Joey's New York Pizza and Italian Restaurant
Joey's New York Pizza and Italian Restaurant
Generous portion of a side of spaghetti.
Lasagna and NOt penne
Pepperoni, Mushroom, Xtra Cheese Large Pizza
Veal Parmigiana (plentiful portion!)
pizza, food
Menu
Interior wine wall
Specials for the week
What a feast! All For $47
Plenty of parking right out front. It's in a shopping plaza so Parking is never an issue :)
Menu
Menu
Slice of pizza
pasta, food, pasta dish
Shrimp Alfredo
Inside shot
Sausage, peppers, onions, and cheese with fries
My ribeye was phat! I would guess about 3oz worth :/
Filet mignon
Chicken piccata
interior
Meatball sub with fries
Stromboli & fries
Tabatha M.
Sep 23, 2024
We did take out tonight as we were exhausted from our garage sale. The food has been mediocre for the past few times we've had it from there but this... WOW - my Chicken Marsala was amazing! The sliced garlic was a wonderful treat to discover exploding with flavor in my mouth. Full of flavor and the pasta was perfect!! 2 good size portions of chicken breast and an ample amount of pasta (I got fettuccini). It lasted me 3 meals there was so much!My husband got the Chicken Parmesan and he loved it - made perfectly - the breading was so flavorful and baked perfectly. I had a bite and loved it. There was so much it lasted for 2 meals for him. We will be back soon and we will try the Napoleon pizza again, hoping for success.
Read More
Mike K.
Feb 26, 2025
Had never been to this place before but decided to order a pizza for take out. Ordered the Neapolitan plain cheese pizza. When we got home it seemed the cheese was more "yellow" than the usual "white" we normally see on a pizza and the taste was odd. Almost as if it was a blend of mozzarella and American cheese. Is this the usual cheese this restaurant uses?
Read More
Pam K.
Feb 15, 2025
Saturday night and I'm too tired to put frozen waffles in the toaster oven! Hubby says let's go to Joeys New York Pizza and after a short wait, we could see that they were understaffed but the young crew kept it together. Cameron C, our waiter, was super! Said out of the 4 white wines listed, they had one. Told hubby out of the 4 red wines, they had one pinot noir. Decision was easy but not the best compliment to management for letting this happen. Really inexcusable! Get your wine selections up to speed, please!!!! Other than the wine thing, our food was great, Cameron did an outstanding job to keep the momentum moving! Kudos, Cameron!!!!!
Read More
Heytherelittlefella
Feb 16, 2025
The pasta was stale, the sauce felt way to salty, good ambiance, and we didn't even get forks for our salads, and food was cold compared to other people which had steaming hot food, just try better, you call this place and Italian place and the only thing they do good is pizza, just call it a pizzeria, I'm from New York and this doesn't compare.
Read More
David R.
Dec 7, 2024
That's it that's it that's it this place is officially dead , it's a dump. All amazing servers are gone, they charge fees galore , fees for extra bread after charging exorbitant price for Olive Garden quality dishes , fees for CC , even fees for switching from red sauce to white sauce on over priced dishes , and now the pizzas are now over 19 bucks for little ceaser quality pies wtf .....the last time I was there for my spouse's bday the entire table got food poisoning !!!! RUN away for this dump and take your business anywhere else buyer beware !!
Read More
Jeaux B.
Jun 27, 2024
I will most likely try this place a third time just in case today was an off day. My first time was OK; this time the food is almost inedible. I wish I was dining in so that I could send it back however, had I been dining in I probably wouldn't have received food like this. I ordered the chicken Parmesan lunch special with a Caesar salad, which by the way is also supposed to come with a drink and salad I got home and there was no salad or drink. not a problem. I called them just to let them know. They apologized and were very sweet which is why I didn't call them back to tell them how bad the chicken Parmesan was. I wasn't looking for a refund.I don't know if the chef was out, if this is a weird day, if they lost power, if a monkey came in and cooked...I'm not sure but the chicken Parmesan had the consistency and flavor as if it had been cooked three days ago after being pounded out super thin so that it would be as tough as possible Then put back in the refrigerator had some cheese thrown on it and then was thrown under the broiler to melt the cheesepart of why it seemed like it was done this way is because the last time the pasta and the chicken were all in one container and this time the pasta and chicken were in different containers, and when I was emptying out the chicken one down the garbage disposal, that's when I saw the burn marks on the aluminum foil to go container that they probably put in the oven to melt the cheese on top of the flattened disgusting chicken ParmesanDidn't realize how annoyed I wasn't until I started writing this out. OK so I only wasted $12 today but it's the point...chicken Parmesan is not hard to make. It's not hard to make good pasta, it is not hard to send home containers of not completely dried out pasta with barely sauce also with cold tasteless Garlic rolls that also had probably been made three hours earlier and left to sit and dry outOther than that, friendly staff. But I do think I now understand why this place always looks empty at lunch
Read More
Kate W.
Jun 23, 2024
One of our favorite Italian takeout spots in Palm Harbor. There's a lot of small mom and pop shops in Palm Harbor, but we can't seem to stay away from Joeys. The garlic knots here will have you in a coma, but at least you'll be happy. We generally get the chicken parm and the fettuccini Alfredo and add chicken and it is made consistently, every single time. The only thing I will mention is that if you order takeout, whatever you do, make sure as with all places that you check out your order. We've had a few times where things were missing in our order, but they fixed it fast. If you're in the area... give Joeys a try.
Read More
Cammie R.
Feb 19, 2025
I would not recommend Joeys New York Pizza here's why.I placed my order a little after 4pm.At 5pm no pizza I call and was told there was an error. They would have to make again. I would be another hour. I call hour later they say it will be delivered. The Uber driver picked it up. At 6:29 I call back Joeys New York Pizza ask where pizza is at I get hung up on. I called back to say they are getting a review. Shortly after that Uber driver calls and says he is on way. He then ask if there anything he needs to know. Then he calls a second time.Pizza is delivered. When we opened box it wasn't what we ordered.,We couldn't believe it. Wrong topping on pizza. We didn't order roast beef topping. Rating -1
Read More
Steve G.
Mar 1, 2025
Good neighborhood NE style pizza, hot sandwiches, parm's. Popular, local, Italian joint
Read More
Kelly C.
Dec 8, 2024
Good food and a terrific selection of desserts, but no coffee Overall, a good experience. I just wanted a cup of coffee with dessert after my delicious dinner.
Read More
