NY East Lake Pizza

They're not bad, they deliver to our area but unfortunately they're not consistent. Sometimes their crust is under cooked and I haven't figured out who it is that doesn't cook it fully, because sometimes it's fine.

Did an online order and when I get there they say they don't have cheese pizza for my kids order. Since I had to wait an additional 15 minutes for the rest of my order, you would think they could have made a cheese pizza in that time. The rest of the order is finally ready and now he says he can't refund my pizza. He doesn't know how. After 5 minutes of arguing he cancels the whole order and I leave. I assume the credit will not appear on my card so I'll have to dispute. I wouldn't go near this place. Awful, unprofessional and dirty. It has went way down hill. Avoid at all costs.

Great food, friendly, orders always spot on. Pretty decent pizza close by my home and always fast.

Great pizza place. I think that if you order too many toppings on a thin pizza you are asking for trouble. When I order their specials (meat lovers, white, etc.) or 2 topping pizza. Perfect! Excellent service! Never had a problem.

For a venue in a convenient store, their food is impressive. Quick & easy! Take out or delivery. Just a few tables if you are in a hurry. Get your car wash and enjoy a tasty meal.

I discovered this pizzeria quite by accident...it quickly became my "favorite "pizza! The dough is fully cooked! Generous toppings, flavorful..and great employees!

When NY East Lake Pizza 1st opened, they were good, but as time went on they kept getting worse, especially with their deliveries! Most recently, I ordered a thin crust pizza, but received a thick crust pizza instead. I asked for mild sauce on my wings, and got hot sauce instead. They forgot my dessert, so returned an hour later to deliver it, after I called them 2 times about it. Decided to give them another chance, and this time I received cheese cake instead of the chocolate cake I ordered. Also, the salad did not look fresh, like it might have been several days old. Doubt I will be using them for future orders, even though delivery is convenient.

I am extremely disappointed with this location. My wife and I order at least once a week and give them our business. This is the very LAST TIME they will ever get my business again. This location is EXTRMELY inconsistent and fed up with wasting money on slop and mess. It seems like when you ask for anything extra that you are willing to pay for, they fuck it up! I am extremely pissed and annoyed with this location. Nine times out of ten you can bank your order will be inconsistent. I've expressed to management my concerns, and it goes in one ear and out the other.They screwed my order previously because I asked for extra sauce on the pie, which I was expecting to pay for, but never got it. So, when I ordered my free pie, the cook decided to have a party on my pie and just drained it with pizza sauce. Let alone not getting the toppings I asked for.In addition, every time I paid cash they would charge me a credit card processing fee, which I had to dispute each time! Are you kidding me?!Below is a pick of the wet and soggy pizza I got for being a valued customer.My advice, stay away because if you piss off the cook in a wrong way, he'll take it out on your food. P.S. I would have given NO star rating if I could. I think 1 is too much.

A little disappointed. The pizza was ok (we only got cheese so not much to go on). The ziti was just pasta and sauce. No cheese?! The fries were burnt and soggy (didn't expect much since it's a pizza joint but they were inedible). The wings were also just ok but they forgot the blue cheese dressing. The online ordering system was easy. The delivery person was very sweet and the delivery was on time which are very much appreciated. All in all, not a great meal for the price so I'll be ordering elsewhere.

amazing customer service, i had a really weird request to put corn on pizza for a birthday and they were so nice about everything. the pizza here is really good too!