Original Pizza

So happy I found this pizza place (and also not because I want to order from here way more than I should). I typically get a small pizza with onions and sausage and their breadsticks. Both are fantastic.This is true NY style pizza which is why I love it. If you don't like NY style pizza this probably isn't for you. If you think costco pizza is amazing then this pizza probably isn't for you. The sauce is delicious on the pizza and for breadstick dipping. It's my fav pizza place in st pete.It is unfortunate thaylt you can't order by the slice but I still think it's worth 5 stars.I order it online and pick it up. Never had any issues.

Came by this place after an afternoon at the beach. Appetites were strong and eyes were wide after all that sun and swimming. What caught my eye was the cute Italian flag sign, effortlessly blended in the plaza amongst the bright signs of other places. Looks really low key so I knew it would be a good choice. Has a very down home, hole-in-the-wall feel. A true "Mom n Pops" pizza joint vibe. You can see the pizza artists in the back. No software involved, the front end server just hollers to them. Walked in and was greeted with a-lot of excitement which only amplified the appetites. Felt like a regular even though it was the first time. Smiles always go a long way.Put in an order for a large cheese pizza. They do have an extra large, but im cautious on my first attempt. I tend to gauge a place by ordering a plain cheese. The large ran about $21. It tasted great. The cheese was firm and seasoned atop a sweeter tomato sauce. The cheese fit over the pie like a weighted blanket. The crust was thin, crispy and maintained a flexible chewy consistency. Combined with the cheese it was a pleasantly bendy experience. Sweetness of the sauce danced with the seasoning of the rest of it. Overall this is a great place to pick up a pie! I'll definitely be back to stretch my eyes across the rest of the menu. Good enough to make it a tradition to swing through after a beach day. A strong 4.5 for this place!

This was a good and convenient pizza place right in Treasure Island. Easily accessible. The pizza was yummy and the calzone was huge and delicious. Fresh ingredients. We definitely had enough for dinner and then lunch the next day. Friendly staff but not a very large place.

It was ok, but I guess it works if you're at the beach. If you like paper towel thin crust, then this is the place for you. Sauce was pretty bland. Even the pineapple we got on one of the pies seemed lacking in taste. The Sicilian pizza had a good thick crust, but was almost burnt.

Not bad at all! About a 15-20 min wait. Decent service but not a lot of inside seating. Definitely not a dine in place you'd have to buy and take it home but the pizza was immaculate and the cheese bread was snacked on throughout the night!

Great pizza and great service our first and only call when we are on spring break and we have tried many places around mederia beach thank you

18 inch was delicious and feed family of six... be careful there are two locations we drove to the wrong one.

Best place in Treasure Island for pizza! We've been coming here for seven years and always grab a pizza to take home with us. They do get busy so do not be surprised if you get a busy tone when trying to call. You can go in and order in person if you need to.

Tried to order online, it said transaction was cancelled but I still got charged. DO NOT ORDER online or you will get scammed. And they never answers the phone

I'm assuming people that loved this pizza bought it after a night of drinking or something. Completely inedible and disgusting. sauce tastes like sweet ketchup, cheap ingredients. ordered Greek salad also, which is fairly hard to make gross but they achieved it with runny, sweet potato salad.spent 40 dollars for a large bag of garbage. they should taste their product once in a while. better yet, order some good pizza elsewhere and compare it to theirs. so pissed off and hungry.