New York New York Pizza - Wesley Chapel

Delicious and nice atmosphere. I totally recommend this place for a date or take out. My daughter and I stopped in and was surprised by how good the slices are.

NY, NY is a fool proof spot for a good slice and garlic knots. When I moved to Wesley Chapel, I was so excited to see that there was one near me! The service has always been good and fast, the pizza and garlic knots are fresh, and I love sitting outside with my doggo and eating a good slice because of how nice the little sitting area is. If you're looking for a quick bite in the area, make sure you drop by!

Best pizza in town and all 8 locations a must try anytime for good pizza!! Ybor is my favorite!

4* Pizza last night. We've been ordering pizza from here for nearly 10 years. They have recently upped all their prices and (WHY??) eliminated mozzarella cheese from some of their pizzas. That alone has taken away points for me. The crust was better than we have had in quite a long time. After all, it is pizza and pick up, so they need to watch their price point.

Decent pizza, but do not ever order delivery. Their drivers are beyond rude and disrespectful. One was banned from my neighborhood and the latest one demanded more tip than what I already paid due to "being the only delivery driver tonight".

It's hard to find good pizza anywhere in Florida, but this never disappoints. They have super quick delivery, are great folks, and make damn good pizza for Florida.

So it's really hard for me to write about this place because I've had fresh out of the oven pies there and being in New York City pizza snob I can tell you the pizza is excellent. BUT, DoorDash is destroying their business. I will never order delivery unfortunately again I ordered pizza from her on 4 different occasions over the last month. The pizza gets to me ice cold. The last pizza even had the cheese spread all over it. Shame

Living in New York my whole life, I know what good pizza is. Trust me. With that said, there are very few places here in Wesley Chapel and/or Tampa that duplicate or even come close. NY NY pizza is pretty good for a local spot (they have multiple locations). They serve by the slice which is great if you're not looking to get a pie. They also do different variations of pizzas with toppings. The meatball parm sub was flavorful and actually chopped up vs a full round meatball in the hero lol. Cheese fries were also good as well.

NY NY Pizza in Wesley Chapel serves up authentic NY-style pizza that's simply delicious. While delivery waits can be lengthy, the quality of the pizza makes it well worth the wait. Crispy crust, gooey cheese, and flavorful toppings combine for a five-star experience every time. I order from here at least once every few weeks.

ONLY good pizza I've found here. I'm a New Yorker (from Queens) and finding an authentic NYC slice in the Tampa Bay area has been tough. I've tried all the other recommended places over the years, but they weren't actually good. This spot IS actually very good and authentic, especially the regular (cheese) slices. I'm grateful I live nearby because pizza is life and it's been a struggle until I found NYNY. :( SALTY GRANDMA - However, the past 2x we ordered grandma pies, both times the sauce was VERY salty. I hope you guys can lessen the salt in that because it's a turn off. Otherwise I would've rated this location 5 stars.