The Most Scrumptious Pizza in Tampa

Original Pizza

★★★★☆ 3.8 (116) • $

"So happy I found this pizza place (and also not because I want to order from here way more than I should). I typically get a small pizza with onions and sausage and their breadsticks. Both are fantastic.This is true NY style pizza which is why I love it. If you don't like NY style pizza this probably isn't for you. If you think costco pizza is amazing then this pizza probably isn't for you. The sauce is delicious on the pizza and for breadstick dipping. It's my fav pizza place in st pete.It is unfortunate thaylt you can't order by the slice but I still think it's worth 5 stars.I order it online and pick it up. Never had any issues."

Moschello's Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.4 (107) • $$

"Best New York pizza around here, and great Italian dishes. Great service and nice dinning room to eat in!"

Noble Crust

★★★★☆ 4.3 • $$

"Went here for brunch on Saturday with my aunt. The parking lot was crazy busy no spots we had to park kind of far away but definitely worth it. My son wanted to try the beignets that were light, airy dough balls covered in a jelly and chocolate with a caramel floss to dip stuff in lots of them in the serving. I had a figgy piggy pizza that was amazing. My son had the pepperoni pizza that he said was really really good. He loves cup pepperoni and they had that. My aunt had the fried green tomato eggs, Benedict and she loved it. The other aunt had a French toast and said it was amazing. She ordered extra crispy bacon on the side and they did not disappoint with how crispy and good those tasted. The iced tea was really good. Nice flavor waitress was on top of making sure we had everything we needed. One aunt had a bloody Mary and said it was very tasty. The other had a mimosa or two and she loved them. We left very full and very satisfied. this place is hopping for their brunch can't get a reservation so it's just a wait definitely worth the 35 minutes we waited. Tables inside or not too much together plenty of room at our four top. You can see inside the kitchen, which I kinda like. Bathrooms are very clean."

Monty's Pizza

★★★★☆ 4 (124) • $

"It's my first time here and I came in during a rush after work. This place has been here 40 years and earned its reputation! I'm very impressed about everything!!!! The service kept up with my every request and I'm thankful for everything that they have done! My pizza was not thick, it was "NY"Style and flexible. The toppings were abundant and my beer never hit bottom! I will be back and they deserve a try!"

Il Forno Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆ 4.4 (9)

"Food is very good! Had a calzone and it was really tasty. Our waitress was attentive an took great care of our party of 6."

Circo Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen

★★★★☆ 4.2 (65)

"We were staying at the Marriott on TV and wanted to try something close by. We went at 6:30 on a Saturday night and were not disappointed! They were busy and after eating here we understand why. We ordered the prosciutto appetizer (delicious) and split a meat lovers pizza. The dough was perfect! The service was wonderful, very attentive. The owners Susan and Dave were lovely people. We enjoyed it so much we went back for coffee and a Breakfast sandwich the next morning. We will definitely be back!"

PJ's Brick Oven Pizza - Brooksville

★★★★☆ 4.1 (7)

"Excellent pizza and colzones, service is great,employees are friendly. Service is excellent"

Fireside Pizza Cafe

★★★★☆ 4.2 (368) • $$

"I realized that we first went to this place about 13 years ago when my daughters were young. The door is so cool. The pizza was excellent and our server was wonderful. We had a half and half pizza with one side Supremo and the other vegetarian."

Fabrica Pizza

★★★★★ 4.5 (509) • $$

"The BEST pizza in Tampa! Went into the restaurant late night after an NFL game and the service was quick and friendly. We ended up going with the MVP (perfect balance of sweet and salty, pepperonis were perfectly cooked), Buffalo Chicken (most pizzas don't have enough buffalo on it but this one was perfectly balanced, the sesame seeds added such a nice touch as well), and the Cheesy Bread (it was what you'd expect from cheese bread!)We ended up sitting outside which offered a great view of the city and helped us appreciate a rare cooler evening in Florida!"

Monster Pizza

★★★★☆ 3.8 (19)

"Great food and great service. We had the all meat pizza with the buffalo chicken wings. Will definitely recommend this for people that live here and also visitors that are in town. 5"

Pizza Haven

★★★★☆ 4.2 (117) • $$

"Got the lunch special - 2 slices of cheese and a can of soda or bottle of water. Slices are big and it's a great value for the amount of food you get. Flavor is solid for a "ny slice". Cheese has that expected tang and good cheese grease and pull. Served piping hot although not fresh made it was still good. My main complaint is that it had burnt semolina all over it which really took away from the taste and it was super floppy. You walk up to the half door to order. No searing inside although they have a couple of picnic tables outside. Staff was nice, ordering is quick and only took 5 mins to get the slices."

