Garlic Knots
4. Florentine Pizza
Gourmets Pizza (4 cheese)
Food
meat lovers pizza, italy pizza
This is the cost of greatness
Zeppoles
None of that extra dough that can be there when dealing with other places
Stromboli
The crust is perfect
I'm in love with this Stromboli
Beautiful
Box
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza slice
Pepperoni Pizza
Store front
Memu
Menu
Menu
Veggie slice
Daily specials
Cheese pizza
4. Florentine Pizza
Natacha C.
Aug 17, 2024
Their pizza is absolutely delicious omgWill be ordering again soonThe garlic rolls were amazing too!!
Read More
NM H.
Jan 24, 2025
Really good pizza at a reasonable price. It's convenient and the service is always friendly. It's becoming our favorite.
Read More
Melissa L.
May 27, 2024
The family stopped here to grab a bite before hitting the road home from our day at Busch Gardens. We were all tired and hungry but the service was quick and efficient so we didn't have to wait long! Indoor seating is extremely limited to only two tables.The food was quite good. Not an exact replica of that savory NY pizza but it was close! I definitely need recommend giving this place a try!
Read More
Stacy K.
Sep 5, 2022
I really like thin crust pizza, don't tell my Chicago friends! I've always wanted to try New York pizza. This pizza had huge slices and was very greasy so I'm guessing this is what's it's like in NY according to a guy I use to work with. I liked it while it was hot. It was fine. Once it got cold it wasn't as good. The service was fast. Would try something else different if I try them again.
Read More
Paul M.
Dec 1, 2023
If you like thin crust New York-style pizza, NY NY is your huckleberry.Great crust, tasty sauce, and ample cheese. Other than Eddie & Sam's downtown, this is a breath of fresh air in this vast pizza wasteland we call Tampa. Highly recommend.
Read More
Andrea J.
Apr 25, 2023
We ordered 2 extra large pizzas with pepperoni via DoorDash. Loved the size of the pizzas. But the taste was a bit off. The pizza was just too salty for me. I've never had a salty pizza before. It wasn't too bad, our group still ate the pizza. It was edible. But we probably won't be ordering this pizza again. Pretty disappointed in this. It was our first time trying this pizza. Not sure why this pizza was so salty. It would've been an AMAZING pizza if it wasn't salty. I wouldn't recommend nor will I be ordering from here again. Maybe some people like salty pizza? I'm not sure.
Read More
Katherine H.
Dec 28, 2022
We stopped by NYNY Pizza when another place we wanted to go to closed. It's your average pizza shop and we got the meat lovers and italy pizza. Both were pretty good but very salty and greasy, especially the meat lovers. Overall, I think it was fine so if you're looking for regular pizza this is the place
Read More
David D.
Jun 26, 2023
When you order a pizza with 4 different toppings the expectation is that each of the pieces of the pizza will have some degree of all 4 ingredients. No one expects exact measurements across the surface area but this one was a disaster. I even looked under the cheese as instructed but to no avail. Disappointing as the crust is good and when you got all the ingredients the taste was good as well.
Read More
Susan C.
Sep 9, 2024
This Pizza RULES. I've had a problem ordering a pizza going through the call center, but when I go to the store to order it's THE BEST AROUND. I think the call center sometimes doesn't get it right .
Read More
John S.
Aug 26, 2024
Great pizza, great food! I recommend the Florentine pizza, the lasagna, and the Alfredo
Read More