Plum Tomato
Plum Tomato
Ask about our catering menu!
Ask about our catering menu!
Ask about our catering menu!
pasta dish, pasta, food
Loaded with toppings!
pizza
a receipt for a delivery order
food, pizza
Tiramisu
Ask about our catering menu!
Chicken Quesadillas
Ask about our catering menu!
Ask about our catering menu!
Chicken Quesadilla
Ask about our catering menu!
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Wings Hot , Mild ,Honey BBQ, Teriyaki, Garlic Parmesan
Custom pizza
SM Greek Salad
Custom pizza
Chicken Piccata
pizza, food
pasta, food, pasta dish
Plum Pizza. Horrible.
Kate W.
Dec 29, 2024
My wife and I have always heard of this place called "Plum Tomato," and our biggest regret was not coming here sooner. We came here for an early Friday dinner and I'm happy we did because this is a local hotspot that a lot of people might not even know is here. It can seemingly get crowded and it's a very tight fit if you have to wait for a table.You get bang for the buck in terms of the food and price. We got a custom pie and a Greek salad. The pie was MASSIVE, at the best price you'll find in the area. The ingredients were fresh and the food tasted amazing. Nothing is better than a piping hot pizza! The Greek salad is a wonderful addition and you get the potato salad at the bottom, as you do with most places in the area. I highly suggest giving Plum a try if you're a local trying a new spot or if you're visiting the area. The staff is amazing and on top of it ensuring the best possible experience and the food is the best Italian in the area.
Read More
Da D.
Nov 22, 2024
I ordered an eggplant Parmesan sandwich. The eggplant was bad tasted horrible. Couldn't eat it. I called and politely told them of the issue. They apologized and never offered anything to make it right. So, I'm out $13.35 and left hungry. Very disappointed. Now I can only do what I can.
Read More
Majida P.
Sep 5, 2024
Plum Tomato is a great little restaurant that serves a wide variety of Italian dishes, but what stands out are these chicken quesadillas! Yes, you read right--quesadillas. The staff is welcoming and attentive and always smiling! Great atmosphere and food!
Read More
Sheila M H.
Dec 28, 2024
Ordered chicken parm sandwich delivery. Delivery was under an hour. Delivery driver was appropriate and spot on. Chicken was so rubbery picked it off and had cheese bread for the first half. Threw out the other half. Total waste of my 20 buck dinner for cheese bread. Disappointing .
Read More
James S.
Apr 24, 2024
I'm gonna be straight up honest...This may not have been the worst pizza joint I've eaten at, but it's pretty badThe eating environment is nice and warm, and the personnel inside the restaurant are friendly in person, but not so much on the phone the last time I called. The pizza is bland and their crust is terrible, their wings are awful, and their appetizers are mediocre at best.Eat here if you're on a road trip...but if you're ordering, please don't for your sake.
Read More
Amanda W.
Aug 10, 2024
Pizza and wings are awesome!! Cute little place inside, have not been there to eat, only have got to go! Always on point
Read More
Vanessa G.
Aug 1, 2024
One single pizza cost us over $40! Insane! Never again. They nickel and dime you to death. No pizza is worth $40. Not even this price in Little Italy, NYC!!'
Read More
Athena K.
Jul 5, 2024
My family and I have been coming here for years and we love Plum Tomato! Some of the best pizza and wings in the area and Melissa and the girls are always so fast and friendly! Great local place, you've gotta check it out!
Read More
Andrea P.
Feb 5, 2023
Update : the owner reached out and made right on the situation and will be addressing how the situation was handled with the manager ! I am thrilled with this outcome as we love plum tomato and their food !
Read More
Mary R.
Dec 1, 2024
I can eat inside or have takeout and I am never disappointed in the food and service.
Read More
