So good but seasonal. Tastes like strawberry shortcake ice cream bar.
Sprinkles
Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio Ice Cream
Single scoop with cone $6.50, mango sticky rice and coffee sticky bun
a scoop of ice cream with sprinkles
Double scoop ice cream - Cookies and Cream and Mint Chocolate Chip
Coquito ice cream with real rum.
Sprinkles Ice Cream
Matcha passion fruit, strawberry jam, and vanilla bean
Ice cream
Thai Iced Tea
$8 for shortest soft serve in waffle cone.
interior
interior
Counter with current flavor signs
Coquito Scoop Ice Cream. Definitely my fav.
Cookie sandwiches available
Counter
interior
Vegan chocolate chunk and vanilla soft serve with sprinkles
food
Coffee Crunch
This is 1 of 3 menus at OddFellows Ice Cream Co.
Kim P.
Jan 26, 2025
Delicious ice cream. It's pretty steep for two half scoops You could literally go to publix and buy two whole containers for the price I paid for one cone. I guess they justify prices like that by location. Hyde park is chez chez, but I'd go back if I was in the neighborhood and wanted an expensive treat
Read MoreNick S.
Jul 18, 2024
This gourmet ice cream palace is special! Like Jenni's they have phenomenal flavors that are next level. Not cheap, but truly a special experience.The shop is in lovely Hyde Park. An area of Tampa that's lovely for shopping, a stroll, and lots of eateries! Free parking!!!It offers a wonderful variety of exotic flavors. Soft serve. Floats. Pints. They were very accommodating about petting me try some of their terrific flavors. The Green Hills of Pandan is a Sonic the Hedgehog flavor coconut and pandan flavored ice cream with candy and chocolate in it. They also have miso peanut butter brownie, an Aval raspberry ciderrosé infused flavor,. The matcha latte coconut based matcha green tea is GREAT! They have a vegan grasshopper chocolate mint cashew based ice cream with chocolate cookies that has cashwes and wheat in it.. They also have several vegan coconut based ice creams. They have a passionfruit apricot pistachio,. They do a peabut butter s'mores, a key lime pie with marshmallow swirls and graham soil, two GREAT coffee flavors : coffee crunch with swirls of coffee soil and one with St. Pierre's waffles.Cones are about $7, a double scoop for $10. They also do floats, flights ($12) ice cream sandwich, soft serve and pints for 11ish. I love their coconut vegan flavors and their cashew based one. The tropical fruits sorbet, a mix of mango, banana, passionfruit and guava, is delicious.Definitely a splurge for extraordinary ice cream including two Sonic the Hedge Hog themed flavors!!! What's not to love?
Read MoreHayli Z.
Mar 27, 2024
An Instagram reel brought me here. I got the ice cream flight with my friend. I've gotten ice cream flights elsewhere that had bigger portions, so I thought I wouldn't be able to eat one alone, this one had smaller scoops so I probably could have. I liked that there were a variety of flavors, some I liked better than others. Flavors:Vegan Matcha Latte: 3/5Raspberry Rose Cider: 5/5Key Lime Pie: 5/5Passion Fruit, Apricot Pistachio: 3/5Miso Peanut Butter Brownie: 3/5The last one was a long name I can't remember. All in all, it was ok. The Rose one is probably the only one ai would get again because it was unique but none of the other were ones I would get a pint of, maybe because I'm comparing it to other ice cream flights I've gotten, this one didn't seem as memorable.
Read MoreMatthew O.
Aug 4, 2024
Really solid place to go for ice cream in the Hyde Park neighborhood. So many unique ice cream flavors available. The people working here are really friendly and allow you to sample and find the flavor of ice cream you are looking for. Love the ambiance and vibe of the store in general as well. I got the Peanut Butter Marshmallow Ice Cream and it was well balanced between sweet and the savory notes from the peanut butter. I only wish the shop had more group sitting options, but on a nice day, sitting outdoors is perfect as well :)
Read MoreAustin P.
Dec 1, 2023
Oddfellows has I screaming, you screaming all of us screaming for ice cream! First off, it is located in the heart of Hyde Park Village, one of Tampa's best hangout spots. The location instantly gives extra points as there is so much to do in Hyde Park and what better way to end the night then with ice cream. Upon walking in, I was warmly (ironic) greeted and offered to sample some literal cold treats. The flavors had fun, unique names that my kids enjoyed while I enjoyed the taste. I found the ice cream to not be overbearingly sweet, in fact, I personally could have went for it being a little sweeter. The prices were a tad bit higher than some of my other local favorites but not so much to knock off points. I sampled a variety of flavors before finally deciding on a two scoop but being honest, you really cannot go wrong with any flavor you choose. All are unique enough where you're sure to leave satisfied while not feeling weighed down by the typical richness you would find in these flavor combinations. After you enjoy one of the many spectacular restaurants in the village or if you're just hanging out in the area, be sure to stop here to scream for some ice cream!
Read MoreRoberto G.
May 19, 2024
First time here. I ordered a vanilla bean ice cream with graham cracker solids. The ice cream was delicious. The single serve is a really small cup. They should make it slightly bigger, especially since the topping didn't even fit. I also think they are a bit overpriced. Again, the ice cream was tasty.
Read MoreKristin C.
May 17, 2024
OddFellows is a cute spot right next to the fountain in the middle of Hyde Park Village. There are a lot of interesting flavors of ice cream to try. The ice cream is decent but I wish it was a bit smoother. I would be curious about trying their soft serve.
Read MoreRegina M.
Apr 27, 2024
We were walking around Hyde Park and wanted to get some ice cream, so we decided to give OddFellows a try. The layout was confusing. We weren't sure where to order. Most ice cream places you go, you can actually see the ice cream in the display case but here you just ordered off the menu. I prefer seeing the ice cream before ordering. My fiancé tried their chocolate ice cream and said it was ok, not as creamy or rich as we were hoping for. I tried their chocolate soft serve ice cream which I thoroughly enjoyed. It's definitely pricey for ice cream, but the quality wasn't worth what you paid for. Chills Bros is still our favorite place for ice cream in Tampa. Chills Bros has similar prices but you get a huge serving and better ice [email protected]
Read MoreJustin C.
Mar 2, 2025
If you're looking for a truly unique ice cream experience, Oddfellows is the place to be! From the moment you walk in, you're greeted by the warm, inviting atmosphere and a wide selection of creative, mouthwatering flavors.I've tried a few spots around town, but nothing compares to the deliciousness and innovation at Oddfellows. Their flavor combos are unlike anything you'll find elsewhere--Almond Poppy Seed and Hibiscus Cherry, were so unique. The texture is smooth, creamy, and just the right consistency. The staff is super friendly and always eager to answer any questions. I especially love that they offer a variety of dairy-free options that are just as rich and indulgent as their classic ice cream.Oddfellows is the perfect spot for a treat, whether you're with visiting Hyde Park Village, or just in the mood for something sweet.
Read MoreTessa F.
Mar 2, 2025
ice cream was good. customer service was absolutely horrible. the kids were extremely rude and had an attitude with my friends and i. simple questions were answered with a short temper. we all looked at each other and were shocked. we didn't give a tip and we heard them complaining on the way out. i always love tipping and i'm always happy to do so. for reference, we went on a sunday at 8:30. this kind of an environment should be welcoming and happy and i was very disappointed by those kids. definitely odd fellows.
Read More