Taste Of New York Pizzeria

Our Famous NY Style Pizza

Cheese Pizza - Medium 14"

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$18.05
Cheese Pizza - Large 16"

Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$19.35
White Pizza with Ricotta - Medium 14"
$23.25
White Pizza with Ricotta - Large 16"
$24.49
White Spinach Pizza with Ricotta - Medium 14"
$24.49
White Spinach Pizza with Ricotta - Large 16"
$25.79
Hawaiian Pizza - Medium 14"

Ham & pineapple.
$24.49
Hawaiian Pizza - Large 16"

Ham & pineapple.
$25.79
Special Pizza - Medium 14"

Your choice of 5 toppings.
$25.79
Special Pizza - Large 16"

Your choice of 5 toppings.
$27.09
Mediterranean Pizza - Medium 14"

Tomatoes, spinach, garlic, feta, kalamata olives.
$25.79
Mediterranean Pizza - Large 16"

Tomatoes, spinach, garlic, feta, kalamata olives.
$27.09
Supreme Pizza - Medium 14"

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions & green peppers.
$25.79
Supreme Pizza - Large 16"

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions & green peppers.
$27.09
Meat Lover's Pizza - Medium 14"

Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, ham, bacon.
$25.79
Meat Lover's Pizza - Large 16"

Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, ham, bacon.
$27.09
Veggie Pizza - Medium 14"

Tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and black olives.
$25.79
Veggie Pizza - Large 16"

Tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and black olives.
$27.09
Chicken Parmigiana Pizza - Medium 14"
$25.79
Chicken Parmigiana Pizza - Large 16"
$27.09
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - Medium 14"
$25.79
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - Large 16"
$27.09
Eggplant Pizza - Medium 14"

Eggplant, spinach & ricotta cheese.
$25.79
Eggplant Pizza - Large 16"

Eggplant, spinach & ricotta cheese.
$27.09
Margherita Pizza - Medium 14"

Plum tomatoes, mozzarella, garlic, basil.
$24.49
Margherita Pizza - Large 16"

Plum tomatoes, mozzarella, garlic, basil.
$25.79
Sicilian Cheese Pizza - Large 16"

Thick pan pizza.
$21.89
Sicilian Special Pizza - Large 16"

Choice of 5 toppings.
$29.65
Grandma's Pizza - Large 16"

Thin pan pizza with plum tomatoes, basil, garlic, and mozzarella.
$24.49

Appetizers

Mozzarella Sticks - 6 Pieces
$10.30
Chicken Wings - 6 Pieces

Buffalo, mild,medium, hot, BBQ, garlic parmesan.
$11.59
Chicken Wings - 12 Pieces

Buffalo, mild,medium, hot, BBQ, garlic parmesan.
$18.05
Chicken Wings - 20 Pieces

Buffalo, mild,medium, hot, BBQ, garlic parmesan.
$28.39
Chicken Tenders - 5 Pieces
$10.30
French Fries - Appetizers
$6.45
Side Salad

Ranch Greek Italian
$2.59
Onion Rings - Appetizers
$6.45
Garlic Bread - Appetizers
$6.15
Garlic Bread with Cheese - Appetizers
$7.45
Garlic Rolls - 6 Pieces
$5.15
Garlic Rolls - 12 Pieces
$7.75
Side of Meatballs - Appetizers
$7.75
Side of Beef Sausage - Appetizers
$7.75
Side of Meatballs with Cheese - Appetizers
$9.05
Side of Beef Sausage with Cheese - Appetizers
$9.05
side fries
$2.59

Salads

Garden Salad - Small

Lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, olives, banana peppers, pepperoncini.
$9.05
Garden Salad - Large

Lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, olives, banana peppers, pepperoncini.
$11.59
Greek Salad - Small

Lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, olives, banana peppers, pepperoncini, potato salad & feta cheese.
$10.35
Greek Salad - Large

Lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, olives, banana peppers, pepperoncini, potato salad & feta cheese.
$12.90
Antipasto Salad - Large

Ham, salami, pepperoni, cheese, lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, olives, banana peppers, & pepperoncini.
$14.20
Grilled Chicken Salad - Large

Lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, olives, banana peppers, pepperoncini with grilled chicken.
$14.20

Rolls

Pepperoni Roll with Ricotta - Rolls
$12.90
Chicken Roll with Ricotta - Rolls
$12.90
Eggplant Roll with Ricotta - Rolls
$12.90
Beef Sausage, Pepper & Onion Roll - Rolls
$12.90