Capri Pizza-N-More

★★★★☆ 4.3 (98) • $

"Phone order, penne alla vodka. At last minute I requested extra sauce. Owner made it from scratch and it was Yummie. Huge portions, enough for 3 meals. Staff is friendly and obviously accommodating. My go to for neighborhood Italian."

Pita's Republic

★★★★☆ 3.7 (55) • $

"This is a very nice place to grab a quick bite to eat and be on your way. The place was clean, including the restroom. And the gyro was made quickly and fresh to order, the pita and tzatziki sauce were excellent. The place can be a bit hard to notice as it's in the corner of a large strip mall center, so be sure to watch for it. The staff was friendly and talkative in a helpful way. For something different that a burger, stop in here and get a tasty hot meal. I will eat here again, and you should give them a try if in the area."

American Pizza Oven

★★★★★ 4.5 (35)

"Visited today, loved it! Very friendly staff, great service, clean and spacious place as well!They have pizzas, burger, fries, subs, salads, appetizers. We got the large veggie pizza, cheesy bread, garlic parm and honey sriracha dipping sauces and raspberry cheese cake chimis. Everything was delicious. Great portions, would definitely recommend!"

Jay Luigi

★★★★☆ 4.4 (228) • $$

"Absolutely loved this cute little dining spot and would love to come back! The theme is so adorable with a 70s diner vibe. You order your food then go to your table which I personally don't mind but I know may be a deterrent for some families. I think it would make the perfect charming date. As for food everything was delicious and no notes on taste tbh. We started with the crispy artichoke app and the chicken parm app and both were incredible! The pasta sauce that came with it was to die for I would literally drink it. I got the sweet Jamie Kay pizza and was so full but literally couldn't leave a crumb it was delicious. I really appreciate that there are 3 levels of crust thickness you can choose from because everything is personal size. Almost everyone got pizza and enjoyed but my best friend got the fagioli pasta and really really loved it! It wasn't my personal choice of pasta but you could really tell that the pasta was made fresh and cooked perfectly al dente. This supper was paid for by her parents so I didn't get drinks but the spritz was absolutely calling my name and I wanted to tryI saw they have a brunch menu which I would love to come back to try I but I do wish they had a bottomless mimosa option instead of paying by the glass. As for service, the people here are so incredibly nice, they messed up an order and ended up fixing it and taking it off the bill. The only thing was that everyone's entrees came out at different times and my friend had her pasta and finished it before my pizza came out last but I'm definitely willing to look past it because the food was just that good!"

Neapolitan Italian Eatry

★★★★☆ 3.9 (71)

"This place is so great. The pizza dough is the best in Florida if you ask me. They filter the water 7 times which makes the dough taste so much better. The decor is just a typical small pizzeria, eclectic but cute. The service is prompt and personable. Jennifer as excellent. The mozzarella sticks are deliciousy gooey. I ordered the sausage and peppers sandwich and my friend ordered spaghetti and meatballs lunch special. The portions are huge and everything was incredible. This is a place that you could easily become a regular at. The prices are reasonable especially for your portion size."

Pizzanos Pizza and Grinderz

★★★☆☆ 2.5 (19) • $$

"Everything was spot on and amazing. Every time we order it's always great. We live in winter haven amd drive to lake wales to pick up this pizza. The chicken park grinder amd wings are amazing. Great job guys always good. Thank you"

Toppers Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.1 (7) • $

"If you want no frills, tasty pizza this is your place. The ambience is super local and chill, this establishment has been around since he late 80s. The prices were great, it was awesome to see they're an ice cream parlor as well. I can't wait to go back for some wings, they claim they are quite good."

