally understood those vibes. The one lady which was not the owner was super sweet and kind. So very helpful and kept the coffee coming. The owner was there and honestly she didn't seem friendly, we didn't deal with her at all, she didn't smile, was not welcoming and although it's a long time in business I would think she would understand customers service. I must say the Kamala Harris rally's that she had on the tvs was a major turn off for business. I'm not just saying that because I'm a Trump fan. I believe that needs to stay out of your place of business....if you want to put signs that's your choice and freedom but I do not think it should be on repeat on your place of business TVs. Other than that will still be back to order holiday pies this year.
Read More
Diane H.
Feb 24, 2025
The call in New York cheesecake and the texture is spot on. But it lacks flavor in my opinion. I was left with an odd aftertaste. My friend liked his peach pie. I had the Key lime once before and I wasn't impressed.
Read More
Leigh N.
Feb 15, 2025
The apricot pockets were hard, the filling hard and chewy... not what I was expecting. The taste was really off, like they used margarine instead of butter... just a weird chemical taste I couldn't put my finger on, but I wound up tossing them out. $7 for a slice of pie from a counter is insane. Coffee from a thermos so I didn't even bother.
Read More
Thomas S.
Jul 27, 2024
I have one word. WOW!!!! We got 2 pies, key lime, and sampler. As well as some extra pieces. Walking into this place we were amazed by the smell of the pies cakes and cookies. We were helped immediately and the lady in the front was very patient with us with our ordering.
Read More
Patricia F.
Mar 24, 2024
I was not a fan. The place seemed very chaotic when we went and it took a minute for someone to acknowledge us. We ordered 2 slices of pie to go and I did not finish mine. I had the chocolate pie and it lacked that nice creamy silk chocolate flavor and texture that I am used to with chocolate pies. The crust was very dry and tasteless as well. I am one and done with this place.
Read More
Vero P.
Dec 6, 2023
We felt welcomed when we entered. They did a custom order & it tasted like someone's grandmother made it with love. Thanks for making this bday so special.
Read More
Jennifer P.
May 30, 2024
This wasn't a coffee and pie shop like we expected. Coffee was served from a pump thermos (weak coffee). They have quite a variety of desserts, to be sure, but I'm not sure how many are actually made from scratch at this location. We ordered a couple of refrigerated fruit pie slices and requested them warmed but they were served basically room temperature. I'm not sure I quite understand the appeal exactly (unless maybe you don't bake or need a fast dessert to serve), but the clerk/cashier was pleasant and the interior was clean, so we appreciated that. The high Yelp reviews for this place misled us. To each his own, I guess.
Read More
Anant K.
Apr 21, 2024
Every pie taste great here and you can get it by the slice or the whole thing. The best thing is the drive-through for convenience to get a gourmet type dessert. Amazing service.
Read More
Mark P.
Nov 29, 2024
Great pies and super nice staff. Will definitely come back! The overall selection of pies is huge
Read More
Matthew L.
Jul 8, 2024
Ordered a special birthday cake. Checking the cake before leaving, I noticed they didn't write "Happy Birthday" on the cake. To remedy the situation, they slapped a plastic "happy birthday" cheap sign rather than write in icing. Thats right - a "custom" cake, but instead of piping out the message on the cake, just put a cheap sign on it.Also, the cake was dry. I was so embarrassed as most of the guests are in the hospitality industry. If you have a special occasion, skip this one and go to Publix. They at least write on the cakes.
Read More