New York New York Pizza

Gourmet Pizzas

Gourmets Pizza
$18.50
1. Meat Eater Pizza

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, and mozzarella.
$18.99
2. Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Chicken, hot sauce and mozzarella side of blue cheese.
$18.99
3. Grandma Pie Pizza

Thin seasoned crust, plum tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, garlic, and olive oil.
$18.99
4. Florentine Pizza

Ricotta cheese, tomatoes, spinach, garlic, and mozzarella cheese (white).
$18.99
5. Garden State and Veggie Pizza

Onions, peppers, olives, broccoli, eggplant, and tomatoes.
$18.99
6. New York New York White Pizza

Garlic, olive oil, mozzarella, and ricotta.
$18.99

Appetizers

Fried Mozzarella

Battered mozzarella sticks served with a marinara side.
$10.50
Fried Mushroom

Battered whole mushrooms served with a side of ranch.
$10.50
Fried Mac and Cheese Balls

Served with a side of ranch.
$10.50
Jalapeno Poppers

Jalapeno poppers stuffed with cream cheese served with tzatziki sauce.
$10.50
Fried Zucchini

Italian breaded zucchini sticks served with a side of ranch.
$10.50
Chicken Tenders

Breaded or battered crispy chicken.
$13.25
Meatballs

Ball of seasoned meat.
$8.00
French Fries

Fried potatoes.
$8.00
Onion Rings

Battered onion rings.
$8.00
Garlic Knots

Rolled baked garlic bread.
$4.00
Garlic Bread

Buttery bread that is topped with garlic.
$8.00
Manhattan Rolls
$10.50
Seasoned French Fries with Cheese
$6.99
2 Meatballs with Marinara
$6.99
4 MeatBalls with Marinara
$10.99

Salads

Garden Salad

Romaine lettuce, onion, green peppers, tomato and cucumbers.
$12.00
Caesar Salad

Romaine lettuce, croutons, and Parmesan cheese.
$12.00
Chef Salad

Lettuce, meat, eggs, and vegetables.
$13.00
Antipasto Salad

Traditional Italian salad.
$14.50
Greek Salad

Romaine lettuce, onion, green peppers, tomato, cucumbers, olives, pepperoncini, and feta.
$14.50
Buffalo Salad
$14.50
Steak Salad
$14.50

Pasta DInners

Marinara Pasta

Tomato sauce.
$14.50
Meatballs Pasta

Ball of seasoned meat.
$17.25
Sausage Pasta
$17.25
Meat Sauce Bolognese Pasta

Meat based red sauce.
$17.25
A la Vodka Pasta

Tomato and vodka pasta sauce.
$18.50
Fettuccine Alfredo Pasta
$18.50
Chicken Parmiginia Pasta
$21.25

Baked Pasta Dinners

Lasagna Pasta

Layered dish with wide flat pasta.
$18.50
Manicotti Pasta

Large tube shaped pasta.
$16.00
Jumbo Stuffed Shells Pasta
$16.00
Baked Ziti Pasta
$16.00
Baked Cheese Ravioli Pasta
$16.00
Pasta Combo
$18.50
Eggplant Parmigiana Pasta
$18.50
Baked Eggplant Florentine Pasta
$21.00

Hot Oven Subs

Philly Chicken and Cheese Sub

Poultry.
$14.50
Philly Steak and Cheese Sub
$14.50
Meatball Parmigiana Sub
$14.50
Sausage Parmigiana Sub
$14.50
Sausage and Meatball Parmigiana Sub
$14.50
Chicken Parmigiana Sub
$14.50
Eggplant Parmigiana Sub
$14.50
Chicken Cutlet Sub
$14.50
Philly Chicken Sub

Green peppers, onion, mushroom, and cheese.
$8.99
Sausage and Meatball Combo Sub
$8.99
Philly Steak Sub

Mushroom peppers, onion, and cheese.
$8.99

Cold Sub

Ham and Cheese Sub
$14.50
Salami and Cheese Sub
$14.50
Turkey and Cheese Sub
$14.50
Italian Combo Sub
$14.50

Desserts

New York Cheesecake

Rich creamy cake.
$8.00
Cannoli

Fried pastry with a sweet creamy filling.
$8.00
Chocolate Cake
$8.00
Zeppoles
$8.00

Pizza

Medium Build Your Own Pizza

Add toppings for an additional charge.
$13.99
Large Build Your Own Pizza
$17.99
Extra Large Build Your Own Pizza
$20.99

Sides

Ranch Dressing
$0.50
Blue Cheese Dressing
$0.50
Honey Mustard Dressing
$0.50
Ceasar Dressing
$0.50
Italian Dressing
$0.50
Creamy Italian Dressing
$0.50
Oil and Vinegar
$0.50
Balsamic Vinaigrette
$0.50
Side of Marinara
$0.50

Garlic Knots

4. Florentine Pizza

Gourmets Pizza (4 cheese)

Food

meat lovers pizza, italy pizza

This is the cost of greatness

Zeppoles

None of that extra dough that can be there when dealing with other places

Stromboli

The crust is perfect

I'm in love with this Stromboli

Beautiful

Box

Pepperoni Pizza

Pepperoni Pizza slice

Pepperoni Pizza

Store front

Memu

Veggie slice

Daily specials

Cheese pizza

4. Florentine Pizza

Natacha C.