Hot Subs

Meatball Parmigiana Sub - 12"
$14.20
Beef Sausage Parmigiana Sub - 12"
$14.20
Eggplant Parmigiana Sub - 12"
$14.20
Chicken Parmigiana Sub - 12"
$14.20
Beef Sausage, Peppers & Onions Sub - 12"
$14.20
Philly Cheese Steak Sub - 12"
$12.90
Philly Special Sub - 12"

Mushrooms, onions, green peppers.
$14.20
Philly Chicken & Cheese Sub - 12"
$12.90
Philly Chicken Special Sub - 12"

Mushrooms, onions, green peppers.
$14.20
Grilled Chicken Sub - 12"

Lettuce, tomato & onions.
$14.20

Dinners

Pasta with Tomato Sauce - Dinners
$12.90
Pasta with Meatballs - Dinners
$15.49
Pasta with Beef Sausage - Dinners
$15.49
Pasta with Beef Sausage, Peppers & Onions - Dinners
$16.75
Ravioli with Tomato Sauce - Dinners
$16.75

Oven Baked Dinners

Chicken Parmigiana - Dinner

With a side of pasta.
$19.35
Chicken Siciliano - Dinner

Breaded chicken topped with ham, eggplant, mozzarella cheese & baked in tomato sauce, with a side of pasta.
$20.65
Baked Ziti - Dinner
$16.75
Ziti Siciliano - Dinner
$18.05
Eggplant Parmigiana - Dinner
$16.75
Eggplant Rollatini - Dinner
$18.05
Manicotti - Dinner
$16.75
Stuffed Shells - Dinner
$16.75
Baked Cheese Ravioli - Dinner
$18.05

Desserts

Cannoli - Desserts
$5.15
Cheesecake - Desserts
$5.15
Tiramisu - Desserts
$5.15
Zeppoli - Desserts
$5.15

Beverages

12 oz. Can Soda - 12 oz. Can
$2.59
20 oz. Bottled Soda - 20 oz. Bottled
$3.89
2 Liter Bottled Soda - 2 Liter Bottled
$5.55
Water - Bottled
$1.95

Appetizers Catering

Meatballs Catering - Half Tray
$64.49
Meatballs Catering - Full Tray
$109.65
Beef Sausage Catering - Half Tray
$64.49
Beef Sausage Catering - Full Tray
$109.65
Garlic Knots Catering - Half Tray
$25.79
Garlic Knots Catering - Full
$38.69

Salads Catering

Garden Salad Catering - Half Tray
$38.69
Garden Salad Catering - Full Tray
$64.49
Greek Salad Catering - Half Tray
$45.15
Greek Salad Catering - Full Tray
$77.39
Antipasto Salad Catering - Half Tray
$64.49
Antipasto Salad Catering - Full Tray
$109.65

Oven Baked Dinners Catering

Baked Ravioli Catering - Half Tray
$54.19
Baked Ravioli Catering - Full Tray
$92.89
Baked Ziti Catering - Half Tray
$60.65
Baked Ziti Catering - Full Tray
$105.79
Stuffed Shells Catering - Half Tray
$60.65
Stuffed Shells Catering - Full Tray
$105.79
Manicotti Catering - Half Tray
$60.65
Manicotti Catering - Full Tray
$105.79
Eggplant Parmigiana Catering - Half Tray
$60.65
Eggplant Parmigiana Catering - Full Tray
$105.79
Eggplant Rollatini Catering - Half Tray
$67.09
Eggplant Rollatini Catering - Full Tray
$105.79
Chicken Parmigiana Catering - Half Tray
$67.09
Chicken Parmigiana Catering - Full Tray
$118.69
Beef Sausage & Peppers Catering - Half Tray
$60.65
Beef Sausage & Peppers Catering - Full Tray
$105.79

Michelle V.

★★★★★

Feb 24, 2025

Amazing pizza and I'm Sicilian picky I highly recommend!! You won't be disappointed!!

Peter M.

★★★★★

Feb 4, 2025

2 slices and a can of soda for 6.00? Unheard of these days. Really fresh tasting pizza. It definitely is NYC style! Quick service and right off 75. There's a slice counter with ample seating inside. 4/5 stars on the pie. 5/5 on the deal and convenience! I'll be back. Highly recommend for a great lunch break meal

Jessica B.

★★★★★

Dec 22, 2024

I love their pizza! Everything is so good! The service is amazing! I can't wait to go back and get another slice! The ambience is amazing! I love the environment

Shay D.

