Meat Eater Pizza Pepperoni Pizza
Margarita 3. Grandma Pie Pizza with pepperoni
Meatballs
3. Grandma Pie Pizza
menu
Wings
a pizza on a platter
Menu
people walking on the sidewalk
Chefs making pizzas
two slices of pizza on paper plates
interior
Wings- They mix the flavors together if you order two flavors. I thought it would be half and half. Still good.
Pull up window for take out
pizza, outside
food, pizza
pizza, interior
Restaurant
New York New York Supreme Pizza
outside
Real tasty
Charles D.
Jan 31, 2025
I'm from Brooklyn NY and I have to say I've never had a better Ham Calzone in my life!!! This place is my go to for pizza and hero's. Keep doing what you do!!
Read More
Lissa R.
Mar 2, 2025
Always super packed and busy but service is quick and food is always fresh and yummy!
Read More
Brita R.
Jan 31, 2025
I went to New York New York Pizza when visiting Tampa. I just walked up and ordered a slice of pizza at their to-go window. The slice I got was very big and was reasonably priced, along with being very tasty! Great and fast service!! Delicious Pizza!! Definitely got to checkout this hidden gem of Tampa!!
Read More
Marquese C.
Oct 17, 2024
Food was great, great pizza and a lot of options for pizza! Service was great at the pickup window. You get your pizza fast. Ambiance was great as it's right on 7th Ave in Ybor
Read More
Jenn L.
Dec 26, 2024
As someone who's lived in NYC for almost five years, I've been on a mission to find authentic New York-style pizza outside the city--and New York New York hits the mark! This is the real deal, folks. After countless recommendations that fell short, I'm thrilled to say this spot finally delivered on the true NY pizza experience. The crust, the sauce, the fold--everything screams New York. Took me long enough to find it, but I've officially found my go-to pizza spot! 10/10!
Read More
Tharin W.
Nov 1, 2024
Fast service, fair pricing and a solid pizza flavor. I was looking for a good quick bite while walking around and this spot was perfect.
Read More
Daniel L.
Feb 18, 2025
Always a good staple. Good New York style pizza and the service is always good and the servers are fun. Definitely recommend the pizza bowl if you're not in the mood for the bread.
Read More
Jay B.
Jun 7, 2024
Came here on a whim because it was a 3 minute walk from our hotel. We anticipated it not being great but it was worse than we imagined. Food: worst meatballs I've ever had. Absolutely frozen. Had the texture of being freezer burnt. They were tough to cut through. Mozzarella sticks were fine. Obviously frozen but they always are no matter where you get them from. Garlic knots were ok. Penne vodka was definitely just the tomato sauce with some cream added to it and the pasta was gummy. Service: 2 stars for the servers. The ladies at the bar were so nice to us and super helpful. Ambiance: feels like a dive bar. Ample seating. Ok place. Can't speak on the pizza, but based on the reviews it's probably a safer choice than the entrees.
Read More
Khadija H.
Aug 24, 2024
I had one slice of the Grandma Pie and 6 hot garlic wings. Both tasted fresh and were very good. The service was also amazing from the moment I walked in to the moment I left! Great lunch stop.
Read More
Jordan B.
Dec 20, 2024
Great pizza, you'll get it on time if you placed your order back during the Stone Age
Read More