Baked Ziti, bread and salad
My Calzone after cutting off the corner - good flavor even without my Spinach. On the side is their Jalapeno Poppers which we enjoyed.
Calamar
Is fried calamod and pasta Bolognese out of this world
Their homemade Pasta Fagiole Soup.
A portion of their large Stromboli, very good and very satisfying.
food, pasta
Meat loves pizza
Fantastic food hands down Grandma's Pizza
Lots of Meat and Cheese
Nice and plenty for all...
Menu one side
Burnt Garlic
Steak and Cheese
Slice of deliciousness
pizza, menu
Half pepperoni & half cheese pizza
Stromboli super with sausage,pepperoni,peppers & more
Their stromboli - delicious and filling!
Penne with meatballs
Shrimp parmigiana with penne
Their veggie pizza - not bad, I've had better!
The works minus peppers :) they ran out of mushrooms :( Delicious. Friendly staff!
Menu
Cheryl P.
Mar 1, 2025
Michael Anthony's is one of the very few restaurants near where we live that offers delivery from their restaurant not using delivery services like Door Dash or Grub Hub. This helps to save a little money and is super convenient if you're not feeling well or just want to relax and rest without cooking and cleaning up.We opted to share Michael Anthony's large Stromboli. Made with their homemade pizza dough it's stuffed with pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green bell peppers and onions plus cheese. Very tasty and satisfying. Served with a side of their homemade marinara sauce. Their sauce is very,very good. Not bitter or too sweet - it compliments their strombolis and calzones very well.We also opted this time for a cup of their daily soup choice : Pasta fagiole. Loaded with beans and vegetables in a delicious broth - it was a excellent addition to our meal. My husband who is very particular about his food was very happy with their soup. A very satisfying and filling delivery meal that cost us a total of $33.21 including a delivery fee plus a driver tip for the convenience. It's great to know we have the option of delivery in our area. We will continue to use their delivery service plus eat at their restaurant when we want good quality Italian cooking.
Read More
Sheri M.
Jan 18, 2025
Delicious food, went out of their way to serve me bread even though supplies were at The time difficult (post Milton & Helene) and delivery was was and efficient! It made me feel so much better to eat a good meal. Helped block outAll the devastation around me!
Read More
Michael P.
Jan 20, 2025
Some of the best pizza I've ever had also had the fried calamari and pasta Bolognese so delicious
Read More
Kerry S.
Feb 13, 2025
Over an hour wait on delivery. Would not of cared if it was good however the fries were greasy and cold! The chicken Philly the bread was stale and chicken was like cardboard texture and taste.
Read More
Michelle M.
Jan 20, 2025
From PA and excited to find a cheesesteak made the PA way with sauce! Plus every time my adult kids visit from NC, it's their arrival request...hot honey pizza and chicken bacon ranch pizza! Thanks for helping us fill our cravings and being our go to pizza restaurant!
Read More
Jason H.
Feb 20, 2025
All they needed to do was toast my sub . Then it's our fault. They are plenty of other options in the area. This place sucks
Read More
Toni W.
Feb 3, 2025
We ordered a pizza and calamari. You can tell the calamari had a homemade breading on it. It wasn't thick, but seasoned perfectly! The pizza....soggy! While ur was loaded either way toppings, I think it was too much for a thin crust pizza. Half of our pizza had almost a completely chopped onion on it! I think we'll head back over to Moschellos! We weren't impressed
Read More
henry k.
Dec 5, 2024
Great food great cheap lunch specials $8 for a sandwich drink and fries or onion rings Chicken parm pizza is the best ever Chicken cutlet salad is perfect
Read More
Sharen H.
Dec 3, 2024
I'm a NY Italian American. Super picky about pizza. Michael Anthony's is great by even NY standards. The crust is the best I've ever had. Very light, thin and crisp. The sauce is perfect and the cheese is top quality. It actually melts and us oh so stringy. If you love NY style pizza, this is the place for you.
Read More
Teresa P.
Jun 4, 2024
Chicken piccata was great. Will definitely return This was a take out order will enjoy leftovers for lunch
Read More