J J Gandy's Pies

You're probably coming here for the key lime pie! You won't be disappointed! Lot of other options besides that too. Friendly people!

THE best key lime pies in the area. Need to stop by during business hours (not open later) but so worth it. They have so much more in pies, cookies and desserts...but we can't stray for the Key Lime. So good I hand flew one all the way up to Louisville for a sweet birthday surprise for family!

So disappointed closed not mentioned on website. Our go to place for thanksgiving Not sure what's going on

Inside the green warehouse style building on the southbound side of Alt-19 is a little spot of heaven!The best key lime pie outside of key west! They have other flavors as well, as well as cookies and cakes. Not a huge selection of flavors, but, definitely quality over quantity!Now, I've lived in this area for 26 years and it is hard to beat Publix Bakery, but, for Key Lime pie, this place is so worth the drive!

It's literally the best key lime pie I've ever had. I don't have a photo because by the time I think to take a pic, I've already eaten all of it

Insane that this gem is in my town! Order anything and you'll be thrilled. Order the key lime pie, pumpkin chiffon or coconut cream and you'll have gone to heaven. Order EARLY for holidays as even the best pie shop around needs a vacation every now and then. Love my town,local LQ

Stopped in for a Key Line pie. It was great and we will be back. Good folks and had an opportunity to talk with them. Very friendly.

Their key lime pie is the BEST but they also have other delicious items! They have gluten free key lime pies too!

We came here trying to get some pies for Pie Day, only to find out that they were closed as 3/14/22 happened to be a Monday. What pie shop closed on Pie Day????So yeah, don't go on Mondays, but otherwise this is a great place to get some pies, especially their famous key lime pie. They also have a gluten free version that actually tastes pretty good, not at all an inferior substitute to the original as they often are.

I have always heard wonderful things about this place so I came in for a pumpkin pie. The staff was very friendly and the price was on point but the pie was just ok. Will give it another try some other time.