Brothers NY Style Pizzeria
Brothers NY Style Pizzeria
a pepperoni pizza
Left: 16. TSR Pizza. (tomato Spinach Ricotta). Right: Eggplant Pizza (Eggplant parm on a pizza crust!!)
Pepperoni Pizza
Calzone with 2 Toppings
White Pizza
sushi and sashimi, menu
actual menu price now
Spaghetti with Meatballs
menu, sushi and sashimi
Mozzarella sticks
food, pizza
Brothers Supreme Pizza
White Pizza, well half a slice. So garlicky, herby, and good! Great crust.
Pepperoni pizza
sushi and sashimi, menu
food, pizza
Pepperoni Pizza, Spaghetti with Meatballs, Mozzarella Sticks
SlimBRolling U.
May 11, 2024
Great Tasting pizza . Closes thing to New York .Service was great , I give it a 8.9 out of 10 . Would definitely come back for this .
Read More
Rob L.
Aug 7, 2024
Hard pass. All the pizza might be halfway decent, I absolutely will not spend money at any establishment that charges me extra to use my debit or credit card. I will never be back.
Read More
Grant W.
Apr 19, 2024
Didn't even get to try out the pizza, walked in was instantly told there was an hour wait. No greeting, no salesmanship. Turned away immediately. At least attempt to make the situation better
Read More
John P.
Apr 5, 2024
This is a great place, if you go you have to try the BLT pizza and the salads are all good size and good prices
Read More
Cindy R.
Nov 27, 2023
Great quick lunch. A little skimpy on the cheese but you can order extra cheese. For a by the slice I would say above average for sure!
Read More
Preston B.
Mar 9, 2023
Solid pizza joint. Good crisp on crust. Well balanced. Not too greasy. Decent quality ingredients. Not a place I'd go way out of my way for but definitely would be in the carry out rotation if I lived nearby
Read More
Kristi F.
Jan 19, 2025
So good. 10/10. This is a family favorite and our go to when we are ordering pizza! Never had a bad pizza here.
Read More
Roger G.
May 5, 2024
Pizza is pretty good , Florida standards.So I decided to try a Chicken Parm hero.They call it a wedge, ok. I received one meatball chopped into little pieces on what looked like Naan Indian bread. Not the best sandwich I ever had but close to the worst. Stick to pizza if you venture here.Fountain drinks taste like crap too!
Read More
Jeri H.
Jun 28, 2024
If you happen to be local to Winter Haven or if you are just in town to visit LegoLand, be sure you get a few pies delivered to you from Brothers NY Style Pizza! Best pizza in the area! Important to note though...All the pizza restaurants in the area only deliver via GrubHub or Uber Eats! We ordered thru UberEats and had a great experience. We ordered 4 large pizzas for a "working thru lunch" business meeting and they were delivered in 30 minutes. We ordered 2 large cheese thin crust, 1 veggie pizza and 1 meat lovers. All were hot, freshly prepared and delicious! Prices were good too!
Read More
Janet D.
May 11, 2024
I was headed to a different pizza place which turned out to be closed. We found this one and are so happy we did! The pizza was excellent, service was great. Prices reasonable. We'll be back'
Read More
