Olde Town Pizzeria

Happy to finally get to try Olde Town Pizzeria. My friend told me a while back that they do Chicago style pizza and try it and see what I think.We tried it and loved it. This is hard for us to find since everything is mostly New York style. We had the deep dish Supreme requested taking out the onion and adding pineapple.Good pizza is judged by everything - a good amount of sauce, cheese, fillings, & crust. The crust must hold everything up. There's a lot of sad soggy pizzas out there.This was not one of them! Super impressed with this Chicago Deep Dish. They also have thin crust, and Italian beef, amongst other menu items.They have a location in Plant City as well. Took a long time to find this place but would def go again if in the area. Service was top notch and ambiance reminded me of other Chicago pizza spots!

Loved our visit to Olde Town Pizzeria. We dined in with a larger group including two toddlers and a baby and the staff was very kind and accommodating to the different requests. For appetizers we ordered garlic rolls and boneless wings. The main meal we ordered two large pizzas and eggplant Parmesan pasta. The pasta was delicious and came in a really large serving. It was a busy day at the restaurant but the food still came out really quickly.

We stopped in and got a supreme deep dish pizza. It was very delicious and I like that the crust wasnt too crispy. The restaurant has a nice cozy atmosphere. Would definitely stop back again . The service was great too.

I get an XL Supreme every couple of months and Olde Town Pizzeria always delivers with a piping hot, delicious pizza! The Original Crust is thin& crispy and the toppings are fresh and vibrant. When I've had more time and dined in, the staff is very attentive and friendly and the pizza comes out rather fast.Great place for a great pizza !

Olde Town Pizzeria hit the spot for dinner but this definitely isn't my favorite pizza to eat.My wife and I were near Brandon and needed to eat dinner. After walking into Capitol Tacos and not feeling the vibe. It was hot, limited seating and their menu changed, we walked over to Olde Town. They are right next door to each other.We were seated right away, and our server was around quickly. She was friendly and got us started on drinks. Just soda and water.For a starter to share, we went with their award-winning Strawberry Walnut Salad. Fresh sliced strawberries, candied walnuts, mozzarella cheese and a red wine vinaigrette dressing bringing it all together. This salad was different but good. Sweet salads aren't our usually go-to but this was tasty and was a decent size. We finished it but it took some work. For dinner, we ordered the XL thin crust Olde Town. They only have two options for pizza, thin crust or deep dish. The Olde Town is topped with pepperoni, Italian sausage and smoked crumbled bacon. It didn't take long. This pizza was ok. I've had pizza at many different places but I wouldn't come back to Olde Town for theirs. It was hot and the toppings were ok but seemed very minced. They had to be though, because their standard is to cut the pizza like you're at a children's birthday party. An extra-large pizza, that serves 4 people, cut into tiny squares. I thought we got someone else's pizza but I confirmed with the waitress that this is how they do things.In the end, we barely ate half and brought the other half home for later. This pizza was ok and while the toppings didn't blow me away and the cut was unnecessarily inconvenient, and it was greasy the next day, it was pizza and I do like pizza.We did like the ambiance here. It was old school pizzeria with big wooden booths, red and white checkered tablecloths, pizza racks and parmesan cheese and red pepper flakes in little glass shakers. The staff was friendly and attentive.I'd say, try out Olde Town Pizzeria for yourself and if you do, get the Strawberry salad. As for my wife and I, we will likely try other places for our pizza next time.

The strawberry salad is the best anywhere this side of the Mississippi. Absolutely try it!! The dressing is homemade gold. Portion size is excellent Always fresh!!

Well 3 weeks later and my grandson has yet to get his money back. Can't get a manager by phone or in person nor the owner. This is beyond and error and is outright theft!

Daughter in town so needed two large strawberry walnut salads to go with the pizza! Always a crowd favorite.

This restaurant is Amazing! this glamorous server put bibs on us and treated us well! would definitely come here again we loved the service!

Great service..food is always amazing..best salads in town. Also give their spinach cheese loaf a try..