Rumspringer! They made it on a toasted hoagie bread, and it was phenomenal!
Dry goods
Inside deli area is where you order your food.
food
interior
outside
Ruben!
Ruben!
Famous Rumspringer!
To-go items
The Stu
Potato Salad. Looks and taste, homemade, a little bland, could use more seasoning and spice.
drink
Deli menu
Deli menu
menu
Meat case
food
food
food
food
Rumspringer
interior
Alexandra F.
Nov 12, 2024
So glad we checked this place out! The sandwiches are super fresh and the store actually sells a lot despite it being small. We've tried the rumspringer, the cranberry turkey club, the loaded hoagie, and the stu! All were delicious! Definitely get some cheer wine to go with your sandwiches!
Read More
Beth W.
Dec 29, 2022
Did y'all know we have an Amish market in our backyard?! I stumbled upon the The Amish Country Store (Largo) and had to try the "Rumspringer Sandwich". It was amazeballs!! One of the best sandwiches I've ever had! Note to staff, as a sandwich artist, it is important to evenly distribute all sandwich ingredients to the edges of the bread. This Reuben had the majority of the ingredients piled in the middle, which left the edges dry. I rearranged myself, and it was tasty.The shop itself was stocked full of non-perishable, goods, jelly's, sauces, desserts, and lots of different sodas. We got some scrapple and fresh sausages to take home, along with their dry beef, which was on the Rumspringer and delicious! Potato salad was a little bland, but delicious. It did look homemade and could use some extra seasoning.I do wish they had more homemade foods and I started dreaming how I'd love a little place like this. I will come back here over and over for the Rumspringer sandwich! Definitely add it to your "must-try" list!
Read More
Laura H.
Jun 1, 2024
Sorry no picture, but that Rumspringa sandwich was gone before I knew it. Had purposefully avoided sandwiches with coleslaw on it my whole life. But the Rumpspringa only comes one way, no changes allowed, and they are not wrong. It is freaking delicious. And whatever that special sauce is? Yes please! I think it might be some form of mild whole grain mustard sauce possibly with a dash of garlic. And for my fellow onion avoiders, I was pleasantly surprised that I didn't even taste one, though I'm sure they were there. All in all a completely delightful & delicious find.
Read More
McKenna O.
Jun 19, 2024
Great Reuben sandwiches!!! Everything made to order. Loved the variety and the extra care they took for my kiddos food allergy!
Read More
Hernan P.
Jan 15, 2023
This is a cute little store that has a sandwich bar in the back. I ordered the Cuban sandwich (comes as is) I don't like pickles so pulled mine out. The sub was pretty good, I have had other sandwiches here and have yet to be disappointed. The service is pretty amazing and feel very homey and quaint. They sell other items in the store as well. If your in the area and want to visit a cute and different establishment give them a try.
Read More
James B.
Jun 5, 2021
You wanna mess your life up? The rumspringer sandwich is a spiritual experience. I haven't had a sandwich that was this good ever. Dried beef, turkey, bacon, coleslaw, all of that pressed. Amazing.When they aren't making sammys that will make you regret all you life choices up to this point, they also will sell you house hold goods (got a marble rolling pin for $8) and some goods you would find in PA.5/5 would recommend to a friend
Read More
Louis O.
Nov 24, 2024
I think they have one of the best Cubans around. We really like the Swiss cheese we are from Ohio and that's where it comes from, my wife likes there jams and jellies, they have Dutch loaf that comes from Ohio I can only get there
Read More
Christina S.
Jun 26, 2024
The Amish store had never failed to exceed my expectations and store experience. The store is filled with great food, snacks, and other food goods all of which I'd recommend to anyone looking for a tasty treat. The Stu sandwich made from the deli is one of my absolute favorite sandwiches in the Bay Area. I'll always come back to this store when needing a good meal and friendly atmosphere!
Read More
Barbara N.
Sep 15, 2024
I'm thrilled to have this store close by! I can buy shoe fly pie that is truly Pa. Dutch! also pickled or red beet eggs! Nothing beats some of PA Dutch foods and recipe!
Read More
Sandra S.
Apr 4, 2024
When I first found this store, I was craving something I haven't had since I left home in PA, Birch Beer and Lebanon Bologna. This delightful little gem has both of those and more! Just a short ride down the Pinellas Bike Trail, it's a great place to grab some wonderful sandwiches, or more. Keep it up, folks!
Read More