Mariana's The Stinky Rose

★★★★☆ 3.9 (120) • $$

"This has been our local go-to since we moved here in 2022. Lately, the food has been inconsistent. Let me preface this by saying that we always prefer to patronize local businesses over chains.Two orders ago, there was a problem with the pizza we ordered. I called and spoke to a manager who took my info and offered a credit for the next order. The next order was just fine and we were all satisfied. I placed an order tonight and it was wrong. When you order a pizza, they show it to you before you take it, so I accept some responsibility. We ordered a pizza with broccoli and black olives on the whole pie and meatballs on half. When I went to pick it up, I noticed that the veggie side was bunched up and misshaped, so I was focused on that instead of the fact that the veggies should have been on the whole pie. I didn't want to make a big deal or have to wait for a new pizza on a Saturday night, so I brought it home (after giving a 20% tip on the bill).When I got home I realized that only half the pie had veggies, so I called and spoke to a manager who is giving us a partial credit. I appreciate the speedy and attentive customer service. However, when we tried to eat the pizza, the crust was so thinand floppy that we had to put it in the air fryer and still eat it with a fork and knife. You shouldn't sacrifice quality for speed.The spaghetti bolognese was basically a tray of pasta with about a 1/4 cup of sauce. This has happened multiple times and is not a nourishing meal.Again, we love to support local businesses, and we understand that sometimes things go wrong. But the inconsistency with the food is an issue, especially for the price we pay.I will give them another chance, but I'm very disappointed. I appreciate the prompt response from management but until the kitchen produces great food for the price, this restaurant is going out of our regular rotation."

Rocco's Pizza & Cafe

★★★☆☆ 3 (124) • $$

"Absolutely Delicious!Reminded me when i would eat with my Dad as a kid. The food seemed very fresh."

Villa Italia Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 4.4 (86)

"We came to Largo visiting for the holiday weekend and found this little gem the night we arrived. We were immediately greeted by the owner as we walked in. She was so friendly and inviting it was as if we were family being invited into her home. She was so accommodating and happy to serve our party of five. The pizza was delicious too! Then she offered to cook up some fresh zappoli for dessert and we couldn't resist. Everything about this place from the ambiance, to the service, to the food was top notch! We will definitely be back on our next visit!"

The Pub at Safety Harbor

★★★★☆ 3.9 (120) • $$

"This might be the most underrated pizza in Pinellas County. Maybe in all of Tampa Bay. Top 5 for sure. Highly recommend. Beautiful char on the crust yet still soft and great tooth texture. Flavors are solid. Cheese goo factor on point. Will return."

Apollo Pizza

★★★★☆ 3.6 (136) • $$

"Order a large meat lovers pizza yummy and also ordered gyro yummy we've been trying desperately different pizza places this one by far has been the best Service was great too thank you"

Little Italian Pizza

★★★★★ 4.7 (32)

"We only live a few blocks away and this place has changed so many hands it's almost unfathomable. A group of six of us stopped in on Friday night and were amazed at how different the place felt. Same decor, same tables but, it definitely had a positive upbeat atmosphere, it hasn't had in several years. We met the current owner who stopped by each table checking in and making sure patrons were satisfied. Our server was sharp, he knew the menu well, he knew what the ingredients were and he knew how things were prepared. We were a bit concerned when he took our orders because he didn't write anything down but, everything came out perfectly. He checked on us several times and made sure we had everything we needed.Our food was absolutely, spot on delicious.Sandwiches were large and filling and expertly prepared as though some little grandma was preparing them. The dinners were large and well seasoned, needing a box for leftovers. The pizza was the star of the show, thin, crispy crust with toppings edge to edge and flavor that was as robust as anything in Chicago. The sausage had that scrumptious fennel taste that distinguishes it from any other place in the country that, and the fact it's cut into squares. Having lived in Chicago over 20 years, it was an awesome experience when requesting the gahlick and the 'regano and it came out in shakers. That really seals the deal!! The only thing missing from this place compared to those in Chicago was the addition of ordering homemade creamy garlic salad dressing on the salad.All in all, this place is top notch, give it a try and tell Joe, Jack sent ya!!"

Country Pizza Italian Grill

★★★★☆ 4.2 (30)

"First time customer: real good crust and cooked perfectly! Excellent service and decent atmosphere. No draft beer but 5 types in cans - served in icy mug. IMO 7.6"

Lakeland Stadium Pizza & Italian Grill

★★★☆☆ 3.3 (35) • $$

"Ordered a small meat pie. My girlfriend ordered the lasagna. Her review is that the lasagna tasted store bought. The tomato sauce wasn't good. The meat was just ground beef. The lasagna came with two garlic knots, which were good and a side salad with fresh mozzarella. Those two were good. My review (small meat pizza) the dough looked store bought as well however it was good. The pizza was actually pretty good. I have this place three stars while my girlfriend gave it two stars. I left it a three but ultimate we will most likely not return nor recommend. My girlfriend did ask our server how the lasagna was prior to ordering it and we were told it was made in house. Also, the floors are super sticky so wear non skid shoes. The bathrooms were clean."

