New York New York Pizza

I was shocked at how quickly this pizza was delivered to my door! Delivery Man was very pleasant too. Absolutely delicious!! The cheese was still sliding off of this piping hot, crunchy crust. I will be ordering from you again very soon! Thank you so much Sunday team for hitting the spot tonight .

Damn, man. I love this joint. I'll preface this by saying I'm an Italian from Jersey. I get it - we're in Tampa and we got lots of Cubans. But yo. Teach them fuckin English like we'd do up north. I ordered a 3 cheese calzone. See this is why you can't deal with Cubans in Tampa if you don't speak Spanish. WOMAN - 3 Cheese Calzone?ME - Yeah 3 cheese calzone. WOMAN - You want 3 cheese calzone?ME - Yeah, 3 cheese calzone. Bill was a little high but whatever. I I didn't think much of it. These morons brought me 3 three cheese calzones. Jesus Christ. When you say "3 cheese calzone" it means mozzarella, ricotta and maybe Parmesan or provolone. Come on, man. If you're gonna have Cubans making our food (and they already fucked up the Mexican), teach them what's up. You boys are sorry guidos.

Fairly late, 8:30pm or so... I finally decided to get some food. Sunday night... my favorite pizza place is closed. Remembered seeing New York New York pretty close by... so placed an order via the website. Website said ready in 30 minutes.I drove over (ten minute drive) and tried to pull in... All three parking spaces were full, lol. Yep.. three spaces. No drive thru either. So I parked at the convenience store next door. New York New York was having some work done over the door, putting up a litte roof thing to keep the rain off or something. Lots of ladders and stuff in the area. But I made it into the business.A young lady helped me and said my stromboli would be ready in about five minutes (remember the 30 minute ready time? It was 15 minutes when they are not too busy). I went and waited in my car... and she brought it out to me on time. Very good service!The aroma coming from that box had me drooling as I drove home... the garlic smelled so good! Got home, opened box... took a picture, cut it in half... took another picture.. and then ate the whole thing. There was little chunks of raw garlic falling off the crust as I ate (and yes, I picked it up and ate it... I love garlic!). Pretty good stromboli ( and they know the difference between a stromboli and a calzone too... some pizza joints are clueless that way). Good crust, fair amount of cheese and toppings, well... there was room for more, but enough. Not generous... but enough.I tried their marinara sauce and was shocked. It actually was chunky, with REAL tomatoes in it... and not overly sweet! IT WAS GOOD! So many places add too much sugar! I would eat here again!

A true New York experience, from beginning to end. In the best way possible. Called and ordered for pick up. Food was ready within 20 minutes. Pizza was really good and fresh. Garlic knots and Caesar salad also good, but nothing out of this world. We will definitely be back.

I'm a Jersey girl born and raised, and I have to admit, I'm always skeptical of places that claim the name "New York Pizza" outside of New York... I think another eyebrow raised when a friend told me it's adjacent to a gas station too. But trust and believe, this place is the real deal! That perfect crunch and thinness is exactly what I've been missing from back up north... IYKYK.I don't live in this area but I knew I had to stop in to grab a pie on the way home from my friend's house. There is nowhere to sit so make sure you order online or call ahead to bring home. I placed my order online and I was given a 30 min wait time. Casually walked in around the 25 min mark and my order just came out. I wanted a bite before my drive while it was still fresh out of the oven so I ate my slice outside of my car in the gas station parking lot.*Let it be known that the grandma slice is heaven on earth* If you had to only get one pie, get this one... You can really taste the fresh tomatoes married with the perfect pull of cheese and ending with that crispy crunchy crust. It is a true *chefs kiss* in my book, I know it would make all the Nonnas proud. I am so impressed with the quality and the staff was so down to earth. I had my 10-month old son strapped in my carrier with my hands free and ready to take my order out but the gentleman behind the counter insisted he'd carry my pies to my car. Awesome service, awesome food- I'll be sure to make my way back ASAP!

Fast ! Great customer service, and friendly employees. They are pleasant on the phone , always helpful and quick- pizza is delicious, best crust and good amount of toppings. Only a few miles from home and it's only 15 min processing time. Love this location!

I love this pizza! The place is small but I always either pick up my pizza or order delivery. My son was sleeping in the car and the staff was nice enough to bring the ex pizza out to my car.

Personally I think it's the best pizza around the area. The store itself is tiny and I'm not sure there's any seating. More of a take away joint. Garlic knots are decent but the pizza is the way to go. Usually a decent wait for orders so def call ahead to place your order.

The BEST PIZZA IN TOWN!!This is actually pizza that tastes like New York. It's worth trying at least once and you will definitely come back again and again...we do:) Friendly service great taste!!

Really great pizza came out pretty fast and nice people. brought out chairs for us to sit.