Talarico's Pizzeria

Area: Very walkable. Street parking and pay lot are both conveniently located nearby. Location is on the main street, well-lit, and with good food traffic.Interior: Inside is somewhat like a sports bar, however they welcome families (under 21) until 10pm. Inviting, comfortable with plenty of table and bar seating. Service: Came here on two different occasions, once on a weeknight evening and the second during lunch on a Saturday. Both times the service was good, just a different crowd later in the evening.Food: Pizzas were great. We ordered a full-size salad to share. Fresh, tasty and generous quantities.Overall: We enjoyed both visits and will return.

A local sports bar serving slices of pizza, as well as other items. The service was adequate; it was busy, but the servers stopped by to check on us.We sampled a variety of food. While the slices were huge, the dough was limp and overall a bit greasy. I didn't try the wings; one sibling said they were cold, the other liked the flavor. The house salad was plain iceberg lettuce with crudely chopped vegetables. The beet salad was tasty though, as were the meatballs.

The pizza slices are huge!!! Lots of cool flavors and extra points for them being named after film directors. Great service, great atmosphere, highly recommend the swine lovers slice if you're a meat lover. Their ranch is also amazing to dip the crust in. Biggest and yummy pizza slices in Seattle!

When you hear that each slice can be up to $9, you might think that this place is quite pricey, but it is in fact the opposite: each slice was gigantic and this was well worth the price. Honestly, just one slice was enough to make me full. The pizza quality itself was also quite good. I personally enjoyed the crust as it was not too chewy and crisp. The diverse pizza choices is also amazing as there should be a pizza for everyone. 5/5 just for the great pizza deal, but the servers and bartenders were also very nice and accommodating even though we came pretty close to closing.

I've been here twice in a month, and it's been awesome. All the staff is attentive AND friendly. I got the West Side pizza, 14 in(awesome price!), and the soup of the day: Marsala, mushroom, and artichoke. Both YUM! The vibe in this place is they have their regulars, and for good reason. Kayla is a sweetheart, and so is Keanu-service with a sweet smile! Angel's Envy whiskey for $13, what??? Yes please! Pricing here is super reasonable. I'm going to join the "regulars" family

Agree with many others that the pizza is subpar. It's precooked cheese pizza lacking sauce with toppings thrown on during the reheat process. This was obvious when my slice came out so quickly after being ordered.I got a piece of the Kauai pizza and while the ham had sort of melted into the cheese topping, all of the pineapple pieces were just loosely sitting on top and both toppings were tepid at best. The crust was lukewarm, barely browned, and tasted like a frozen pizza crust. While the slices are huge (about the size of two normal slices), the quality is lacking.Our server was great and kept checking in on us during a very busy night, but that wouldn't be enough for me to come back for more pizza.

I was really really hungry when I arrived at Talarico's which was recommended by someone who lives nearby and is a regular. We sat outside because I had my dog with me and were given the menu right away. But our server never came so we ended up ordering from the host. Our waiter came later to apologize and the saving grace was that the food came out super quick. We ordered the chop salad and I had a slice (yes, huge slice) of the butternut pizza Wow! I don't know what kind of sorcery they do to their crust that makes it so crispy and delicious. It has a special taste and I don't know what is but I loved it. Definitely recommend. Definitely will be back.

Giant slices, kewl bar, big TV's for watching the Mariners! What's not to like? Meatballs are great too!

We loved this place so much! This place is legit amazing. The pizza slices are giant and absolutely delish, the caesar garlic perfection, the garlic bread will appear in my dreams, the pesto penne pasta chefs kiss... We never hang in west Seattle and now we have a reason to rush back! YUM!Great service and good vibes too!!!

We ended up here on the recommendation of locals. They were not wasting our time. I ended up getting a slice of "South Street" and the mozzarella balls. Both of these things were outstanding. A couple days later, I came back and had the Chicken Parm. Which was very good. The next time I go, I'll stick with the pizza which I can hardly wait to have again. PS - beware there are multiple karaoke nights. So if you're not in the mood for that, get the pizza to go.