NYPD Pizza
NYPD Pizza
Slice of cheese pizza
Chicken fettuccini Alfredo (very little chicken)
Vegan cheese and cauliflower crust options
the front of the restaurant
Front of menu
Water they gave my dog without asking for it!
Pizza box
Menu
Great names for menu items.
Back of Menu
Salads and sandwiches
Pepperoni small pizza
Chicken wings
Lunch specials! Great deals at a great place.
Garlic nuggets
14" Hawaiian Pie 14"
Garlic knots
Boneless wings
How to eat a slice. Cute signage
Vacation beer, lol.
A slice of the special of the day pizza
Pepperoni & Sausage with all the fixings like you should if you know how to eat pizza!
Cup of chicken noodle soup
Large Greek salad
Terry H.
Sep 29, 2024
Had a visit today for lunch with my wife, we always get their lunch special, well it ends at 4 is what we are use to the waitress stated 3 , all the menus and placards say 4 ! We asked for the manager, he was not working today, the waitress took it personal though and got smart with my wife, I don't get excited, so I listened, this waitress took everything personal, told us to have a nice fucking day , I waited for the receipt, never came back so I went in for it, the waitress started ranting again, I said just give me the receipt , she tried to explain , I said miss we were not angry until you told us have a nice fucking day, that's where you made a big mistake , let alone argue with a customer that comes in 2-3 times a week, I managed an original Pizza Hut back when people waited in line to get in, I never argued I usually compted the entire meal just to keep my customer happy.I never had a customer I couldn't make happy, however , I believe in great service to keep a customer, I know how much it costs to make a pizza , 3.00 todays prices, including toppings, That pales in comparison to the amount of money spent to gain 1 customer... Quite possibly customers do not matter to them, they are doing so well.I would fire a waitress telling my customer to have a nice fucking day, guess she was mad I kept my cool, but I wasn't there for poor service it was that we felt doupdd on the special... what was not a problem escalated by a waitress that wasn't very concerned other than swearing at us.... She needs a new career path because she caused the grief... we are allowed to ask for a manager... We are allowed expected specials than it written on a chalk board. Customers have rights, her mouth abused us, I frankly told her I was a general manager and would fire her on the spot,We will not be returning ever!Keep on perpetuating this toxic waitress I can only imagine the loss of revenue!
Read More
Gigi V.
Sep 1, 2024
It's ok not everyone has same taste I personally like Not chain restaurants It's not for me
Read More
Melody M.
Aug 5, 2024
Coming from NY I was expecting NYC taste. I was not disappointed! The pizza tasted pretty comparable to NYC pizza. The wings were very good too. The sweet and tangy sauce reminded me of how much I miss the NFL season. One small pizza was enough to share between two people. We did have the garlic nuggets since everyone raved about those. They were good but the marinara sauce could have been a little sweeter. It was on the salty and acidic side, which I know some people may prefer.
Read More
Stephanie L.
Feb 28, 2024
I get it, I'm from New York and spoiled when it comes to pizza. It I also do not have high expectations with pizza in Florida. The pizza was as expected.... Mediocre at best but that wasn't even the issue. I ordered a large grilled chicken Caesar salad with warm chicken. What I got was the saddest excuse for a salad I've ever seen. The chicken was like they sliced the dried edges off the chicken to throw away but mistakenly added to this salad. I don't normally even write bad reviews so I didn't bother to take pictures, but I decided to write one with the hope that the owners see this and make sure the next person that orders a salad doesn't get ripped off because $14 for that dry chicken jerky salad was just robbery!!
Read More
Bruce M.
Aug 23, 2024
Been eating at NYPD roughly twice a month for fourteen years. It has always been our go to pizza place. A couple of weeks ago we ate there and were disappointed in the pie. It was flavorless, undercooked and just not up to par. So we decided to come back again in a couple of weeks to confirm. We ordered our typical medium all black olive and half pepperoni, and asked for a little extra oven time. The cooking was perfect, however, the pie is just not as good they used to be. First, the sauce is lacking flavor,it's just bland. There is plenty of it, enough to make it gloppy. Additionally it has not been run out anywhere near to the edge. The pepperoni and olives are just fine, but that's pretty hard to mess up. At one point they were using sandwich size pepperoni which is just plain wrong. But they switched back. The cheese is ok except that it is also held way back from the edge at least a good inch. Sure, that's a great way to cut back on ingredients at the expense of the product. But even the cheese doesn't seem up to par any longer. The crust is just ok, but it used to be excellent particularly when it was just out of the oven. So now our search will commence to find a really tasty pizza nearby. We find Marcos is pretty good for a takeout pizza and Pizanos is leading for sit down, but they are normally quite busy. Flippers make a good pie occasionally but is inconsistent.I suggest that somebody review all ingredients and process to determine what has changed.
Read More
Barbara G.
Jan 10, 2025
I only had take out so I cannot speak on the service or the ambiance. But... the food was delicious!! And we order takeout as much as I can .
Read More
Nyasia R.
Jan 8, 2025
You know when some pizzas just aren't good the next day when reheated... this pizza is not only great when it's hot and fresh but still taste great the next day I love getting this pizza they never disappoint my kids are obsessed as well lol garlic knots are also ON POINT definitely give this place a try when you get that pizza craving cause they do not miss
Read More
Jody M.
Jan 7, 2025
Super service and Delicious food!! Gary and his team went above and beyond for our work holiday party that they catered! If you haven't tried them out you need to!
Read More
Jessica G.
Dec 31, 2024
I can't say enough about NYPD Pizza( The Villages) and especially Soren! I called to say that my car battery had died at Publix when I was on my way to pick my pizza and that I wasn't sure if I would get there to pick it up before they closed. Soren not only volunteered to bring me my pizza but showed up with jumper cables and saved the day. Soren is my angel of the new year! We already lived NYPD Pizza but love it even more now!!!!
Read More
Dance M.
Dec 12, 2024
Ignored mediocre reviews. Due to close proximity, I wanted to taste their pizza. Ordered a small special. Reviews were accurate. The thin crust was over baked and crisp like a matzah. Toppings were so finely chopped that I couldn't distinguish the sausage, mushrooms and pepperoni. Looked like all the toppings were chopped in a food processor. Service excellent. Ambiance was acceptable. Disappointed as the pie was not much better than those found in frozen food sections.
Read More