★★★★★

Aug 17, 2024

Their pizza is absolutely delicious omgWill be ordering again soonThe garlic rolls were amazing too!!

NM H.

★★★★☆

Jan 24, 2025

Really good pizza at a reasonable price. It's convenient and the service is always friendly. It's becoming our favorite.

Melissa L.

★★★★☆

May 27, 2024

The family stopped here to grab a bite before hitting the road home from our day at Busch Gardens. We were all tired and hungry but the service was quick and efficient so we didn't have to wait long! Indoor seating is extremely limited to only two tables.The food was quite good. Not an exact replica of that savory NY pizza but it was close! I definitely need recommend giving this place a try!

Stacy K.

★★★☆☆

Sep 5, 2022

I really like thin crust pizza, don't tell my Chicago friends! I've always wanted to try New York pizza. This pizza had huge slices and was very greasy so I'm guessing this is what's it's like in NY according to a guy I use to work with. I liked it while it was hot. It was fine. Once it got cold it wasn't as good. The service was fast. Would try something else different if I try them again.

Paul M.

★★★★★

Dec 1, 2023

If you like thin crust New York-style pizza, NY NY is your huckleberry.Great crust, tasty sauce, and ample cheese. Other than Eddie & Sam's downtown, this is a breath of fresh air in this vast pizza wasteland we call Tampa. Highly recommend.

Andrea J.

★★☆☆☆

Apr 25, 2023

We ordered 2 extra large pizzas with pepperoni via DoorDash. Loved the size of the pizzas. But the taste was a bit off. The pizza was just too salty for me. I've never had a salty pizza before. It wasn't too bad, our group still ate the pizza. It was edible. But we probably won't be ordering this pizza again. Pretty disappointed in this. It was our first time trying this pizza. Not sure why this pizza was so salty. It would've been an AMAZING pizza if it wasn't salty. I wouldn't recommend nor will I be ordering from here again. Maybe some people like salty pizza? I'm not sure.

Katherine H.

★★★☆☆

Dec 28, 2022

We stopped by NYNY Pizza when another place we wanted to go to closed. It's your average pizza shop and we got the meat lovers and italy pizza. Both were pretty good but very salty and greasy, especially the meat lovers. Overall, I think it was fine so if you're looking for regular pizza this is the place

David D.

★★☆☆☆

Jun 26, 2023

When you order a pizza with 4 different toppings the expectation is that each of the pieces of the pizza will have some degree of all 4 ingredients. No one expects exact measurements across the surface area but this one was a disaster. I even looked under the cheese as instructed but to no avail. Disappointing as the crust is good and when you got all the ingredients the taste was good as well.

Susan C.

★★★★★

Sep 9, 2024

This Pizza RULES. I've had a problem ordering a pizza going through the call center, but when I go to the store to order it's THE BEST AROUND. I think the call center sometimes doesn't get it right .

John S.

★★★★☆

Aug 26, 2024

Great pizza, great food! I recommend the Florentine pizza, the lasagna, and the Alfredo

New York New York Pizza

Menu

Build Your Own Pizza

Build Your Own Pizza

Gourmet Pizzas

Gourmets Pizza

1. Meat Eater Pizza

2. Buffalo Chicken Pizza

3. Grandma Pie Pizza

4. Florentine Pizza

5. Garden State and Veggie Pizza

6. New York New York White Pizza

Appetizers

Fried Mozzarella

Fried Mushroom

Fried Mac and Cheese Balls

Jalapeno Poppers

Fried Zucchini

Chicken Tenders

Meatballs

French Fries

Onion Rings

Garlic Knots

Garlic Bread

Manhattan Rolls

Seasoned French Fries with Cheese

2 Meatballs with Marinara

4 MeatBalls with Marinara

Wings

Wings

Stromboli and Calzones

Stromboli

Calzone

Salads

Garden Salad

Caesar Salad

Chef Salad

Antipasto Salad

Greek Salad

Buffalo Salad

Steak Salad

Pasta DInners

Marinara Pasta

Meatballs Pasta

Sausage Pasta

Meat Sauce Bolognese Pasta

A la Vodka Pasta

Fettuccine Alfredo Pasta

Chicken Parmiginia Pasta

Baked Pasta Dinners

Lasagna Pasta

Manicotti Pasta

Jumbo Stuffed Shells Pasta

Baked Ziti Pasta

Baked Cheese Ravioli Pasta

Pasta Combo

Eggplant Parmigiana Pasta

Baked Eggplant Florentine Pasta

Hot Oven Subs

Philly Chicken and Cheese Sub

Philly Steak and Cheese Sub

Meatball Parmigiana Sub

Sausage Parmigiana Sub

Sausage and Meatball Parmigiana Sub

Chicken Parmigiana Sub

Eggplant Parmigiana Sub

Chicken Cutlet Sub

Philly Chicken Sub

Sausage and Meatball Combo Sub

Philly Steak Sub

Cold Sub

Ham and Cheese Sub

Salami and Cheese Sub

Turkey and Cheese Sub

Italian Combo Sub

Desserts

New York Cheesecake

Cannoli

Chocolate Cake

Zeppoles