New York New York Pizza - Carrollwood

I have been to every location times over the last decade and this one has provided the best service courtesy of Wendy. It was so good that even if I didn't like the pizza I'd be back.Got cheese and a grandmas pie. I give the cheese a five star and the grandma's pie a four star. We will be back for sure.

Great pizza, have been to this location about 3 times now and not once did they disappoint; will be back again for another delicious pizza pie!

I love their cheese pizza reminds me of New York, they have cold beers, customer service is good, plenty of parking lot and their prices are fair.

Their service is great, but their food is sub par. Have gone here a couple times because they have a gluten free pizza and my BF has celiac. I've had some slices and their eggplant grinder and both times my stomach was a mess afterwards. Likely will not return to eat there myself, but my BF thinks their GF pizza is decent, so might return for that.

If I could give 10 stars I would! Perfect NY style pizza, was hot when we picked it up & didn't have to wait long! Chicken wings were huge and crispy!! Staff friendly & accommodating, overall great food and experience! If you're in the area, NY NY is the best!!

Our go to pizza spot when we want a taste of home. The pizzas are delicious and big like real NYC pizza. They're stuffed shells are pretty good also. Don't forget to get garlic knots.

We ordered two pizzas for takeout and we're able to get the pizzas sooner than expected. The employees were super nice and gave us our order as soon as we got there. The pizza was good but a little greasy. We were expecting a true NY style pizza that was thinner but it probably had the same thickness as Papa John's.

Needed four pizzas for my Super Bowl party and Pizza Hut was sold out 4 hours before kick off. New York New York (NYX2) told me now problem, four pizzas coming up! The 18 inch pies were large, our order was accurate, and overall a good deal (about $100 after tax and tip). I fed 17 ppl and had a whole pizza left over at the end. My favorite was the supreme. The pizzas were thin, and the center was soft/ the tips of the slices were floppy. I would order from NYX2 again if I was entertaining and needed a bunch of pizzas for a good prices

Employee and website. I had a $10.00 on my account for birthday. I couldn't make it work. So today I went in store. My email they set me for birthday still had discount order on it. She would even try, the girl said sorry it's no good now. I then ordered 3 pieces of pizza. $15. I was about to throw box after she said $15. I'm on disability, I only came to use coupon. She embarrassed me and then turned on to phone and said to another customer I know the special is over but I'll still let you use it. I'm lost used to be here twice a week. Those days are over. You don't treat customers like that. I've referred allot of people here. Hate to tell them what' the place is nice now.

We ordered to go... the Florentine and Zucchini fries. The place itself is cute and the staff friendly. We reallyyyyy liked our food. The pizza was loaded with fresh ricotta and the zucchini fries were crispy and fresh. Not to mention sprinkled with Parmesan cheese! We are going to be back! Nom nom nom