New York New York Pizza

Not a bad spot to get a slice to go. They're really quick. Pepperoni and Cheese slices are fresh. I'm a fan of their crust. Small take out shoppe with a couple tables outside to dine at.

Always order from here and tonight the pie was phenomenal! I got an extra large meat lovers. And they are not stingy with their toppings.Thanks guys!

I don't know where to start here you walk in and the pizza has been sitting out for so long and when you ask, if there's any fresh pizza, they say that the pizza is fresh the woman with the tattoos who is a little large behind the counter stinks of cigarettes Has no communication skills and frankly this place is dirty the pizza taste like garbage the place looks like garbage the people who work there look like garbage in front of the store there's garbage all over the place so dirty everything about it

Very good.I lived in NY before and pizza here are reminiscent of NYC pizza.Will def be back.

I am not a big pizza consumer because it always upset my stomach, but recently I discovered a new place called New York New York Pizza and I wanted to try it after a long time and to my surprise, I liked it very much. Curious, I wanted to know what the difference was with the other pizzas, so I asked an employee and he told me that they only use olive oil and high quality products, they make it by hand and after two and a half hours, they throw away what they haven't sold and prepare it fresh again.I think this makes A BIG DIFFERENCE.I recommend it to everyone because I know it is VERY TRUSTED.

New employee there doesn't bother to reheat when you order by the slice and she selects the highest tip option before flipping the tablet to you. Probably to take advantage of the drunk customers. Shame because I've been going here for 7 years since I live nearby. Thankfully westshore across the street is also good. On weekdays away from the "drinking hours" it's usually really good.

This is a walk in place and I walked in got 2 slices of pizza and the guy at the register dom added his own $2.00 tip I didn't authorize. I asked him the prices of the pizza he told me $7.50. Then the total came out to $9.99, so I asked him for the receipt and he added a tip for himself. So pay attention to your total if u decide to go here.

The pizza is like going back to NewYork. The best in Florida. Must have pizza when in Tampa. Service is outstanding

I love their pizza. The garlic knots are great. I don't know why more people don't go there!

I learned never to order from here on a Friday or Saturday night because that guaranteed a burnt, wrong order. But I thought a Thursday would be ok. I called up to order a pizza and was told to f*** off. Then I was hung up on. No provocation, no reason. I called back and asked to speak to a manager. I had to wait 20 minutes for a manager to call me back. I explained what happened and I still did not get an apology. The manager brought us a free pizza, but they STILL got my order wrong. It had bacon all over it and I cannot eat bacon for religious reasons. I gave the pizza back since I couldn't eat it. I now have to find a new pizza restaurant. NEVER EAT HERE.