Supreme

While I do reserve a perfect score for places you should plan your day around. I feel this place will absolutely fit into your day or evening plans as a pit stop. Pizza: The best of its kind in West Seattle. Perhaps top 5 in the city. Drinks: They do have tap cocktails. They're balanced but just mid...it's a dive bar. Vibe: Capitol Hill / dive.Service: Fast and friendly. They seem (from what i saw) to take care of their regulars.

They have some affordable pizza that is pretty good and can also be warmed up fast. We came here during the day in between lunch and dinner and there were various pies in the display -- cheese, pepperoni, veggie, breadsticks, etc. I think they also make garlic knots upon request. I think the only thing that might be difficult with eating here was that there was very little air circulation inside the shop -- it was warm and could have used some air either more fans or the AC. But overall the $6 slices were pretty affordable and convenient.

Pizza is good. Honestly, there isn't much else to say. The slice isn't dry nor is the square, you'd think it would be dense but the square is surprisingly fluffy. It's 21+...which means it's loud but not to the point you can't have a conversation. Slices will run you a little under $6

We have no shortage of great pizza places in West Seattle, but I kinda think Supreme is my goto when I get that pizza craving. They may not have outlandish topping combos but is that really what you want? This just hits all the right notes with those big slices, and great crust.

I always seem to pop in here late at night when everything else is closed and me and my friends want to keep the party going. Great pizza by the slice. Not really a cocktail bar but you're going to do fine with the standard drinks. I think there are 1 or more video game tables? Love this place. Hits the spot.

The pizza was so very good, I've been trying to find this place on yelp to let them know. The service was a-ok, they were definitely busy when me and my friend came in to grab some slices, so I won't fault them on not getting to us super quickly. They did mess up my order, but they fixed it right away. The vibe of the place was very nice for a late night, low lighting, a game on in the background, strong drinks, and decent music. All in all a good experience, I would gladly go again just for the pizza!

When it comes to satisfying my craving for comforting pizza, Pizza Supreme is my go-to spot. Each slice is a perfect balance of indulgence and flavor, with generous portions that never disappoint. From classic combinations to inventive creations, every bite is a culinary delight. After trying nearly every flavor on the menu, I've yet to encounter one that doesn't impress. Whether you're a fan of traditional favorites or eager to explore new taste sensations, Pizza Supreme delivers an unforgettable pizza experience.In addition to their amazing pizza, their lemon pepper wings are absolutely fire.One thing to note is that slices are available for most of the day, but if you come in late at night, you might be limited in your options.

Def reminds me of New York pizza so it is good! But man, their double pep is probably the greasiest pizza I have ever eaten. Just ask for lots of napkins so you can soak up the little oil puddles in each pepperoni. Still love it. If you order online and want 1/2 and 1/2 just put that in the comments section.

* I have only had take out from this location. That being said...This is the closest to a NYC slice I've had in a long time. This straight up reminds me of Joe's in Lower Manhattan. I've been here a few times now and order a cheese and a pep each time, heated them up at home on the pizza stone, and WOW! The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, with just the right amount of chewiness. The sauce is flavorful. And the cup and char pepperonis are out of this world. The price per slice is really good too. This will be my go to from now on when I need to grab a quick slice. Looking forward to bringing some friends here to watch a game.

My visit to Supreme Pizza in West Seattle left me with a heartwarming experience I'll not soon forget. Arriving near closing time, I was disappointed to learn they had just sold their last slices. Feeling a bit bummed, (knowing this was completely on me and no fault of the staff), I asked the bartender for nearby food options.To my surprise and delight, a kind man named Dave, who works there part-time, overheard my conversation and generously offered me his slices he was planning to take home. His act of kindness truly blew me away. He wouldn't let me pay him for it, after insisting twice (He also gave me a lesson about how many times you're allowed to insist/refuse before it ends up being rude :) and if you're curious, it's two times. :D) so, we decided I'd leave a nice tip for the bartender and be on my way.As I enjoyed the delicious pizza, I thought about Dave's gesture. It's moments like this that remind me that there is good in the world and being a kind person costs us nothing (except maybe a slice of pizza). Thank you, Dave! You made my night. 10/10.