NY Times Square Pizzeria - Land O Lakes
NY Times Square Pizzeria - Land O Lakes
Slice of pepperoni and sausage.
a man sitting at a table eating
a view of the brooklyn bridge
interior
two slices of pizza
Rachel H.
Feb 8, 2025
My mom and I got the Sicilian cheese pizza, garlic knots, and mozzarella cheese sticks. And oh boy, the garlic knots reminded me of dominos garlic knots but better, more garlic less butter I feel like. It didn't make me feel gross afterwards. The mozz sticks had some good cheese pulls! And the Sicilian pizza... it's a thicker pizza (which I didn't realize when I ordered) but I love thicker crusts. And it didn't a bit to cook and be ready to eat but ohh so worth the wait. I'd definitely come back when I'm back in the area!
Read More
Alicia Y.
Nov 14, 2024
Pizza is good, and staff is usually friendly. The younger crew is the nicest. Hence the four stars
Read More
Mark W.
Jan 25, 2025
Horrible pizza! If you think by calling this NY pizza you are sadly mistaken! I eat pizza and do testings everywhere in Tampa Bay Area. I did not order online but went in person to make certain I would get what I paid for. Well that fell on death ears by the guy who took my order having no personality to start with. I pacifically asked for extra extra cheese and the whole thing covered in pepperoni and will pay what ever it cost like you see in photos online, as well I want it well done please. Well stupid me! I got home after waiting for it outside and should have checked it, no extra cheese at all and like 2 to 3 pepperonis on each slice, was not well done but doughy to top it off. You know it's amazing how nobody wants to give you what you pay for and 75 dollars later it was a waist. Got wings as well and we're just covered in the whole bottle of sauce. Not real NY pizza and no flavor I was baffled, it was unreal to see this and I'm not one to complain but leave good reviews on Yelp all the time. Not going back!!!!
Read More
Natalie A.
Mar 28, 2024
I love the vibe of the pizzeria it takes me back to New York. It's clam and chili and very family oriented. The pizza is actually very similar to New York pizza. The service is sweet as well they aren't rude or mean. They are very kind and funny!
Read More
Tracey W.
Feb 25, 2024
Great for a slice to go and even better for a pie! If you live a good thin greasy New York style slice this is the place! The owner is nice guy who loves his country and loves his restaurant. They will hand toss you a fresh pie right there so fast you will say mama Mia hahahha
Read More
Alex L.
Nov 24, 2023
Great pizza. Outstanding service and beautiful inside decor...highly recommend. I just wish they opened on Sundays
Read More
Michelle W.
Sep 30, 2023
I've passed by this pizza shop many times and finally stopped in one day for a quick lunch. The crust was so thin and crispy! I had to go back that weekend I ordered a white spinach pizza and a pepperoni pizza. Both were delicious.
Read More
Angie V.
Nov 11, 2023
Ordered for the first time tonight. So good. The crust is crunchy and chewy. Just the right amount of sauce and toppings for my liking. It's so convenient for my husband on the way home from work. We will return.
Read More
Taiz T.
Mar 1, 2024
I've passed this place almost everyday and I'm a pizza lover; however never made the stop until today and definitely no regrets... just one ; no stopping a long time ago! Pizza is delicious and very fresh and crispy just like New York style pizza ! Clean dining area and great service! Lovely spot with beautiful murals that makes you feel you're in NY! I'll be coming back for sure and I've already spread my word with my friends!
Read More
Andrew C.
Mar 14, 2024
Great pizza if you're truly looking for NY style. My wife hates thin crust pizza and still likes this.
Read More
