Supreme Pizza
a pepperoni pizza
Outside
Wall pictures
All drinks are in a can or bottle
a shelf of t - shirts
the outside of the building
a sign for the restaurant
the front of the building
a buffalo bills sign and a buffalo bills sign
the front of the building
drink
CUP N CHAR PIZZA!!!! (Small pre cooked to go)
Buffalo food for sale
Entertaining & clean dining area
The Buffalo stop
Meat Lovers Pizza
Veggie Pizza
Pepperoni pizza
Axe throwing, they did not provide any information on when this is available
Russell W.
Feb 9, 2025
A great little place with Buffalo memorabilia. Ordered a small cheese, pepperoni and mushroom pizza. It was very good. Reminded me of buffalo food. The place is just a beautiful little place. If you wanna see Buffalo Bills and Sabres posters Jim Kelley, Josh Allen, and many others Sabres memorabilia the pizza was awesome. There is also a display with Buffalo type food. The service was great. I love the ambience the whole place with TVs and the Sabres and Bill stuff. Great price for the pizzas.
Read More
Marilyn W.
Jan 26, 2025
AWESOME!!!! We are snowbirds from Buffalo and loved it here!!! The decor was amazing and the pizza delicious just like home. We will be back and highly recommend!!!
Read More
Marilyn S.
Aug 30, 2024
Pizza is always outstanding! Location expanded and has a shopping area with many Buffalo favorites! Lots of TVs, definitely a great place to watch the games while enjoying a Labatt Blue and a slice! Order at counter, they bring you food. If you get wings ask for extra crispy, regular crispy didn't quite get there.
Read More
Dana M.
Jun 5, 2024
Wonderful as always!! They have added a lot of wall decor since my last visit. Staff is welcoming and the vibe is incredible for Buffalo folk. They have even got a little "shop" with all things Buffalo for sale.
Read More
Christi K.
Mar 8, 2024
Okay WOW! MIC DROP! Their pizza is sooooooo good! Thicker crust, bold flavored sauce and cheesy deliciousness! I LOVE that their pepperoni is thicker. Only real downside is their garlic knots. Not much flavor and butter didn't have a garlic flavor at all! Hopefully it was just an off night . Very New York ambiance and I love it!
Read More
Kevin S.
Jan 10, 2024
Great representation of Buffalo pizza...Great crust and pepperoni...I give them a solid 8 out of 10...If you're from Buffalo check it out...Buffalo memorabilia everyone...One TV had a stream a Ray/Domi fights lol.
Read More
Katrina M.
Jun 1, 2024
The restaurant is small but the food is delicious! Best sandwich I've had in a long time. Wings are full of flavor and pizza is just amazing.
Read More
Sue T.
Dec 30, 2023
Royal sub... not enough sausage, more bread then meat.Garlic knots-huge & delish, sauce it came with was great!BOW , bottom of roll was soggyI asked for light on salt & kemmelweck hardly got anything, oh dear.The roast beef had a weird taste .the seasoning , didn't like. Yes, born & raised in Buffalo , never got a soggy roll & always had enough sausage on my sub.Will I return , probably not. Drove to far for this, no thank you.
Read More
Jim M.
Oct 27, 2024
I finally tried 716 Pizza Joint for our Saturday pizza night and am I glad I did. We got two small pizzas and we loved them. The wife's Vegetarian pie looked great and my Pepperoni was great. The price won't break the bank, the service was friendly and quick.This Pizza Parlor is truly a hidden gem that I will be back for more.
Read More
Joe R.
Sep 28, 2024
After hearing good comments about 716, we decided to give it a try. All i can say is after a $100.00 order we were VERY DISAPPOINTED!! The pizza was fair at best. The WINGS were OLD ,Tuff and DRY. The sub was not toasted, little meat. The salad was GOOD.So may daughter called and to our surprise the nice cordial people, turned into ASSHOLES !!!Never will go back !!
Read More