★★★★☆

May 27, 2024

Cheap pizza always tastes good. They have a good lunch combo option with soda. Worth the price point. Would go again. Employees are nice. They have plenty of seatings.

Lisa A.

★★★★★

Dec 27, 2024

Always fantastic! As close to Jersey pizza we have found in New Tampa. Accurate and delicious!

Nishant N.

★★★★☆

May 11, 2023

We wanted to have pizza on Friday night so we searched near us and found Taste of New York Pizzeria.I looked through the menu and from the menu I decided to order Vegetarian Pizza through door-dash.The pizza order was ready in 10-15 minutes. The service was good and we picked up the pizza from the restaurant.The pizza was hot with fresh ingredients. The crust was also crisp and amazing and delicious pizza made our Friday night.

Hannady H.

★★★★★

Sep 19, 2024

Amazing delicious pizza. We had the Margherita and the cheese and it was to die for!! So fresh.

Carlos C.

★★★★☆

Feb 8, 2025

Good freshly made pizza NY style. Quality ingredients and friendly service. The service is quick and prices reasonable.

Keke M.

★★★★★

Feb 7, 2025

Absolutely love this place! Delicious Pizza and Good Service! Officially one of my top pizzerias

Jennifer S.

★★★★★

Jan 26, 2025

Food and service was great! We had pasta meatballs, and , all tasted wonderful and Great portions. the owner even gave us a free salad, which was super kind of him. We will definitely add this to our Italian rotation

Taste Of New York Pizzeria

Menu

Specials

Two Cheese Pizza Slices & Drink Special

Two Medium Cheese Pizzas Special

Our Famous NY Style Pizza

Cheese Pizza - Medium 14"

Cheese Pizza - Large 16"

White Pizza with Ricotta - Medium 14"

White Pizza with Ricotta - Large 16"

White Spinach Pizza with Ricotta - Medium 14"

White Spinach Pizza with Ricotta - Large 16"

Hawaiian Pizza - Medium 14"

Hawaiian Pizza - Large 16"

Special Pizza - Medium 14"

Special Pizza - Large 16"

Mediterranean Pizza - Medium 14"

Mediterranean Pizza - Large 16"

Supreme Pizza - Medium 14"

Supreme Pizza - Large 16"

Meat Lover's Pizza - Medium 14"

Meat Lover's Pizza - Large 16"

Veggie Pizza - Medium 14"

Veggie Pizza - Large 16"

Chicken Parmigiana Pizza - Medium 14"

Chicken Parmigiana Pizza - Large 16"

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - Medium 14"

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - Large 16"

Eggplant Pizza - Medium 14"

Eggplant Pizza - Large 16"

Margherita Pizza - Medium 14"

Margherita Pizza - Large 16"

Sicilian Cheese Pizza - Large 16"

Sicilian Special Pizza - Large 16"

Grandma's Pizza - Large 16"

Pizza By The Slice

Cheese Pizza Slice - Slice

Gourmet Pizza Slice - Slice

Appetizers

Mozzarella Sticks - 6 Pieces

Chicken Wings - 6 Pieces

Chicken Wings - 12 Pieces

Chicken Wings - 20 Pieces

Chicken Tenders - 5 Pieces

French Fries - Appetizers

Side Salad

Onion Rings - Appetizers

Garlic Bread - Appetizers

Garlic Bread with Cheese - Appetizers

Garlic Rolls - 6 Pieces

Garlic Rolls - 12 Pieces

Side of Meatballs - Appetizers

Side of Beef Sausage - Appetizers

Side of Meatballs with Cheese - Appetizers

Side of Beef Sausage with Cheese - Appetizers

side fries

Salads

Garden Salad - Small

Garden Salad - Large

Greek Salad - Small

Greek Salad - Large

Antipasto Salad - Large

Grilled Chicken Salad - Large

Calzones

Cheese Calzone - Calzones

Stromboli

Stromboli

Rolls

Pepperoni Roll with Ricotta - Rolls

Chicken Roll with Ricotta - Rolls

Eggplant Roll with Ricotta - Rolls

Beef Sausage, Pepper & Onion Roll - Rolls

Cold Subs

Italian Sub - 12"

Ham & Cheese Sub - 12"

Hot Subs

Meatball Parmigiana Sub - 12"

Beef Sausage Parmigiana Sub - 12"

Eggplant Parmigiana Sub - 12"

Chicken Parmigiana Sub - 12"