Roundabout Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.1 (38)

"Perfect pizza spot! Walkable from my work other wise parking would be too hectic to even try."

Pizzaissimo

★★★★★ 4.5 (68) • $$

"I randomly had a taste for pizza and this was the first place that popped up. It's about 8 minutes away from where I live so I said why not? I approached the restaurant and saw that they have a lunch special for $7.75. That's a deal. Personal pizza, one topping, and a drink. Can't beat that at all. I, however, got a personal pizza but got 4 toppings. Grilled chicken, pineapple, jalapeños, and bacon. After I ordered, it took about 8 minutes for it to be ready. I dined in, they bring it to you. Two men were working. Very nice men and helpful. It was a quiet restaurant and very pleasant. This will definitely be my go to pizza place for here on out."

Angelo's Pizzeria & Ristorante

★★★☆☆ 3.2 (94) • $$

"I'm from NY so a rarely order pizza when I am in Florida, but this pizza was good. I forgot to order the wings well done so they were a bit undercooked for my liking but that's on me until I try them again. If you like NY style pizza this will scratch the itch."

Sal's Pizza II

★★★☆☆ 3.2 (26)

"Yummy! Chicago Supreme Pizza. 1st time here and will be back againPizza was delicious. Love the crispiness, non-soggy crust."

Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.2 • $

"Great pizza spot downtown for regular and monster slices. Great prices. It's kiosk service but food comes out quick. Chill spot to sit and eat with some outdoor seating. Come check them out."

Ava

★★★☆☆ 3.3 (712) • $$

"We were a large group celebrating a friends birthday The food exceeded my expectations. Had the double filet mignon . Service was superb. Staff were super friendly. I don't usually like meat balls but the ones I had at this restaurant were surprisingly very delicious"

By The Chef Pizza

★★★★★ 5 (4)

"My friend and I stopped by today to try out a new pizza spot, and we decided to sample a variety of slices. We ordered the pepperoni with hot honey, the vodka pizza, the cacio e pepe, the classic New York slice, and the potato, bacon, and rosemary pizza. Every single one was phenomenal!Out of all the slices, the vodka pizza and the pepperoni with hot honey were my absolute favorites. The sauce on the vodka pizza was rich, flavorful, and perfectly balanced, while the hot honey on the pepperoni added just the right kick to complement the savory toppings.The potato, bacon, and rosemary pizza was also a standout. The crispy potato slices gave it a unique texture, and the combination of flavors was both unexpected and delicious.Even though it's still their soft opening, you'd never know--it felt like they've been doing this for years. The owner was there, chatting with customers and making sure everyone was enjoying their slices, which added a really nice personal touch to the experience.The space was clean, the atmosphere was lively, and there was a steady crowd while we were there. I really hope this place thrives because the food and the service were fantastic. I'll definitely be back soon!"

Giovanni's New York Pizza

★★★☆☆ 2.7 (103) • $$

"We stopped in after bowling at Incredibowl.The place is old school. Nothing fancy. Don't let that fool you. This place has great pizza. We ordered the eggplant Parmigiano pizza. Now, I like a thin crust, well done pie. I didn't ask for it, but that's how it was done, and done well. We will be back, and soon. The pizza was really well done, tasty and fresh!!"

Kc's Artisan Pizza and Wine Bar

★★★★☆ 4 (62) • $$

"This place is so good! They have the BEST ever dough, thin and crisp. The Sauce is delicious, we always order sides for our crust. The staff and keener are super and best of all they make Vegan pizzas and appetizers. The garlic knots and stuffed mushrooms are our "go-to", the house salad with homemade dressing is always hard to pass up, and the pizza's are inventive and yummy. They do seasonal pizzas as well like a pumpkin and mushroom for fall. It had capers and pumpkin seeds....really really good! So original, something I've never thought to incorporate with pizza but a very good combination."