Joey's New York Pizza and Italian Restaurant
Joey's New York Pizza and Italian Restaurant
Salad. Shrimp parm on Friday.
CHEESE covered in GREASE with hardly any toppings inside
Coffee
Supposedly a custom dish
Menu, side one.
a box of bread
Mushy, very overcooked ziti. Yuck.
Joey's pepperoni pizza
Wing "juice"? Saturated bag and entire order
Pepperoni pizza
Italian Trio
Greek salad
Italian Sausage and Bean soup. The soup was good.
Garlic rolls
This is how my food came ... does it look appetizing? Would it entice you to come back again??? Along with grumpy servers.... I wont be back
Garlic knots
pasta, pasta dish, food
1/2 dozen of garlic rolls $2.95
Gross tiramisu
food, pancakes
Greek Salad $8.50, huge salad but presentation could use help.
food, salads, salad
Menu, side two.
oysters and mussels, oysters, mussels, shellfish, food
Tony O.
Nov 16, 2024
I'll be the first admit, I'm not really a "big" slice guy. Usually it means the place is over reaching. Though not a bad slice of football pizza, they could have made it smaller and cooked it longer. That said, the service was really good and the ambiance not so bad. All in all, a typical shopping center pizza.
Read More
Victor G.
Oct 26, 2024
Not great. No decent Italian restaurant would serve pasta so overcooked it falls apart.... far from al dente. When you can't pick up a piece of ziti without it falling apart you know you got problems. The cook either doesn't care or needs some training. The owner should try this food one of these days. Wonderful server.
Read More
Pamela N.
May 12, 2024
Fast, efficient and friendly service. Delicious food with MOXIE Flavors!!!Had the biggest Greek salad and the Pasta sauce is to die for!!!Don't even get me started on those soft garlic and buttery knots! Oh mama!!Oh yeah, my husband took me and our friend to Joeys for Mother's Day!!!!! Such a treat!
Read More
Scripture S.
Jun 10, 2024
Not sure what all the hate was about. This place was pretty good. I feel bad for the people who had a bad timeGood food, good service, and a very nice atmosphere! A lot of these reviews were questionable, but overall, not a bad spot to grab some pizza or some pasta. Pizza was definitely a little bit thicker than New York Style, but was very good. Not overcooked nor undercooked. Garlic rolls were full of flavor and they were delicious. Definitely lots of garlic so if you don't like garlic, prepared for a garlic explosion. Greek salad was absolutely bomb. Italian trio did look a little bit interesting and confusing, but definitely not 1 star material. Cassidy was awesome.Check out our YouTube video if you want to see more information on 2TRUE's Honest Review!https://youtu.be/79lPgDiB1Ug?si=34whBRssydurqNSy
Read More
Suzanne C.
Aug 8, 2023
This must not be a fun place to work ... everyone was grumpy no smiles nothing. I ordered fried calamari ... it looked like some of it slid off the plate and the marinara spilled in the process. I think .... I will just go somewhere else next time .... it did not make me feel like ... wow cant wait to come back . Left a 20% tip because I have waited tables but I have a feeling not everyone would do that . My servers name was something like Kendra .... the ink on the receipt was faint and hard to read
Read More
R A.
Dec 13, 2024
Little bit of sausage peppers and onions on a very dry roll. Had to ask for marinara to help eat it. The sub we had, Italian, really left lots to be desired. Our waitress, Ceil I believe, was super friendly and helpful
Read More
Thomas M.
Feb 18, 2024
Fantastic food. Great prices. Ginormous portions!! I'm not sure why this place only has 3.5 stars average as our experience with a table of 11 was near perfect. I had a ten inch Hero sub with sausage & peppers and opted to add mozzarella for an additional dollar. The bread was perfect not too dense. Plenty of chunks of incredible sausage and tri-colored peppers with onion. It was 9.95 with the extra cheese. You cant get a sub anywhere less than that and most are not nearly as tasty. My side of potato salad was equally good and generous in portion. The remainder ten in my party ordered a variety of food from pizza to chicken parmigiana and all were happy. The garlic knots are absolutely incredible. Marisa our waitress was extremely efficient. She was very cordial and attentive to all of us. I will be back!!!
Read More
Paige B.
Sep 1, 2024
The food was very good and flavorful. The delivery was one time and handled with care. We will definitely be ordering again. Thank you.
Read More
Alana H.
Feb 14, 2025
Do not order from this location. Absolutely terrible experience!! I ordered a pizza through grubhub only to come to find out the front desk did not check the order so when I went to pick up they had no idea I ordered. It took over an hour to make a pie. Shame
Read More
Bette R.
Feb 10, 2025
ordered trays of stuffed shells and chicken parm. The trays came with one inch mozzarell on top, could not determine what was in the trays.. thought i would be able to serve individual shells/chick parm but had to serve like you would a lasagna. looked like a mess of whatever. the cheese in; shells was disolved by the heat and ran out of shellls when cut. What a mess1 Will never order here again.
Read More
